You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our best 11
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our best 11


rikz Flag Croydon 03 Oct 20 4.06pm

Guaita

Ward cahill Tompkins pva

Kouyate mccarthur

Townsend eze zaha

Batshuayi

Thats our best 11 when everyone is fit, sick of 442, sick of zaha and ayew up top, isolated and us offering nothing going forward. Yes we are well drilled and probably have just about enough to get away with it and remain in the league for another year but I'm sick of us defending with 10 men and hoping we boot the ball to zaha and he manages to get a 1 on 1. Can't wait till Roy retires.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 03 Oct 20 4.29pm

We dont have a fully fit best 11

Bats is not our player & apart from keeper, i dont think we have 10 DM's. Joking aside, Chek is a shoe-in as a CD with(imo) Cahill, then with, as it stands, Clyne & Mitchell as full backs.

If going for 442, id br inclined to go with Andros, Eze & the 2 Jmacs with Wilf & Ayew up top, bearing in mind Bats is only on loan, or, are we only going for this season?

Everybodys opinions are going to & will differ, dependant on what games we lose, nature of loving our club i guess.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

rikz Flag Croydon 03 Oct 20 5.12pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

We dont have a fully fit best 11

Bats is not our player & apart from keeper, i dont think we have 10 DM's. Joking aside, Chek is a shoe-in as a CD with(imo) Cahill, then with, as it stands, Clyne & Mitchell as full backs.

If going for 442, id br inclined to go with Andros, Eze & the 2 Jmacs with Wilf & Ayew up top, bearing in mind Bats is only on loan, or, are we only going for this season?

Everybodys opinions are going to & will differ, dependant on what games we lose, nature of loving our club i guess.

Bats loan deal was with an option to buy at the end of the season

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Oct 20 5.22pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

We dont have a fully fit best 11

Bats is not our player & apart from keeper, i dont think we have 10 DM's. Joking aside, Chek is a shoe-in as a CD with(imo) Cahill, then with, as it stands, Clyne & Mitchell as full backs.

If going for 442, id br inclined to go with Andros, Eze & the 2 Jmacs with Wilf & Ayew up top, bearing in mind Bats is only on loan, or, are we only going for this season?

Everybodys opinions are going to & will differ, dependant on what games we lose, nature of loving our club i guess.

Isn't that what we played today....

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 03 Oct 20 5.45pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Isn't that what we played today....

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 03 Oct 20 6.25pm

I'd love to see us try something like this when everyone is fit...


Guaita

Tomkins Cahill Dann

Ferguson - - - - - - - - PVA / Schlupp

McArthur Riedewald

Eze - - - - - - - Zaha
Batshuayi

For me Zaha isn't a striker but also can't cross so isn't that great on the wing. Him and Eze are best running at defenders so let them do that with Ferguson and PVA / Schlupp providing the width. Could play Schlupp because of the three CBs to cover. Get Riedewald in the centre or, if we're feeling really ambitious, Meyer. Ideally we'd sign a new CB to replace Dann.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (03 Oct 2020 6.25pm)

Edited by Canterbury Palace (03 Oct 2020 6.25pm)

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Oct 20 6.37pm

Guiata

Ward kouyate Dann mitchell

- - - -McArthur Riedewald McCarthy

Zaha batshuayi eze

With who we have available at the moment, this would be my team.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 03 Oct 20 9.03pm

For me its:

Guaita

Ward
Cahill
Tomkins
Mitchell

McArthur
McArthy

Townsend
Eze
Wilf

Batshuayi

Eze has done a reasonable job as a winger but naturally, he is more of a number 10. And for me, Wilf as a striker does not work

 

BM Flag 03 Oct 20 10.28pm

Guiata, Ferguson, Tomkins, Sakho, van Aanholt, Zaha, McArthur, Riedewald, Schlupp, Eze, Benteke.

