You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Satisfaction Chart
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Satisfaction Chart


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 Oct 20 11.01pm

I think we needed another young winger and a developing centre back.

The number 10 thing is a white elephant. Few teams can afford the luxury the way football is played now.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (16 Oct 2020 11.07pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Oct 20 11.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I think we needed another young winger and a developing centre back.

The number 10 thing is a white elephant. Few teams can afford the luxury the way football is played now.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (16 Oct 2020 11.07pm)


Perhaps the club hope Banks will fill that role before too long. Or they feel they can wait till January or next summer now that Andros has shown a bit of form again and we have Eze on the left.

Edited by doombear (16 Oct 2020 11.21pm)

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 17 Oct 20 12.02am

7/10
Think the fact we signed players early has removed some of the excitement from the window. Overall I’m please but could of been brilliant if we got Sarr or Benhrama.

Would say if we signed Eze, Ferguson and Batshuayi towards the end of the window people may of viewed it more positively.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 17 Oct 20 5.53am

By my estimation this is now our squad, roughly in order of strength. I've left out youth players like Kirby who have yet to fully break through.

GK - Guaita, Butland, Hennessey, Henderson
RB - Clyne, Ferguson, Ward
LB - Mitchell, Van Aanholt
CB - Cahill, Tomkins, Dann, Kelly, Sakho
CM/DM - McArthur, Milovojevic, Riedewald, Kouyate, McCarthy
AM/WF - Zaha, Eze, Schlupp, Townsend, Ayew, Meyer
FW - Batshuayi, Benteke, Wickham

Positives: I think we've evidently strengthened some key areas of the team, particularly at right back and in the goalkeeping department, with Butland a much better deputy than Wayne.
Eze must be considered the signing of the window for us and will hopefully, if used properly, either exploit the space created by teams concentrating on Zaha or take some of the attention away from him altogether to allow Wilf to thrive.
At 29.8, we had the oldest squad in the division and, with an average age of 25, our new signings will bring that down slightly.
Keeping Zaha obviously a major win.
Our net spend was, again, not far off the lowest in the division so hopefully we can plug any further holes in January.

Negatives: I'm slightly concerned that Butland has been brought in as a replacement for Guaita, not Hennessey. In an ideal world he signs a new contract and we ship out Wayne in January.
We were crying out for another winger/forward and a centre-back but didn't land either. Half-hearted bids for Sarr at the last minute, a pursuit of Benrahma who damningly preferred to play under David Moyes and the dildo-salesmen, Brewster opting for Sheffield United over us can all be marked down as missed opportunities.
The striking situation which, let's be honest, has been shambolic since we were promoted, still isn't a lot clearer. Do we have an option for Batshuayi next summer? If so is that next summer's business already done? Conor Wickham is still here and must go down as the worst signing in the history of the club, in terms of how much he has cost us. Whoever gave him a contract extension, even on reduced wages, needs flogging.
Our aging central defenders will have to muddle through again and I just pray that two of them remain fit enough so that I don't ever have to watch Sakho needlessly scythe someone down or slice the ball into the path of the opposition striker again.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Oct 20 6.44am

Unless my maths is wrong I counted 28 senior players. I thought we are only allowed 25 in a senior squad plus youngsters. Do Eze (22 years old), Mitchell (21) and Ferguson (20) all count as youngsters and if so for how long?

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 17 Oct 20 7.14am

Banks doesn't count for those window, was last year signing. But you're right, is promising.

Originally posted by silvertop

No argument on the gaffer but I might challenge the period of time we have been in this division.

7.5. Higher marks had we off-loaded Wickham, and pushing a perfect 10 if we sign Sarr (we won't).

You guys are forgetting Banks. Nominated for player of the month in PL2 (development). Expect to see him off the bench soon and starting in the Cup in Jan...

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Oct 20 7.56am

To answer the OP's questions 6/10 not bad but I really wanted another striker rather than a winger which we didn't get. If Batman gets injured we are in trouble.

 


One more point

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Oct 20 8.14am

Originally posted by rossboss29

7/10
Think the fact we signed players early has removed some of the excitement from the window.

I think that there was still excitement as Roy said that we needed another striker and we all waited in hope to see who would arrive

 

EddieMac Flag 17 Oct 20 8.17am

I may be missing something that others have heard but does Batshuayi not count as that striker?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Oct 20 10.24am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I may be missing something that others have heard but does Batshuayi not count as that striker?


