You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Next 18 months
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Next 18 months


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Mar 21 3.39pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

It’s a rather damning indictment of the rest of the team that Schlupp, Zaha and McArthur out means we go from being a competitive side to one which barely leaves its own half even though we have just spent £16m-£20m on Eze and looking to spend a similar amount on Mateta and having taken one of Belgium’s top strikers on loan.

If this is the case why has our recent transfer business been in none of the positions where we are currently desperately short?


That’s something that has had me wondering. We bypassed Gallagher, for Bats. When the midfield was crying out for that type of mid fielder.
I wonder if the Mateta, deal was almost done in the summer, and failed to complete, panic , lead to Bats, and the Gallagher deal , was dropped. January ,and Mateta, completes. It may have not been if Bats , was doing the job, he isn’t.
It’s deeper than that though in so much as , it would still seem to be a case of one or the other, not just because we couldn’t have two from one club, but more we couldn’t have two.
They must know we need far more punch in that mid field, it must be we can’t afford it . Eze, is a very promising talent, he is one that you would like to see let off the leash a bit. But he is going to become a liability unless they put people round him that can clean up his mishaps. It needs investment.

 

PatrickA Flag London 02 Mar 21 3.48pm

This is 100% how I see it.
We are very easy to stop as set up currently.
I’m amused by commentators who talk of our counter attacking strength and pace on the break, in particular in the absence of Schlupp and Zaha.
I hope we’ll be seeking to address the lack of pace and energy in the next windows.

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Because of the way we are setting up with a low block when we get the ball the players are too close to each other and there is little opportunity to stretch the opposition. This means we either look for a quick break with one or two players carrying the ball 50+-yards upfield, we hit it long in hope, or we end up passing sideways and backwards until the opposition has had plenty of time to recover and get men behind the ball. The opposition also know that they can simply foul Eze, Andros or Ayew inside our own half to limit any threat on the counter. It might be crude, but it seems highly effective and something we often have no answer to.

If we had a big man up top who could make the ball stick this could help us get out, but we do have a severe lack of pace meaning there is often a huge gap between the forward(s) and the midfield (again due to the low block). There also seems to be a distinct lack of movement when we are in possession meaning our more creative players often end up going backwards due to a lack of options. This is one of the most significant things that goes missing when Wilf is out, as he goes looking for the ball and looks for the best ways to link things up.

It's difficult as when we were a bit more expansive for a few games we conceded a lot of goals and looked so open. Probably the most important area we need to look at for next season is adding pace through the middle both in defence and midfield as until we do that we will struggle to play higher up the pitch without being exposed.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 21 3.54pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Because of the way we are setting up with a low block when we get the ball the players are too close to each other and there is little opportunity to stretch the opposition. This means we either look for a quick break with one or two players carrying the ball 50+-yards upfield, we hit it long in hope, or we end up passing sideways and backwards until the opposition has had plenty of time to recover and get men behind the ball. The opposition also know that they can simply foul Eze, Andros or Ayew inside our own half to limit any threat on the counter. It might be crude, but it seems highly effective and something we often have no answer to.

If we had a big man up top who could make the ball stick this could help us get out, but we do have a severe lack of pace meaning there is often a huge gap between the forward(s) and the midfield (again due to the low block). There also seems to be a distinct lack of movement when we are in possession meaning our more creative players often end up going backwards due to a lack of options. This is one of the most significant things that goes missing when Wilf is out, as he goes looking for the ball and looks for the best ways to link things up.

It's difficult as when we were a bit more expansive for a few games we conceded a lot of goals and looked so open. Probably the most important area we need to look at for next season is adding pace through the middle both in defence and midfield as until we do that we will struggle to play higher up the pitch without being exposed.


Indeed, on Sunday one pundit/commentator compared our players to statues when our player on the ball was looking for options. Occasionally, we spring into action and play half a dozen quick and mesmerizing passes that totally bamboozle the opposition (last seen when Eze scored against Wolves). but those occasions are rare and when Wilf isn't playing they are non-existent.

Tend to agree with the rest of your post as well.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 02 Mar 21 3.55pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

What seems to stand out for me is lack of planning to have so many contracts expiring simultaneously.
It has the distinct look of a disaster waiting to happen.

