This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
VAR legal challenges
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
BlueJay UK 30 Jul 20 1.42pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Unless the appeal would be to force the ref to check pitchside. Now that's the way to go with appealing although it would still be refs call. Our 'goal' against villa might well have stood.
You make a good point there. But as you say, it's still the refs call so there's always that subjective aspect.
|
Pierre Purley 30 Jul 20 2.04pm |
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
There were 2 other VAR failures that night.
And that is the whole point, we have given VAR 2 years to get it right but it doesn't, causing more hold-ups more controversy and still making wrong decisions, in which case what is the point.
In fact our PL football is becoming a lottery, there is no point in attending matches if it is decided remotely.
I wanted it to succeed after seeing the success of DRS in cricket, but they are chalk and cheese.
One benefit for those relegated is that they can play football once again without it.
The more changes and allowances you make for VAR, the worse it becomes.
Don't forget that DRS has taken time to Morph into what it is today. Hopefully VAR will be shaped in the same way over time so we all end up with something that is decisive, fair and not to time consuming. I personally think it must start with Ref's studying the monitors and Offsides using the players bodies not limbs, though they will still be fractions in it.
|
steeleye20 Croydon 30 Jul 20 3.05pm |
|
Originally posted by Pierre
Don't forget that DRS has taken time to Morph into what it is today. Hopefully VAR will be shaped in the same way over time so we all end up with something that is decisive, fair and not to time consuming. I personally think it must start with Ref's studying the monitors and Offsides using the players bodies not limbs, though they will still be fractions in it.
We already do have something decisive, fair and not too time-consuming P.
It is called 'No VAR' and it is in the Championship right now.
VAR is a 'pantomime' - RH. 'A busted system' - SP.
|
steeleye20 Croydon 30 Jul 20 3.16pm |
|
|
Germany happy with VAR? You cannot be serious.
Things nearly came to a head in the match I saw, where the 'Shiedsrichter' (ref to you) consulted the pitch-side monitor twice to be sure, taking over 5 minutes.
He returned and awarded a penalty where it did not actually strike the arm, to the outrage of the home fans.
And of course, as it is VAR, even then the ref was then shown subsequently to be wrong!!
|
cryrst The garden of England 30 Jul 20 9.03pm |
|
|
And scary 
|
deleted 25 06 Aug 20 4.15pm |
|
|
VAR was brought in to clear up contentious decisions but in fact it has probably lead to more mistakes.
It dosent help when those calling judgement don't know the difference between hand and arm.
The marginal offsides are a joke
Was supposed to be able to stop biggest teams getting favourable decisions but who got awarded most pens? Man Utd
Who can feel most aggrieved? Bournemouth
|
BlueJay UK 08 Aug 20 2.42pm |
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
VAR was brought in to clear up contentious decisions but in fact it has probably lead to more mistakes.
It dosent help when those calling judgement don't know the difference between hand and arm.
The marginal offsides are a joke
Was supposed to be able to stop biggest teams getting favourable decisions but who got awarded most pens? Man Utd
Who can feel most aggrieved? Bournemouth
I don't think it's been a total disaster, but as you say there is still a subjective component to it. Who decides exactly when the ball has left the foot and and so on.
|
Elpis In a pub 09 Aug 20 10.47am |
|
|
There is nothing wrong with the technology its the way its used that is wrong . The 'Goal'Sheffield scored against Villa was clearly a goal watching it on the TV and was clearly a goal to anyone close to the action . The ref from memory just pointed to the watch which hadn't indicated the ball crossing the line shrugged his shoulders as if to say it couldn't have done the watch says so and played on .
As with many of the iffy decisions that have happened this seaon with that hawkeye blip and the VAR where the decision in the office was an opinion not fact the ref just has to
GO AND LOOK AT THE FECKIN MONITOR !
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 11 Aug 20 10.45am |
|
|
Eagleman13 would be the person to comment on this thread. He was a top level referee. His usual comment is the referees decision is final (even if wrong). "If, in the referees opinion,...."
I know it's $hIt, but once the final whistle blows, that's it. The EPL and EFL don't want legal challenges to a result. Palace have had their fair share of bad decisions.
Freddie Sears at Bristol, anyone ?
[Link]
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
cryrst The garden of England 11 Aug 20 8.38pm |
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Eagleman13 would be the person to comment on this thread. He was a top level referee. His usual comment is the referees decision is final (even if wrong). "If, in the referees opinion,...."
I know it's $hIt, but once the final whistle blows, that's it. The EPL and EFL don't want legal challenges to a result. Palace have had their fair share of bad decisions.
Freddie Sears at Bristol, anyone ?
[Link]
Clive Allen's free kick at cov.not got a link, if you could.
|
Spiderman Horsham 11 Aug 20 8.51pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Clive Allen's free kick at cov.not got a link, if you could.
[Link]
Here we go
|