You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plan A didnt work, lets try plan A again....
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Plan A didnt work, lets try plan A again....


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Jan 20 7.44pm

The players are in their comfort zones, on nice contracts for silly money. The play is slow and sluggish, fitness levels are suspect, injuries far too many.
Total overhaul required.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Jan 20 7.46pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

You could see today,, we are crying out for a creative midfielder who could see a pass and play a pass.. like old Rooney did today...

Tight box play, slow build up and predictability in Palace play...
Yes players are tired, but teams like Derby are playing the same amount of games.

Time for Plan B & Plan C..

We’ve got an ageing squad that lacks investment and very few players who are able to travel quickly with the ball or maybe go past a player. Those that can ie Zaha, PVA, Townsend, even Schlupp are injured. Roy’s brought Pierrick in to try and address this.

The players aren’t there to have a decent plan A at the moment let alone B or C.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Jan 20 8.39pm

Palace, are not the best watch in the premier , but they are effective, 28 pts with their thin unbalanced squad is quiet an achievement .
They have probably over achieved ever since Roy, took the job. Last year it was clear the all round depth of the squad was not great, after a clear out , that squad was in need of all round improvement. What it got was anything but. A worthwhile addition to central defence, and some cover for midfield, part of which was wasted money.
The best team option Roy, has, couldn’t play its way into the top six
Under any manager, top ten maybe. But with no fullbacks, no regular scorer, and several of the best players injured, no one would want the job. Yes it’s now a hard watch, but blame the board , they haven’t given the right support to Roy, if it wasn’t his boyhood club, and probably his last big job, he probably would have done the same as previous managers, here and walked,. And who could blame him?
If he did go ,and the support from the board didn’t change, then it is the Championship, see how boring that can get in the bottom half . This is a real threat, as if it wasn’t for Roy’s organisation of what he has been left with, we are prime meat for the second tier.

 

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 06 Jan 20 9.19pm

Originally posted by lexmark87

i was at the game yesterday and i can honestly say if roys here next year i wont be we have become the most negative team in the league i go to football to be entertained totaly fed up with roys tactics and ive been supporting palace since the 70s

Me included in that. 550 quid to watch the dross at hime this season. Worse than last year, even if we have a Slightly better points tally.
Unfortunately the premier league is what most fans want, and without the personal available, we aet out every game to not lose.
Saying that the standard of the league has gone down, hence our current position.
Liverpool at home has been the only match that I feel we actually had a proper go at our opposition.
Let's see what happens.

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

Ecopalace Flag Wickham 07 Jan 20 12.53pm


Really unfair post on Roy. The problem is with the board, including Steve P, not Roy. What Roy has achieved at Palace this season is phenomenal with a tiny squad, horrendous injuries and almost no recent investment. Roy is the only thing good coming out of the club right now. Exciti g football, No, but he's keeping us in the premiership with a poor squad. Thanks Roy.

Originally posted by cpj

Good post. This is my 36th year of having a season ticket and I don't think I've ever been so bored as watching us this season. Every game is the same - we just sit back and let teams attack us - all except in the last 15 mins when Roy realises we're losing and lets us attack and then we actually look OK. We don't press teams, nobody risks having a shot from distance and subs are always like for like. I see that Roy wants 2 strikers and 2 full-backs - yet the striker we are linked with is Tosun - another failure at this level. We already have PL failures on crazy contracts - we don't need another. In any case, as someone else implied, we could sign Kane and Aguero and they wouldn't score for us because we don't create anything. Corners are a joke; we've scored I think 9 goals in 12 home league and cup games, and we've scopred 2 goals in open play in the first half in 23 games this season. Sorry, but Roy must go.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 20 1.04pm

Originally posted by Ecopalace


Really unfair post on Roy. The problem is with the board, including Steve P, not Roy. What Roy has achieved at Palace this season is phenomenal with a tiny squad, horrendous injuries and almost no recent investment. Roy is the only thing good coming out of the club right now. Exciti g football, No, but he's keeping us in the premiership with a poor squad. Thanks Roy.

Ecopalace

I concur with your sentiments lauding Roy Hodgson.
Fully deserved.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Jan 20 1.32pm

Originally posted by Ecopalace


Really unfair post on Roy. The problem is with the board, including Steve P, not Roy. What Roy has achieved at Palace this season is phenomenal with a tiny squad, horrendous injuries and almost no recent investment. Roy is the only thing good coming out of the club right now. Exciti g football, No, but he's keeping us in the premiership with a poor squad. Thanks Roy.

In the circumstances that have been in place in all the time Roy, has managed Palace, it’s ridiculous to think he should be able to please the purists , and keep the club in the top league. The best we had ,needed improvement to progress. The fact is it was not improved as a squad with depth, it was in fact left depleted, before the season even started, right now it’s barely good enough to play in the championship, that is unless managed by one of the best tacticians around.
This is Palace, I beg to differ, if anyone thinks it cannot get any more difficult to watch. It makes me shudder to think what real boredom, has been watching Palace, through my lifetime, which covers every division except the Southern league.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Jan 20 1.58pm

Those of you that say you are long standing supporters but have never been so bored / seen such dull football have obvious erased the era of Mullery, Taylor, Francis and early Freedman from your memory banks. All of which was played out at a lower level.

