You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer shambles
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer shambles


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
jhillman Flag USA 10 Sep 20 10.27pm

Originally posted by JohnB

How are we behind other teams?

We've signed an exciting youngster in Eze for £16m and the type of player we've been crying out for.

We've signed an exciting youngster who will potentially be or new right back on a tribunal based transfer.

We are about to sign Batshuayi on loan.

We're still in for a couple of players

We've held on to all of our first team players

Yet you're wetting your knickers because Villa are paying hugely over the odds for Watkins, Newcastle have signed an 28 year old with a dodgy knee for £20m and Villa have signed Wesley and Sammata who scored 6 goals between them for a combined fee of £32m.

The club has a limited amount of money and we've spent it pretty wisely to date.

Exactly my thoughts ... Now we do have the Batsman with an option to buy at end of season. Let's wait and see and everybody hold off on the whining. Also the window is still open, so who knows? COYP

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Sep 20 5.50am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Maybe, maybe not. Depends on wether the club, Dazza & 3T's agree, just saying

Wow hes got in ya head.
1-0 to dazza.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Sep 20 7.48am

Originally posted by elky30

How are we so behind every other club in the prem.

We have been in desperate need for a striker for years.
How we have not signed someone a week before the window opens is aboslutely shocking.

Hopefully you are now regretting starting this thread. It seems that the club actually have a plan this year and it all seems to be coming together and there are rumours of more to come

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Sep 20 8.05am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Hopefully you are now regretting starting this thread. It seems that the club actually have a plan this year and it all seems to be coming together and there are rumours of more to come

If the plan is to reduce the age of the squad, then that is certainly going well.

However, the plan is clearly flexible given that Gallagher was the initial target from Chelsea, and then suddenly switched to Michy !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Sep 20 9.10am

Originally posted by NEILLO

the plan is clearly flexible given that Gallagher was the initial target from Chelsea, and then suddenly switched to Michy !

Unless one has a bottomless pit of money like the North western clubs surely all transfer plans must be flexible and there should always be a plan b if not c and d as well.

Players who weren't available will suddenly become available, players who we think are affordable will have silly prices attached to them (like the £100m we asked for Wilf last year) and a variety of other reasons.

As a long standing critic of Parish's transfer activity I say thank goodness for flexibility

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Sep 20 9.18am

for me its a good switch we know what he can do the other kid unknown

 

elky30 Flag Clapham 11 Sep 20 9.18am

If we have an option to buy on Michy I am happy otherwise we are being used as a shop window for him.

We still have spent less than 20 million this window.
When you add in how much we have spent in the last few windows plus the money we have got for AWB i still think its very poor and we should be spending a lot more.
If we want to progress in this league and not be in a relegation fight every year we need to spend more money.

If we go and sign a winger like Benrahma along with Downes and the young german CB then I will take this all back and say we have have a good successful window
I am certainly happy we are going for younger players as we desperately need this.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Sep 20 9.36am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Unless one has a bottomless pit of money like the North western clubs surely all transfer plans must be flexible and there should always be a plan b if not c and d as well.

Players who weren't available will suddenly become available, players who we think are affordable will have silly prices attached to them (like the £100m we asked for Wilf last year) and a variety of other reasons.

As a long standing critic of Parish's transfer activity I say thank goodness for flexibility

Agreed.

In the case of Gallagher / Michy, much as I like what I have seen of Gallagher, I think the greater need was for a striker.

Good to have the purchase option too

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Sep 20 11.22am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Agreed.

In the case of Gallagher / Michy, much as I like what I have seen of Gallagher, I think the greater need was for a striker.

Good to have the purchase option too

Either player option was going to be a gain,. But we do make chances , making more would be fine if anybody was there to put more in the net. it’s been a curse at times. So at this moment it’s Bats, we need most.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Sep 20 11.28am

Originally posted by Putitout

Either player option was going to be a gain,. But we do make chances , making more would be fine if anybody was there to put more in the net. it’s been a curse at times. So at this moment it’s Bats, we need most.


That's it. A shame we can't have Gallagher as well but it seems that what funds we have available are being targetted at a wide player rather than at picking Bats up with them this window.

 

The Beger Flag Croydon 11 Sep 20 12.44pm

Originally posted by elky30

How are we so behind every other club in the prem.

Villa on the verge of singing Watkins for 28 mil and rising to 33, yes its far too much for him but how have they got this money to spend and we dont. They spent 22 mil on Wesley and 9 mil on Sammata last yearTeams like Newcastle also splashing the cash compared to us. We have been in desperate need for a striker for years. How we have not signed someone a week before the window opens is absolutely shocking.

Hmmm, it's the 21st Century, don't you have access to google?

Try this:

[Link]

See who is spending what.

Excluding the "big 6", Brighton, Westham, Burnley, WBA, Southampton, Sheffield UTD, Fulham and Leicester have spend no more than 25m per club.

Regarding Aston Villa. Their owners will buy "shares" worth 100m, to buy players, a dodgy way of circumventing FFP.

Leeds are gambling, like Villa did last year. Villa won their bet, but Bournemouth and Watford did not, the latter 2 are now in deep trouble and are thus having a fire sale to reduce debt and outgoings.

 


I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer shambles