You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Man City vs Palace match thread
November 16 2026 5.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Man City vs Palace match thread


Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10
dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Jan 20 2.20am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

In his post-match interview, Tosun said that he (Tosun) fouled him. Just barely, but he didn't dispute the call.

Yeah but he’s the player, i am the fan so I can be biased!

Edited by dreamwaverider (19 Jan 2020 2.22am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Jan 20 2.26am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Great result, fantastic performance and another upset of the big boys. We're turning into draw specialists, that's four in a row now.

Unfortunately every silver lining does have a cloud and today's result was slightly tinged with sadness for me, as I was forced to accept that the Scousers are now definitely going to win the league :'(

They look in the dustbin for something to eat, they find a dead cat an they think its a treat, so god knows what will happen when they win the league.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Jan 20 2.29am

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Very much agreed. Shame that goal won't be counted for Zaha or Wickham.

It counted. That’s all that matters.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Jan 20 2.34am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Kouyate instead of Luka for me for now.
I always said he was good when others didn't and he is now proving it as well as being versatile.
Tosun put in a shift and scored.
Good news all over the pitch!

Fantastic for Roy. Selection choices.

 

PatrickA Flag London 19 Jan 20 9.15am

I wouldn’t swap Tomkins or Cahill for England centre backs McGuire, Stones, Keane or Mings.
Our centre halves just know how to defend , where to position themselves and how to read the game.
I also like Mcarthur in the deeper midfield role.
Luka is one paced and gives away so many free kicks in dangerous areas.
Mcarthur is busy and more mobile than Luka and seems to play more forward passes.
McCarthy looks to be a sharper tackler than Luka and again offers more energy.
An interesting selection dilemma for Hodgson and hopefully the increased competition will lead to Luka rediscovering his early form for Palace.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Jan 20 9.31am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I wouldn’t swap Tomkins or Cahill for England centre backs McGuire, Stones, Keane or Mings.
Our centre halves just know how to defend , where to position themselves and how to read the game.
I also like Mcarthur in the deeper midfield role.
Luka is one paced and gives away so many free kicks in dangerous areas.
Mcarthur is busy and more mobile than Luka and seems to play more forward passes.
McCarthy looks to be a sharper tackler than Luka and again offers more energy.
An interesting selection dilemma for Hodgson and hopefully the increased competition will lead to Luka rediscovering his early form for Palace.

I think we also have to give credit to Roy and the coaching staff, retired defenders who have worked under Roy have praised him for that aspect. That is why I think KWP would like to come to Palace.

As for Luka his form has definitely dipped but that maybe due to carrying an injury or just tiredness his work rate is excellent.


Hopefully a short rest will do him the world of good but he will have to fight his way back into the team which is never a bad thing.

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Jan 20 9.44am

I thought it was a well deserved point.

City came into the game on the back of a big win which illustrated how important organisation, concentration and shape are when playing against them. Villa lacked all three and got a hiding.

Aguero's second goal was disappointing as for once he was unmarked. To recover from that the way the team did was remarkable . For Wilf to find the strength to go on such a forceful run in the last minute of a hard game is testament to his determination especially as I suspect he's not 100% fit at the moment.

So many people on here like to have a moan about Hodgson and yet his players are going out and giving their all.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 20 10.35am

I was particularly impressed by our right side yesterday. We have Kelly and Ayew playing out of position and they did a great job, especially Ayew who ran his socks off and was dead on his feet at the finish. His defensive contribution was important to the final result.

People have to remember this is a great Man City team, playing at home and coming off some recent strong form. Really good result.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 19 Jan 20 12.14pm

Ex Premier League referee Chris Foy states that the Stones tackle on Zaha wass a definite penalty. So were we robbed? Also not mentioned at all on MoTD.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 19 Jan 20 12.22pm

Originally posted by NEILLO


So many people on here like to have a moan about Hodgson and yet his players are going out and giving their all.

At a time when we're all feeling so positive it's a shame to sound a cynical note. But when the next performance like Derby or the first half against Arsenal comes round I guarantee that this site will be awash with all the tired old criticism of Roy's tactics, poor substitutions, etc. I don't take any pleasure in saying that but in the hope that we supporters will be a bit more forgiving when things aren't going right.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 19 Jan 20 12.44pm

Thought the last 2 games were free hits and to get 2 points, great stuff. Undoubtedly yesterday was a better performance, disciplined and organised all round the park at a very tough place to visit. Tosun already making an impression and with all our injuries others really putting in a shift. Next 5 games, good chance to put some more points on the board. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 19 Jan 20 12.55pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I was particularly impressed by our right side yesterday. We have Kelly and Ayew playing out of position and they did a great job, especially Ayew who ran his socks off and was dead on his feet at the finish. His defensive contribution was important to the final result.