There seem to be many players we'd like to lose but will have to offer new contracts to.

I hope that it's an opportunity to blood some youngsters into the squad (some hope).

I think it'll need some careful and inspired management to come out the other side with a decent squad.

or, it is part of the masterplan to overhaul the squad, and there's some bigger picture stuff happening behind the scenes, which will see a cash injection, new manager, and that new manager bringing some signings from his previous club to help bed in the new positive style of football. We can dream right?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Mar 21 4.09pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

or, it is part of the masterplan to overhaul the squad, and there's some bigger picture stuff happening behind the scenes, which will see a cash injection, new manager, and that new manager bringing some signings from his previous club to help bed in the new positive style of football. We can dream right?

Bloody hell, that’s a positive vibe we would all love to share. Maybe we are all too cynical having supported Palace for years, but you know as do the rest of us, what you are saying is unlikely to happen.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Mar 21 4.17pm

Originally posted by doombear


Indeed, on Sunday one pundit/commentator compared our players to statues when our player on the ball was looking for options. Occasionally, we spring into action and play half a dozen quick and mesmerizing passes that totally bamboozle the opposition (last seen when Eze scored against Wolves). but those occasions are rare and when Wilf isn't playing they are non-existent.

Tend to agree with the rest of your post as well.

That's the frustrating part as it shows we are capable of passing our way through an opposing team. We have some very skilful players in Eze, Jairo, Ayew, and most notably Wilf, while players like PvA and Schlupp are very adept at finding space in behind defences; however, as you say, these brief glimpses are becoming less frequent as time goes by.

Having watched Gallagher a few times recently I'm becoming increasingly convinced we should move for him. He looks like a young McArthur, with speed, tenacity and a willingness to work hard at both ends of the pitch. Doesn't really look suited to a top 6 club as he's more of a scrapper, but definitely looks like a player who would fit in with us.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Mar 21 4.26pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

That's the frustrating part as it shows we are capable of passing our way through an opposing team. We have some very skilful players in Eze, Jairo, Ayew, and most notably Wilf, while players like PvA and Schlupp are very adept at finding space in behind defences; however, as you say, these brief glimpses are becoming less frequent as time goes by.

Having watched Gallagher a few times recently I'm becoming increasingly convinced we should move for him. He looks like a young McArthur, with speed, tenacity and a willingness to work hard at both ends of the pitch. Doesn't really look suited to a top 6 club as he's more of a scrapper, but definitely looks like a player who would fit in with us.

He gets booked a lot, but I don’t mind that, it shows he’s, as you said, a scrapper. I reckon he’ll cost about £16m- £18m and I’m not sure we have that for one player.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Mar 21 4.26pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Because of the way we are setting up with a low block when we get the ball the players are too close to each other and there is little opportunity to stretch the opposition. This means we either look for a quick break with one or two players carrying the ball 50+-yards upfield, we hit it long in hope, or we end up passing sideways and backwards until the opposition has had plenty of time to recover and get men behind the ball. The opposition also know that they can simply foul Eze, Andros or Ayew inside our own half to limit any threat on the counter. It might be crude, but it seems highly effective and something we often have no answer to.

If we had a big man up top who could make the ball stick this could help us get out, but we do have a severe lack of pace meaning there is often a huge gap between the forward(s) and the midfield (again due to the low block). There also seems to be a distinct lack of movement when we are in possession meaning our more creative players often end up going backwards due to a lack of options. This is one of the most significant things that goes missing when Wilf is out, as he goes looking for the ball and looks for the best ways to link things up.

It's difficult as when we were a bit more expansive for a few games we conceded a lot of goals and looked so open. Probably the most important area we need to look at for next season is adding pace through the middle both in defence and midfield as until we do that we will struggle to play higher up the pitch without being exposed.

That about sums it up. The only thing I would add is that your last sentence , tells why using a low block has been used so often. We have been exposed to often this year particularly. Not just of late. The Villa, game comes to mind.
It is true the play does become very condensed in a low block, but it is only a partial excuse, the players do need that bit of composure , quality to cope well. In the Brighton game I could not count how many times after much chasing shadows, the ball came freely to one of our mid fielders, and they couldn’t make the first simple pass which was on, let alone take part in something more expansive. When it comes to good offensive football it is so much reliant on movement , but it has to be movement in every direction for every purpose. Only if you have that can you not get exposed.
It’s been said many times here , it does need stirring up, it’s a four or five player job as I see it throughout defence, middle, up front remains to be seen, and might improve if the rest is sorted.

