This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Kelly and Ward both try their hardest every game but seems neither is PL quality. Not replacing AWB has left us exposed down the right and every opponent knows this. If we don't get an upgrade RB this window looks like a less enjoyable second half of the season. I disagree re Ward. I think Joel Ward was having a good season until his injury. Kelly did well for the first few games but ultimately started to struggle. We need a proper back up / competition for the position. The fact that the club trousered £50m and then failed to do so is bewildering.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
We should get a new rb yes, possibly of an age where he can improve and become a regular for the future, that's for sure.
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
wrong expectation. the other teams have a) been studying us all season and now know our weaknesses better, b) all other teams below and around us have worked to improve their squads or managers. if we dont fix right back, chances are we aregoing down. thank me later. Originally posted by Ian-VI
We should get a new rb yes, possibly of an age where he can improve and become a regular for the future, that's for sure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I disagree re Ward. I think Joel Ward was having a good season until his injury. Kelly did well for the first few games but ultimately started to struggle. We need a proper back up / competition for the position. The fact that the club trousered £50m and then failed to do so is bewildering. The club did not trouser £50m. That money is not available for a number of reasons. Firstly, I don't think we've been making too much profit every season with our sizeable wage bill, so much of that cash will offset deficits. This is obvious and the hierarchy understands the need to spend, but it is still a factor. The club is also planning to upgrade the academy to Grade 1 status and the plans look pretty ambitious with a fair bit of funding required. Also, our approach is tentative because in this day and age clubs can hold us to ransom for their best players (we did the same with AWB). The strategy is complicated I would imagine and would involve careful scouting to minimise the risk of forking out for a flop. A decent England U21 right back in the Championship could go for upwards of £20m and not cut it in the Premier League.
I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry. |
|
|
We always have to have no players to cover in at least one position - it's the Palace way.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles
The club did not trouser £50m. That money is not available for a number of reasons. Firstly, I don't think we've been making too much profit every season with our sizeable wage bill, so much of that cash will offset deficits. This is obvious and the hierarchy understands the need to spend, but it is still a factor. The club is also planning to upgrade the academy to Grade 1 status and the plans look pretty ambitious with a fair bit of funding required. Also, our approach is tentative because in this day and age clubs can hold us to ransom for their best players (we did the same with AWB). The strategy is complicated I would imagine and would involve careful scouting to minimise the risk of forking out for a flop. A decent England U21 right back in the Championship could go for upwards of £20m and not cut it in the Premier League.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I disagree re Ward. I think Joel Ward was having a good season until his injury. Kelly did well for the first few games but ultimately started to struggle. We need a proper back up / competition for the position. The fact that the club trousered £50m and then failed to do so is bewildering. Yes Ward was playing well. He did take some time to get back to near his best after his previous injury, however, he hasn't been out too long this time and hopefully he will be up to speed soon.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles
The club did not trouser £50m. That money is not available for a number of reasons. Firstly, I don't think we've been making too much profit every season with our sizeable wage bill, so much of that cash will offset deficits. This is obvious and the hierarchy understands the need to spend, but it is still a factor. The club is also planning to upgrade the academy to Grade 1 status and the plans look pretty ambitious with a fair bit of funding required. Also, our approach is tentative because in this day and age clubs can hold us to ransom for their best players (we did the same with AWB). The strategy is complicated I would imagine and would involve careful scouting to minimise the risk of forking out for a flop. A decent England U21 right back in the Championship could go for upwards of £20m and not cut it in the Premier League. The club didn't have £50m to spend from AWB sales as you say, an element of the fee was used to buy Martin Longs shares and repay directors loans.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I disagree re Ward. I think Joel Ward was having a good season until his injury. Kelly did well for the first few games but ultimately started to struggle. We need a proper back up / competition for the position. The fact that the club trousered £50m and then failed to do so is bewildering. I agree, We didn’t miss AWB till Ward got injured.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I agree, We didn’t miss AWB till Ward got injured. And then he did, illustrating the paucity of available options...
|
|
|
Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles
The club did not trouser £50m. That money is not available for a number of reasons. Firstly, I don't think we've been making too much profit every season with our sizeable wage bill, so much of that cash will offset deficits. This is obvious and the hierarchy understands the need to spend, but it is still a factor. The club is also planning to upgrade the academy to Grade 1 status and the plans look pretty ambitious with a fair bit of funding required. Also, our approach is tentative because in this day and age clubs can hold us to ransom for their best players (we did the same with AWB). The strategy is complicated I would imagine and would involve careful scouting to minimise the risk of forking out for a flop. A decent England U21 right back in the Championship could go for upwards of £20m and not cut it in the Premier League. I know all about the Academy plans thanks and have written about them on HOL a number of times. However the club did receive ( if you prefer that term ) £50m and then failed to secure specialist back up at right back. I think you will find the manager had referred to this as an issue on more than one occasion. And I’m not buying your “ holding to ransom “ theory and you shouldn’t be selling it. Most clubs don’t sell before they have lined up replacements. Palace’s strategy is more about chancing it and hoping ( in this case ) Ward didn’t get injured. They got caught out.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Clearly I am in the minority regarding Ward. Depends if you consider Ward playing well is " premiership quality " which I accept is a loose term. In terms of defending and tackling I would suggest that a fit on form Ward would be possibly half as effective as a fit on form AWB , if that is true then it's a substantial reduction in defending capability. It's an opinion only I fully agree. Ward can be described as "Premier League quality" only using it as a broad term for mediocrity Edited by mattteo (27 Jan 2020 1.11pm)
|
|
|
Ward is not a top Premier League right back, but is a Premier level right back, because if I look at Femenia or Elmohamady or Lowton or Byram or some other right back in the league, I think he can stay in that group without shame... Edited by Ian-VI (27 Jan 2020 1.47pm)
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I may be in the minority here but I would rather have an average right back (and IMO Ward is just that, a good solid player, but nothing more) and have the money to spend on a quality winger who could light up that side of the field and cause the opposition such problems that they have little opportunity to expose Ward. Carrasco may be the answer to this, someone like Sarr, perhaps others. A lack of a natural wide replacement for Townsend has caused as many problems as a lack of RB replacement for Ward. Ideally, of course get both, but if I was given a choice I would get a winger in this window. I think this is a valid point despite your hesitation. Ideally we'd have both but given the quite good possibility we have neither I am more inclined to bringing in some attacking reinforcement. We hardly create anything and barely score and are only surviving on being able to keep the game tight. Without sweeping changes we will stay the same so extra firepower up front would certainly improve us better than another defender.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
If the other owners wanted to buy out Long they should have done it with their own funds, injecting more money into the club, not with the AWB proceeds. Originally posted by Painter
The club didn't have £50m to spend from AWB sales as you say, an element of the fee was used to buy Martin Longs shares and repay directors loans.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.