Not the extra one that Roy wanted because he made the comment after Batshuayi arrived.

 

EddieMac Flag 17 Oct 20 10.32am

Originally posted by doombear


Not the extra one that Roy wanted because he made the comment after Batshuayi arrived.

Ah I see. Thanks

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Oct 20 10.33am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Unless my maths is wrong I counted 28 senior players. I thought we are only allowed 25 in a senior squad plus youngsters. Do Eze (22 years old), Mitchell (21) and Ferguson (20) all count as youngsters and if so for how long?

Your Maths aren't wrong.
Mitchell and Ferguson don't count (Mitchell will from Jan 2021 and Ferguson from Jan 22). Players who are UNDER 21 as at 1 January don't count. Eze does count.
Expect Hennessey NOT to be included in the 25 for this part of the season as it seems he has an injury that will keep him out for several months if the rumours are true - and presumably they are true otherwise we wouldn't have made the last minute dash for Butland who confirmed he was only approached on Thursday evening! Take Ferguson, Mitchell and Hennessey out and we are down to the 25 max with Woods presumably dropping down to the U23s - he's still 22.
(all change with next transfer window perhaps)


Edited by doombear (17 Oct 2020 10.37am)

 

GujiMadDog Flag England 17 Oct 20 10.43am

A promising transfer window petered out. Are we surprised?

Given our performance in past transfer windows this represents a revolution. Should we be happy with our lot?

As with every fickle football fan (probably all of us) I would answer 'No' to both questions.

Overall transfer window verdict, C+. Can do better.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 Oct 20 10.53am

Originally posted by GujiMadDog

A promising transfer window petered out. Are we surprised?

Given our performance in past transfer windows this represents a revolution. Should we be happy with our lot?

As with every fickle football fan (probably all of us) I would answer 'No' to both questions.

Overall transfer window verdict, C+. Can do better.

I feel we need to see at least twelve games before we award ourselves marks, we must let players settle in and get back from injury ...hard to say 'can do better' especially when we of all people know what a difference one player can make to a team....

Edited by Tickled pink (17 Oct 2020 10.54am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 17 Oct 20 10.54am

I'm fairly satisfied with it. Addressed a few concerns RB, striker, creativity and age.

But as with all windows it'll be a good 6 months before we can really judge if it is a hit or miss... a win on Sunday would be a positive start

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Oct 20 11.28am

Originally posted by doombear

Your Maths aren't wrong.
Mitchell and Ferguson don't count (Mitchell will from Jan 2021 and Ferguson from Jan 22). Players who are UNDER 21 as at 1 January don't count. Eze does count.
Expect Hennessey NOT to be included in the 25 for this part of the season as it seems he has an injury that will keep him out for several months if the rumours are true - and presumably they are true otherwise we wouldn't have made the last minute dash for Butland who confirmed he was only approached on Thursday evening! Take Ferguson, Mitchell and Hennessey out and we are down to the 25 max with Woods presumably dropping down to the U23s - he's still 22.
(all change with next transfer window perhaps)


Edited by doombear (17 Oct 2020 10.37am)

That's helpful thanks, wasn't sure what the dates/ages were for becoming a senior player.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 17 Oct 20 12.07pm

Thanks for this. Just to put it into perspective, I think we had 5 goalies on the 25 last season, so I'd say we're doing much better.

For me it was a B+ or 7.5/10. But I think it's hard to get a mark better than that.

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

That's helpful thanks, wasn't sure what the dates/ages were for becoming a senior player.

 

the.universal 17 Oct 20 2.00pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Thanks for this. Just to put it into perspective, I think we had 5 goalies on the 25 last season, so I'd say we're doing much better.

For me it was a B+ or 7.5/10. But I think it's hard to get a mark better than that.

A green, think we did some decent business. Ferguson, Clyne & Butland all for next to nothing (tribunals always stitch up the selling club).

Eze looks a real prospect and Bats is a good striker with an option to buy. Got some money for Sorloth which looked unlikely when he was being shyte on loan to Gent.

 


Vive le Roy!

GujiMadDog Flag England 17 Oct 20 2.58pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

I feel we need to see at least twelve games before we award ourselves marks, we must let players settle in and get back from injury ...hard to say 'can do better' especially when we of all people know what a difference one player can make to a team....

Edited by Tickled pink (17 Oct 2020 10.54am)

True

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Satisfaction Chart