 

est1905 Flag 02 Mar 21 5.47pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

In 18 months we will be in the Championship with a 10 point deduction after going into administration.

The Americans will not support now let alone if we are outside the Prem...

Tripe,
The Americans loaned the club money to see us through the pandemic. They have also put far more in than Parish has ever done.
Parish got a quarter of the club (and ground) for a fraction of what he'd have paid if it wasn't in administration, his share of the investment while outside the Prem was 100k a year. Once we were promoted not only has he not put a penny in but he is now drawing a salary. I dont really have an opinion on the rights and wrongs of that nor do I care but dont spout rubbish that the Americans dont support the club. Financially speaking the Americans have supported the club more than Parish ever did!

 

AERO Flag 02 Mar 21 5.49pm

Stand to be corrected but thought the main reason for American investment was for ground improvements .

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Mar 21 6.14pm

Originally posted by Putitout


This is the point that the Roy, out, people conveniently overlook .when he has had the players able to carry it off he doesn’t send sides out to not get at the opposition at every opportunity.
The fact is if we have just two or three key players missing at any one time our attacking options are drastically reduced. There is little doubt we need more out of what’s available in respect of attacking play. It’s never not asked for or not wanted.
From a managerial point of view it’s lucky he can get a good effort rate out of them most times. And they know how not to lose to often.


The point that the roy in people conveniently overlook, is that when you have Benteke, ayew, Townsend,eze, and PVA on the pitch, at home, against a team 3rd from bottom, not having a shot on target the whole game, is just not acceptable. Neither is leaving your latest signing who scored a wonder goal last game on the bench the whole game, because benteke defends better.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Mar 21 6.27pm

Originally posted by spartakev2


The point that the roy in people conveniently overlook, is that when you have Benteke, ayew, Townsend,eze, and PVA on the pitch, at home, against a team 3rd from bottom, not having a shot on target the whole game, is just not acceptable. Neither is leaving your latest signing who scored a wonder goal last game on the bench the whole game, because benteke defends better.


If you want to ignore that it’s the players that took on Fulham’s players, and that players can not always do what’s needed in any game. Then I suppose you are only left with having a go at the manager who can only adapt what they are best at if they are going to get any sort of result out of any game.
There was no point in bringing Mateta, on if the rest of the side were not doing enough to help his game. So it follows if he wasn’t going to help their game there wasn’t a change to make.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 02 Mar 21 6.41pm

Originally posted by est1905

Tripe,
The Americans loaned the club money to see us through the pandemic. They have also put far more in than Parish has ever done.
Parish got a quarter of the club (and ground) for a fraction of what he'd have paid if it wasn't in administration, his share of the investment while outside the Prem was 100k a year. Once we were promoted not only has he not put a penny in but he is now drawing a salary. I dont really have an opinion on the rights and wrongs of that nor do I care but dont spout rubbish that the Americans dont support the club. Financially speaking the Americans have supported the club more than Parish ever did!


100% agree I was going to post something like this myself you beat me to it.

SP has taken way more out compared to what he ever put in now some will say regarding salary he worked for that but lets not forget he has other sub companies linked to Palace which are also taking out millions.

This is the thing so many blind fans they see what they want to see and discard everything else.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Mar 21 6.42pm

Originally posted by Putitout


If you want to ignore that it’s the players that took on Fulham’s players, and that players can not always do what’s needed in any game. Then I suppose you are only left with having a go at the manager who can only adapt what they are best at if they are going to get any sort of result out of any game.
There was no point in bringing Mateta, on if the rest of the side were not doing enough to help his game. So it follows if he wasn’t going to help their game there wasn’t a change to make.

What a load of cobblers

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 21 7.12pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

That's the frustrating part as it shows we are capable of passing our way through an opposing team. We have some very skilful players in Eze, Jairo, Ayew, and most notably Wilf, while players like PvA and Schlupp are very adept at finding space in behind defences; however, as you say, these brief glimpses are becoming less frequent as time goes by.