As for entertainment, well it depends what you are looking for. I like to see Palace be competitive in the top league in the world. I want to see the best players and the best teams. I want to see them survive in the Premier League. So I take my entertainment in seeing Palace finish mid table. Upset a few of the big clubs along the way.

Roy Hodgson can be relied upon to deliver most of the above. And that is what the present ownership's top priority is - staying in this league. When Man Utd appointed Mourinho do you think their first priority was for him to deliver attacking, exciting football - or to win trophies ? So I say again, it's about how you derive your entertainment.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dg1937 Flag 07 Jan 20 1.59pm

The football is turgid but far better than we saw when Freedman was in charge (2010/11?). Hodgson has performed wonders in the circumstances, criticism should be aimed at Board level not the manager.

 

lexmark87 Flag 07 Jan 20 3.53pm

agree we have all seen worse but this is supposed to be our golden era.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 20 4.03pm

We have been very much "Snakes and ladders" this season but I believe we have now reached our high-water mark and we will land on the snake this weekend and in all likehood a few more snakes until the end of the season.

Edited by Willo (07 Jan 2020 4.05pm)

 

cpj Flag Kent 07 Jan 20 4.27pm

Sorry, but you are saying what a great tactician Roy is! He has one plan - when that doesn't work he is lost. I go to matches to be entertained and hope we score some goals (and the opposition score less). What we are seeing every week is just dire. Yes, he's been let down by the board over signings but nobody's ordered him to play 3 DMs every game regardless of opposition.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Jan 20 4.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

We have been very much "Snakes and ladders" this season but I believe we have now reached our high-water mark and we will land on the snake this weekend and in all likehood a few more snakes until the end of the season.

Edited by Willo (07 Jan 2020 4.05pm)

Definitely ,a snake coming up, in the fixtures.
If there are no worthwhile signings, sooner than later, and the majority of injuries dealt with before the beginning of Feb, the snakes could become one huge Python, with its tail in eighteenth position.
No matter what the reasons have been, the board have been playing with fire for some time now. If none ,or little of the above happens, then ,Palace, being in the PL come May, will be because we have 28 pts in the bag. and Lady Luck smiles kindly on a regular basis.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 20 4.45pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Definitely ,a snake coming up, in the fixtures.
If there are no worthwhile signings, sooner than later, and the majority of injuries dealt with before the beginning of Feb, the snakes could become one huge Python, with its tail in eighteenth position.
No matter what the reasons have been, the board have been playing with fire for some time now. If none ,or little of the above happens, then ,Palace, being in the PL come May, will be because we have 28 pts in the bag. and Lady Luck smiles kindly on a regular basis.

Excellent.

May I humbly enquire whether you write for that weekly Croydon publication affectionately referred to on occasions as the "Adder" ?

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Jan 20 6.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

Excellent.

May I humbly enquire whether you write for that weekly Croydon publication affectionately referred to on occasions as the "Adder" ?

Nice pun,Long may that rag, continue to have its say. Sadly I don’t speak for it.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Jan 20 7.14pm

Originally posted by cpj

Good post. This is my 36th year of having a season ticket and I don't think I've ever been so bored as watching us this season. Every game is the same - we just sit back and let teams attack us - all except in the last 15 mins when Roy realises we're losing and lets us attack and then we actually look OK. We don't press teams, nobody risks having a shot from distance and subs are always like for like. I see that Roy wants 2 strikers and 2 full-backs - yet the striker we are linked with is Tosun - another failure at this level. We already have PL failures on crazy contracts - we don't need another. In any case, as someone else implied, we could sign Kane and Aguero and they wouldn't score for us because we don't create anything. Corners are a joke; we've scored I think 9 goals in 12 home league and cup games, and we've scopred 2 goals in open play in the first half in 23 games this season. Sorry, but Roy must go.

We've had scoring problems for lots of seasons, our last excellent scorer was Murray by a country mile but we have struggled to find anyone consistent in this league from day one and this has led to the problem we have now, thankfully Hodgson has organised the other end because if we he let him go we'd be relegated tomorrow.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Jan 20 7.19pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Definitely ,a snake coming up, in the fixtures.
If there are no worthwhile signings, sooner than later, and the majority of injuries dealt with before the beginning of Feb, the snakes could become one huge Python, with its tail in eighteenth position.
No matter what the reasons have been, the board have been playing with fire for some time now. If none ,or little of the above happens, then ,Palace, being in the PL come May, will be because we have 28 pts in the bag. and Lady Luck smiles kindly on a regular basis.

Defensively we have no luck because we don't need it and that has helped hugely with the points we have.
Confidence is injured the other end and we need intensive care lol

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plan A didnt work, lets try plan A again....