People have to remember this is a great Man City team, playing at home and coming off some recent strong form. Really good result.

Exactly this, Wilf had their back 4 on toast for our second, good to see Connor getting in the right positions for when the crosses are flying in.

Man City forum - Blue Moon... Fans were asking why wasn’t Wilf hacked down leading up to his cross which lead to the equaliser? Seems to be a general consensus that Wilf should openly and continually get kicked up in the air...

Look at the Stones challenge on him. Stones made no attempt to get the ball and literally shoved him over in the box...

 

Rainforest Flag London England 19 Jan 20 1.08pm

PENALTY WAS CRYSTAL CLEAR - CHRIS FOY

[Link]

Apparently, Roy said Dougie must take all the credit forTosun signing.

[Link]

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 19 Jan 20 1.40pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Exactly this, Wilf had their back 4 on toast for our second, good to see Connor getting in the right positions for when the crosses are flying in.

Man City forum - Blue Moon... Fans were asking why wasn’t Wilf hacked down leading up to his cross which lead to the equaliser? Seems to be a general consensus that Wilf should openly and continually get kicked up in the air...

Look at the Stones challenge on him. Stones made no attempt to get the ball and literally shoved him over in the box...

I feel the reason a pen wasnt given was because it looked as though zaha threw his leg out in front of stones as stones made the challenge, zaha was looking for the foul and stones intent on just stopping him, neither were looking to get the ball but zaha throwing his leg across first may have swayed the decision against us. Just my opinion

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

dg1937 Flag 19 Jan 20 1.49pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Exactly this, Wilf had their back 4 on toast for our second, good to see Connor getting in the right positions for when the crosses are flying in.

Man City forum - Blue Moon... Fans were asking why wasn’t Wilf hacked down leading up to his cross which lead to the equaliser? Seems to be a general consensus that Wilf should openly and continually get kicked up in the air...

Look at the Stones challenge on him. Stones made no attempt to get the ball and literally shoved him over in the box...

Not just their fans. Guardiola had this to say:

'the second goal is a mistake and we have to avoid it. It is not possible Zaha can run and we allow it.'

And this:

'it was a decision. It was a wrong decision and we are going to solve it and improve it. In this situation we cannot let them run in this counterattack.'

Short of saying 'hack him down before he gets in the box' I don't think that could be any clearer.

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 19 Jan 20 1.54pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Not just their fans. Guardiola had this to say:

'the second goal is a mistake and we have to avoid it. It is not possible Zaha can run and we allow it.'

And this:

'it was a decision. It was a wrong decision and we are going to solve it and improve it. In this situation we cannot let them run in this counterattack.'

Short of saying 'hack him down before he gets in the box' I don't think that could be any clearer.

I don't see how else they would stop him to be fair, annoying for us frustrating for zaha but necessary for every other team

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

dg1937 Flag 19 Jan 20 1.59pm

Maybe so but City are notorious for using professional fouls to 'break up play' and clearly it is something that is coached into them. The answer lies in firmer refereeing.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Jan 20 2.15pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Not just their fans. Guardiola had this to say:

'the second goal is a mistake and we have to avoid it. It is not possible Zaha can run and we allow it.'

And this:

'it was a decision. It was a wrong decision and we are going to solve it and improve it. In this situation we cannot let them run in this counterattack.'

Short of saying 'hack him down before he gets in the box' I don't think that could be any clearer.

Spot on.
City aren't used to defending in their own penalty area. They are used to getting the ball back somewhere in the opponents' half, often by several of their players converging on the opponent with the ball and committing little niggly fouls which often don't get picked up. if an opponent gets too close to the halfway line or into the City half, the usual practice seems to be to hack them down and take one for the team.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 19 Jan 20 3.53pm

Originally posted by Adamoc123

I don't see how else they would stop him to be fair, annoying for us frustrating for zaha but necessary for every other team

What on earth is "fair" about hacking down a player?

Hacking down should immediately be punished with a yellow - or red - card.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Jan 20 9.14pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


It hopefully leaves him thinking hard about not making stupid f@cking tackles and having unnecessary afters with players which get you sent off.

As our captain he should be leading more by example.

This may make him sit up and realise that if he keeps picking up cards then he could become a squad player.

Good player Luca, but in my option he’s no better or worse than the lads who played today.

Terrific result.

Yes, temperamental he is and in a position where you definitely do not want a temperamental to be, much much better without.

 

Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Man City vs Palace match thread