Having watched Gallagher a few times recently I'm becoming increasingly convinced we should move for him. He looks like a young McArthur, with speed, tenacity and a willingness to work hard at both ends of the pitch. Doesn't really look suited to a top 6 club as he's more of a scrapper, but definitely looks like a player who would fit in with us.


Absolutely and such a shame we took that last minute decision to dump him for Batshuayi. He could have made a big difference in our midfield. I hope we haven't lost the opportunity to get him next season. I fear we might have since we've hardly played Batshuayi this season (not that he's covered himself with glory when he has played). I'm not sure how Chelsea will react to his lack of game time. They were probably hoping we'd take him off their hands at the end of this season.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 21 7.21pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

What a load of cobblers


Sorry but I'm with Putitout on this one and I'm neither a Roy In or Roy Out person. Our players on the pitch weren't able to cope with the Fulham press . There weren't any midfielders on our bench who were likely to change that and Mateta needs service to feet to do his best work. If he wasn't going to get, why bring him on? With Sclupp back and Wilf nearly back, things will change.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Mar 21 9.16pm

Originally posted by doombear


Sorry but I'm with Putitout on this one and I'm neither a Roy In or Roy Out person. Our players on the pitch weren't able to cope with the Fulham press . There weren't any midfielders on our bench who were likely to change that and Mateta needs service to feet to do his best work. If he wasn't going to get, why bring him on? With Sclupp back and Wilf nearly back, things will change.

To say mateta wouldn't get the service he needs so don't bring him on is ridiculous. He had one chance against Brighton and scored a great goal. Who's to say he wouldn't have done the same against Fulham. At 0-0 surely worth a chance.

 

Den1923 Flag 04 Mar 21 2.54pm

Originally posted by est1905

Tripe,
The Americans loaned the club money to see us through the pandemic. They have also put far more in than Parish has ever done.
Parish got a quarter of the club (and ground) for a fraction of what he'd have paid if it wasn't in administration, his share of the investment while outside the Prem was 100k a year. Once we were promoted not only has he not put a penny in but he is now drawing a salary. I dont really have an opinion on the rights and wrongs of that nor do I care but dont spout rubbish that the Americans dont support the club. Financially speaking the Americans have supported the club more than Parish ever did!


[Link]

The Americans clearly want to sell the club and therefore are unlikely to want to invest anymore for the future. Clearly if the article is correct then their original investment was for improvements to the ground and was supposedly ring fenced for that purpose. The bank charge on the stadium was paid off partly in 2015 and finally in 2018 through a separate holding company owned jointly by Parish and the Americans. The club has invested little in players since Roy arrived and their transfer dealings ins and outs is in profit as Roy said yesterday in his post match interview. Why the club have allowed circa 12 key players contracts to run down without investing in our future is a mystery, clearly this summer providing we survive which seems more likely now but as yet not guaranteed then a big shift in direction has to happen and they last time that happened under FdV we all experience had a glimpse of what could happen.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 04 Mar 21 4.31pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Forget the midfield, the squad containing Cabaye & Loftus Cheek was different class to what we have now. Primarily because it was a lot younger & has had very limited investment since then. This is evidenced in the performances under Roy in his first season at the club which were, at times, very good & disprove the notion that he is just another Big Sam or Pulis.

Cabaye was in his last season with us when we signed RLC, he was on his last legs and was subbed at c65 minutes almost every game that season.

In that midfield was also Luka and Jimmy Mac, neither of whom are blessed with great speed.

RLC was played out of position too on the left to keep a solid 442 as we know Roy likes this.

I don't think it's as simple as saying our midfield is a few years older, although that is a factor. The biggest factor appears to be the lack of movement - how often do we have promising possession in the opposition half and then pass back into our own half and eventually pass back to the keeper?

Then there is the speed - a one paced build up is so much easier to defend against as Man U demonstrated yesterday. I thought we handled them quite well, partly as their build up play was so slow.

RLC if fit would be a great addition and Gallagher would add energy. However, if we do not pass and move and remain one paced nothing will change.

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Next 18 months