You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blame FIFA, not VAR
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Blame FIFA, not VAR


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
crystal-purley Flag Purley 01 Oct 20 1.13pm

Originally posted by roman eagle

You can read up on the membership of IFAB here [Link]
The main committee is advised by two panels - the Football Advisory Panel and the Technical Advisory Panel. These comprise various members including former professionals - Luis Figo and Boban for example, representatives of the federations, coaches and former top referees including Collina and Elleray.

Despite all of this accumulated wisdom they’ve managed to make a mess of the handball law. Again I go back to Roy - if the player does it deliberately it’s a penalty, if it hits his hand it’s not. The most ridiculous penalty given this season was the Dier penalty - he actually had his back to the ball so had no idea where the ball was - surely this can’t be what IFAB intended. This makes a mockery of the law and is not a good advert for the game because fairness is a basic principle of football and that is blatantly unfair.

part of the rule used to be that if the ball ended up favourably to the handler then it was a foul on the other hand (no pun) if it didn't then play on. Rehashing this might have stopped the Lindelof, Ward and Dier fiascos which might cause cuts in money at the end of the season.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 01 Oct 20 1.50pm

Originally posted by roman eagle

You can read up on the membership of IFAB here [Link]
The main committee is advised by two panels - the Football Advisory Panel and the Technical Advisory Panel. These comprise various members including former professionals - Luis Figo and Boban for example, representatives of the federations, coaches and former top referees including Collina and Elleray.

Despite all of this accumulated wisdom they’ve managed to make a mess of the handball law. Again I go back to Roy - if the player does it deliberately it’s a penalty, if it hits his hand it’s not. The most ridiculous penalty given this season was the Dier penalty - he actually had his back to the ball so had no idea where the ball was - surely this can’t be what IFAB intended. This makes a mockery of the law and is not a good advert for the game because fairness is a basic principle of football and that is blatantly unfair.

I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this.

Of The 4 handball decisions; Lindlehoff, Maupay Ward and Dier. I would say Diers one the only one where it could have actually been a penalty. Having your back to the ball is not a defence. Just because you cannot see the ball, does not stop you from intentionally putting your body in a position where handling the ball is likely. Same with this notion that the proximity should be taken into account. No! If I were to run at you arms streched, like a goalkeeper, and if you kicked it when I was 'only' one metre away, then that's handball.
There is an argument when looking at Diers jump that he intentionally made his body bigger by using his arms in an attempt to stop the ball getting past him. This is regardless of where he was looking or facing at the time.
This is the issue - judging intent. personally I think that Diers was unintentional, but there is definitely a case for unnatural arm position, and definitely a case for arm-to-ball movement.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

samprior Flag Hamburg 01 Oct 20 6.39pm

It's clearly ruffled some important feathers as interpretation is to be changed for the next set of matches. Thank goodness. You'll obviously not eradicate all dodgy pens but this will hopefully reduce the amount of nonsense decisions that we've been seeing... just a shame it wasn't in place last week.

[Link]

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Oct 20 10.29pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this.

Of The 4 handball decisions; Lindlehoff, Maupay Ward and Dier. I would say Diers one the only one where it could have actually been a penalty. Having your back to the ball is not a defence. Just because you cannot see the ball, does not stop you from intentionally putting your body in a position where handling the ball is likely. Same with this notion that the proximity should be taken into account. No! If I were to run at you arms streched, like a goalkeeper, and if you kicked it when I was 'only' one metre away, then that's handball.
There is an argument when looking at Diers jump that he intentionally made his body bigger by using his arms in an attempt to stop the ball getting past him. This is regardless of where he was looking or facing at the time.
This is the issue - judging intent. personally I think that Diers was unintentional, but there is definitely a case for unnatural arm position, and definitely a case for arm-to-ball movement.

Thank feck you are not a referee. You’re not are you?

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 01 Oct 20 11.09pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this.

Of The 4 handball decisions; Lindlehoff, Maupay Ward and Dier. I would say Diers one the only one where it could have actually been a penalty. Having your back to the ball is not a defence. Just because you cannot see the ball, does not stop you from intentionally putting your body in a position where handling the ball is likely. Same with this notion that the proximity should be taken into account. No! If I were to run at you arms streched, like a goalkeeper, and if you kicked it when I was 'only' one metre away, then that's handball.
There is an argument when looking at Diers jump that he intentionally made his body bigger by using his arms in an attempt to stop the ball getting past him. This is regardless of where he was looking or facing at the time.
This is the issue - judging intent. personally I think that Diers was unintentional, but there is definitely a case for unnatural arm position, and definitely a case for arm-to-ball movement.

I disagree. Maupay’s was the most obvious one as he leads with his arm above his head in the direction of the ball. This would’ve given in any season.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Oct 20 7.36am

Hand to ball rather than ball to hand is the fairest definition of handball and causes the least controversy. That should apply on the entire pitch for equity. The only time this should be overturned is if a team gets a clear advantage from an accidental handball and then an indirect free kick should be awarded.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 02 Oct 20 11.12am

Originally posted by eritheagle

I disagree. Maupay’s was the most obvious one as he leads with his arm above his head in the direction of the ball. This would’ve given in any season.

yeah, that's a fair point.
I guess my point was that too many people are using the "he's not even looking at the ball" defence, which should be taken into account, but does not mean that an offence wasn't committed.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 02 Oct 20 11.14am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Thank feck you are not a referee. You’re not are you?

haha no. couldn't be - I don't agree with enough Of the rules !

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blame FIFA, not VAR