You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brighton vs Palace Match Thread


Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 20 11.09pm

Originally posted by Numbers Man

RH is still reluctant to use subs for some reason. Players looking tired or below par should be replaced and subs should be used to initiate changes in tactics. For example Ayew looked tired towards the end of the game and could have been replaced by Townsend. James McArthur covers every blade of grass on the pitch and should be protected for future games by either being substituted or rested for future games.

He did look rather weary in the latter part of the game and thought he might be replaced.
I was somewhat surprised that Riedewald got the nod over Milivojevic.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 01 Mar 20 11.51pm

Originally posted by Numbers Man

RH is still reluctant to use subs for some reason. Players looking tired or below par should be replaced and subs should be used to initiate changes in tactics. For example Ayew looked tired towards the end of the game and could have been replaced by Townsend. James McArthur covers every blade of grass on the pitch and should be protected for future games by either being substituted or rested for future games.

And if Townsend had come on and given away a stupid free kick or mistake that lead to them equalizing , a la some of Pardew's late subs ? That would've been wrong and people would say Ayew should not have gone.
It's easy to make things up and speculate when it's not your job , we won , the manager got it right, that is what's important.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 20 8.13am

Originally posted by Willo

He did look rather weary in the latter part of the game and thought he might be replaced.
I was somewhat surprised that Riedewald got the nod over Milivojevic.[/quote]

Roy said that although Luka was on the bench, he didn't feel he would be able to do a full 45 mins, hence the Jairo option.

 

Den1923 Flag 02 Mar 20 8.29am

Originally posted by Willo

He has scored 5 PL goals in his last 66 appearances and only 1 since last April.
But he did make an exquisite pass to Ayew for the goal.
I would not give him a rating of 8 but he did play his part in our wonderful victory.

would not disagree with any of that Willo, great all round performance but Cahill was the outstanding player ON THE DAY!

 

Den1923 Flag 02 Mar 20 8.33am

Originally posted by BM

It astonishes me that people can’t see how valuable Benteke is. Yes, he’s not scoring enough but everything else he does is brilliant. Wins headers, not least when we are defending corners, holds the ball up and offers us an option to go long. Someone called his ball to Ayew a lucky pass. He looked up, saw Ayewwas free and stuck it on a plate. Assist of the season. Meanwhile, I saw a poll on Twitter last night claiming Van Aanholt had played better than Benteke. Beyond belief.

He was bought in to score goals and on that point he has failed and is certainly not worth his 130K/per week!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Mar 20 9.24am

Originally posted by Numbers Man

RH is still reluctant to use subs for some reason. Players looking tired or below par should be replaced and subs should be used to initiate changes in tactics. For example Ayew looked tired towards the end of the game and could have been replaced by Townsend. James McArthur covers every blade of grass on the pitch and should be protected for future games by either being substituted or rested for future games.

We get a famous victory away at our biggest rivals and you have to criticise the manager - unbelievable.

Townsend has hardly played for the last 3 months, but you would chuck him into a feisty derby game, upset the balance of the team and then probably be the first to moan if that didn't work out.

As for Jimmy Mac, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. You are advocating the use of subs for the sake of it on this occasion.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

EddieMac Flag 02 Mar 20 9.26am

Originally posted by NEILLO

We get a famous victory away at our biggest rivals and you have to criticise the manager - unbelievable.

Townsend has hardly played for the last 3 months, but you would chuck him into a feisty derby game, upset the balance of the team and then probably be the first to moan if that didn't work out.

As for Jimmy Mac, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. You are advocating the use of subs for the sake of it on this occasion.

Well said Neillo. I don’t understand what a lot of people on here want. We had a game plan and won the game, everyone should be delighted.

 

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 02 Mar 20 8.41pm

It is a squad game if the substitutes are not introduced then when they are really needed they won’t be ready. This seems to have been overlooked by some comments.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 20 9.49pm

Originally posted by Numbers Man

It is a squad game if the substitutes are not introduced then when they are really needed they won’t be ready. This seems to have been overlooked by some comments.


I agree in that we should be operating a proper 14 man system in which players expect that substitutions will be made. But we know that's not really happening.
However, Brighton was very much a one-off. Jairo had to come on for the whole of the second half because of injury to McCarthy. It's usually best to keep one sub up your sleeve for the last few minutes to use up some time or cover unforeseen circumstances (late injury/sending off). It was then a question of should we really change personnel given the intensity of the second half and we know that RH tends to be cautious? and so, if it's not broken don't fix it.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 03 Mar 20 12.32am

Agree with this

Apart from using up a few seconds no need for subs in that game IMHO

Originally posted by NEILLO

We get a famous victory away at our biggest rivals and you have to criticise the manager - unbelievable.

Townsend has hardly played for the last 3 months, but you would chuck him into a feisty derby game, upset the balance of the team and then probably be the first to moan if that didn't work out.

As for Jimmy Mac, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. You are advocating the use of subs for the sake of it on this occasion.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Melbourne Eagle Flag Melbourne 03 Mar 20 2.48am

Originally posted by Numbers Man

RH is still reluctant to use subs for some reason. Players looking tired or below par should be replaced and subs should be used to initiate changes in tactics. For example Ayew looked tired towards the end of the game and could have been replaced by Townsend. James McArthur covers every blade of grass on the pitch and should be protected for future games by either being substituted or rested for future games.

Weary players become more susceptible to injury and so do players substituted into the game who lack match fitness.....a double edged sword.

 

EddieMac Flag 03 Mar 20 6.33am

Originally posted by Numbers Man

It is a squad game if the substitutes are not introduced then when they are really needed they won’t be ready. This seems to have been overlooked by some comments.

If we lost you may have a point but in this instance we won and that is all that matters.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Mar 20 8.00am

Originally posted by Numbers Man

It is a squad game if the substitutes are not introduced then when they are really needed they won’t be ready. This seems to have been overlooked by some comments.

So you are advocating the use of subs for the sake of it.

Managers do it to run the clock down yes, but otherwise you make no sense.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 03 Mar 20 9.12am

And one could argue that Reidewald looked all over the place when he came on for the first 10/15 mins. So I agree that in this instance that Roy made the correct decisions and we won.
At some point all those that have been quick to criticise Roy this season will have to sit down and eat a huge slice of humble pie.

 

Lucky Star Flag Horley 03 Mar 20 1.45pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'German Police and Ultras at the Brighton game.' by bexleydave

Hi everyone. I found this interesting article online. Apparently a load of German Ultras turned up to support BHA last Saturday. Anyone see anything of them?

[Link]

 

EddieMac Flag 03 Mar 20 2.09pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

And one could argue that Reidewald looked all over the place when he came on for the first 10/15 mins. So I agree that in this instance that Roy made the correct decisions and we won.
At some point all those that have been quick to criticise Roy this season will have to sit down and eat a huge slice of humble pie.

100% correct.

 

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 17 Mar 20 9.19pm

With no football for weeks to come lets just remember we have beaten Brighton at the AMEX this year. AAAAHHHHHHHH it still is such a good feeling.

 

Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs Palace Match Thread