 

Noddy-The-Git Flag Tadworth 13 Oct 20 5.32pm

Guaita - Best option

Mitchell - Playing every game he gets better and stronger PVA has his work cut
Dann - I feel is reliable still
Cahill - Expirence, resilience
Fergurson - Has the pace we lack on the right hope he still has it when he is back

Kouyate - Energy and Height
Luka - Puts a foot in more then anyone else in our team need him in the team also setpieces.
Eze - Love his composure on the ball almost like he slows down time to pick his pass.

Zaha - He'll always do his bit in this team.
Bats - Best finisher in our team, lethal in the box
Schlupp - Pace, power and gets goals and assists.

One thing for sure, its not easy picking a so called strongest eleven but I've included Fergurson he's a real prospect (if he ever recovers from this 'forever' injury)

 


We're The Holmesdale We're The Holmesdale We're The Holmesdale Over Here!!.. Can't hear you Arthur.. Can You Sing Up

EAAAAAAAGGGGGGGLLLLLLLLLEEEEEESSSSSS!!

Fatherken Flag 13 Oct 20 5.50pm

Bat's best finisher in our team ?
Hasn't played yet so how can you tell ?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Oct 20 10.19am

Having never seen Ferguson, I don't feel I can pick him, therefore I'd go with this. I think Luka is best when he has a good passer alongside him, like when Cabaye was with us. As such, I think it's important we get Jairo into the team. I keep bleating on about it, but he looked class in preseason and I felt so sorry for him that he got injured just prior to the season's kick off. He also looks forward when passing, rather than constantly going sideways or backwards.

VG

Ward Tomkins Cahill PvA

Jairo Luka

Townsend Eze
Wilf

Bats

I know Eze's preferred position is in the middle, but I think he and Wilf can learn to switch during games. When he signed he said he was told he'd be playing on the left with the freedom to come inside, so this is not a surprise where he is playing. Eventually he may well end up more central but he's a young player with plenty of time to learn. Once PvA is back I think that will make a big difference, as Tyrick is nowhere near as adventurous.

I'm torn with Ayew. He works harder than anyone, but he oftentimes is missing from the 18-yard box at vital times. Playing alongside Zaha I think they are too similar and sometimes seem to get in each other's way. If we persist with 442 then I think either Roy has to bring Bats or Tekkers in for Ayew, or he needs to move Wilf to the wing, possibly for Andros. At least with Eze and Bats in the squad we actually have real options this season, which the same could not be said of last season.


 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 14 Oct 20 10.30am

Originally posted by Fatherken

Bat's best finisher in our team ?
Hasn't played yet so how can you tell ?

Because he was here the season before last and had 1 in 2 goal to game ratio

 

Fatherken Flag 14 Oct 20 11.01am

on loan trying to impress . Big Ben scored loads when he first came , we need to see what Bat's is like second time around , now under contract for the rest of the season .

 

Come to Daddy Flag 14 Oct 20 11.22am

Originally posted by Fatherken

on loan trying to impress . Big Ben scored loads when he first came , we need to see what Bat's is like second time around , now under contract for the rest of the season .

Batshuayi has had that sort of ratio throughout his career, certainly when his Chelsea games are looked at on a per 90 min basis. Other than that he has scored at round that rate or better for Marseille, Dortmund, Belgium and us.

Worth bearing in mind that the competition to be best finisher in our team isn't the hardest there is

Also, he has pretty similar motivation to impress this time. If not us, then someone; he's basically on loan to secure the best move from Chelsea he can get.

Here's hoping...

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Oct 20 12.53pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Having never seen Ferguson, I don't feel I can pick him, therefore I'd go with this. I think Luka is best when he has a good passer alongside him, like when Cabaye was with us. As such, I think it's important we get Jairo into the team. I keep bleating on about it, but he looked class in preseason and I felt so sorry for him that he got injured just prior to the season's kick off. He also looks forward when passing, rather than constantly going sideways or backwards.

VG

Ward Tomkins Cahill PvA

Jairo Luka

Townsend Eze
Wilf

Bats

I know Eze's preferred position is in the middle, but I think he and Wilf can learn to switch during games. When he signed he said he was told he'd be playing on the left with the freedom to come inside, so this is not a surprise where he is playing. Eventually he may well end up more central but he's a young player with plenty of time to learn. Once PvA is back I think that will make a big difference, as Tyrick is nowhere near as adventurous.

I'm torn with Ayew. He works harder than anyone, but he oftentimes is missing from the 18-yard box at vital times. Playing alongside Zaha I think they are too similar and sometimes seem to get in each other's way. If we persist with 442 then I think either Roy has to bring Bats or Tekkers in for Ayew, or he needs to move Wilf to the wing, possibly for Andros. At least with Eze and Bats in the squad we actually have real options this season, which the same could not be said of last season.



A thoughtful post TL. I agree with much of what you say. However, I think Mitchell does look to go forward when he can and does deliver good crosses, so whilst I agree PvA probably provides more of a threat, young Mitchell is not far behind and seems to be learning quickly.
I'm not sure that Tomkins and Cahill together will work as well as it did last year. Also, I'm not sure they will both be able to last the season. Whilst they may be the best two CBs, I'd be inclined to play one of them alongside Kouyate and perhaps alternate them or have one as a substitute coming on after say 60 mins.
Batshuayi has to play. After all, his loan is (apparently) with an option to buy (for £20m?). No point loaning him if we aren't going to use him, to find out if we really want to buy him. He is after all a proper goal poacher and that's what we need -someone who'll get in and around that 6 yard box. Unfortunately, that means one of Ayew or Townsend has to lose out and at present, I'd put Ayew on the sub's bench.
I agree that both Riederwald and Eze should be in there.

Finally, we have to work on the basis of current form and performances and not on what players were doing 2 or more years ago, so as much as I love McArthur, he's on the bench for me, and as for Sakho, not even that!

 

Zaha127 Flag 18 Oct 20 3.08am

GUAITA

MITCHELL TOMKINS CAHILL WARD


KOUYATE MCCARTHY


ZAHA AYEW EZE


MICHY

AYEW and MICHY can play together. AYEW can play many positions including CAM and on the wings when needed. Kouyate and Mccarthy would offer good stability.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 18 Oct 20 7.26am

Originally posted by doombear


A thoughtful post TL. I agree with much of what you say. However, I think Mitchell does look to go forward when he can and does deliver good crosses, so whilst I agree PvA probably provides more of a threat, young Mitchell is not far behind and seems to be learning quickly.
I'm not sure that Tomkins and Cahill together will work as well as it did last year. Also, I'm not sure they will both be able to last the season. Whilst they may be the best two CBs, I'd be inclined to play one of them alongside Kouyate and perhaps alternate them or have one as a substitute coming on after say 60 mins.
Batshuayi has to play. After all, his loan is (apparently) with an option to buy (for £20m?). No point loaning him if we aren't going to use him, to find out if we really want to buy him. He is after all a proper goal poacher and that's what we need -someone who'll get in and around that 6 yard box. Unfortunately, that means one of Ayew or Townsend has to lose out and at present, I'd put Ayew on the sub's bench.
I agree that both Riederwald and Eze should be in there.

Finally, we have to work on the basis of current form and performances and not on what players were doing 2 or more years ago, so as much as I love McArthur, he's on the bench for me, and as for Sakho, not even that!

Mitchell has a fine future to look forward to I'm sure. He does play a little better if he knows hes got protection on his position allowing him to roam up and down. Schlupp gives this and helps him verbally when on the pitch as well. You cannot buy individual experience to coin a phrase.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 18 Oct 20 9.09am

I can’t believe that Jimmy McArthur isn’t being included? Mr Reliable, end to end and the odd goal....

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our best 11