You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy shake it all about
November 16 2026 5.04am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy shake it all about


ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 25 Oct 20 2.50pm

It's not really a thread but he could play three at the back

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 25 Oct 20 8.16pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

It's not really a thread but he could play three at the back

indeed!

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 8.29pm

He could play one at the back.

He chooses not to. Not sure why

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

beak Flag croydon 25 Oct 20 8.37pm

Roy shake it all about Is he on Strictly ?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Oct 20 8.06am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

It's not really a thread but he could play three at the back

You only play 3 at the back if you have dynamic fullbacks capable of playing as wingbacks and they then become the most difficult roles on the pitch as they must play as both attacker and defender. PVA at his best maybe could play this role but we have no-one at right back at present who can.

Playing 3 at the back also requires your 3 to have a turn of speed which we lack from all ours who play there. So for numerous reasons we cannot IMO set up like that at the back.

The best we can hope for is that our full backs overlap our left and right side midfield a bit more and get some decent crosses in.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Oct 20 9.06am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You only play 3 at the back if you have dynamic fullbacks capable of playing as wingbacks and they then become the most difficult roles on the pitch as they must play as both attacker and defender. PVA at his best maybe could play this role but we have no-one at right back at present who can.

Playing 3 at the back also requires your 3 to have a turn of speed which we lack from all ours who play there. So for numerous reasons we cannot IMO set up like that at the back.

The best we can hope for is that our full backs overlap our left and right side midfield a bit more and get some decent crosses in.

That's how I understand it too. Man City and England can do it due to Walker's electric pace.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Oct 20 9.13am

In terms of "Shake it all about", Hodgson is "In/Out" depending on the result!

A win,like against Fulham, and he is "In" as far as supporters are concerned but after an abject performance and a less favourable result, like against Brighton, supporters want him "Out".

For avoidance of doubt I have not witnessed Hodgson gyrating his hips on the dance floor!

Edited by Willo (26 Oct 2020 9.14am)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Oct 20 9.19am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You only play 3 at the back if you have dynamic fullbacks capable of playing as wingbacks and they then become the most difficult roles on the pitch as they must play as both attacker and defender. PVA at his best maybe could play this role but we have no-one at right back at present who can.

Playing 3 at the back also requires your 3 to have a turn of speed which we lack from all ours who play there. So for numerous reasons we cannot IMO set up like that at the back.

The best we can hope for is that our full backs overlap our left and right side midfield a bit more and get some decent crosses in.

Mitchel is better then PVA in defending on that side but yes PVA is excellent in linking up the attack, Ferguson hopefully will sort the right side when available, but I really do worry about PVA getting back into position properly, it's going to be a nice problem for us though when all injured are back.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Oct 20 9.21am

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of "Shake it all about", Hodgson is "In/Out" depending on the result!

A win,like against Fulham, and he is "In" as far as supporters are concerned but after an abject performance and a less favourable result, like against Brighton, supporters want him "Out".

For avoidance of doubt I have not witnessed Hodgson gyrating his hips on the dance floor!

Edited by Willo (26 Oct 2020 9.14am)

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 26 Oct 20 9.29am

I think Ferguson can play left or right full back, hopefully he'll be competing with Wardy and Clyne on one wing, and PVA and Mitchell on the other. As for 3 at the back even if we had the players Roy wouldn't do it - bcos he's Roy. Venables always reckons the best type of defenders in a back three are players like Pearce or Jagielka (or Tompkins?) who can play both as full back and centre back, because back 3 defenders get pulled wide more. So Wardy, Kelly and maybe even our new midfielder Jairo would be beeter in there than say Scott Dann or Kouyate (who I prefer in defence to midfield). And Willo I don't see Roy 'gyrating' on the dance floor but I could see him doing the okey-cokey (or the conga) which is not quite the same thing.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Oct 20 9.35am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I think Ferguson can play left or right full back, hopefully he'll be competing with Wardy and Clyne on one wing, and PVA and Mitchell on the other. As for 3 at the back even if we had the players Roy wouldn't do it - bcos he's Roy. Venables always reckons the best type of defenders in a back three are players like Pearce or Jagielka (or Tompkins?) who can play both as full back and centre back, because back 3 defenders get pulled wide more. So Wardy, Kelly and maybe even our new midfielder Jairo would be beeter in there than say Scott Dann or Kouyate (who I prefer in defence to midfield). And Willo I don't see Roy 'gyrating' on the dance floor but I could see him doing the okey-cokey (or the conga) which is not quite the same thing.

My word, I now have this vision of Parish,Freedman, Hodgson,Lewington etc as part of a formation dancing team akin to that trained by Frank and Peggy Spencer from Penge.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 26 Oct 20 1.42pm

3 at the back:

Guaita
Tompkins Cahill PVA
Townsend Luka Jairo Schlupp
Eze
Zaha Batshuayi

Bench: Ayew, McCarthy, McArthur, Dann, Ferguson, Banks, Butland

go on Roy, you know you want to.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Oct 20 2.26pm

Roy will not have spent 3 years drilling his defensive set up to give it up on a whim. All pundits and commentators acknowledge how difficult we are to score against.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 26 Oct 20 2.37pm

Cheikhou Kouyaté does not even make your bench? Think he has been a stand out performer in our defence.

quote=ex hibitionist;3568896]

3 at the back:

Guaita
Tompkins Cahill PVA
Townsend Luka Jairo Schlupp
Eze
Zaha Batshuayi

Bench: Ayew, McCarthy, McArthur, Dann, Ferguson, Banks, Butland

go on Roy, you know you want to.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 26 Oct 20 3.06pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Cheikhou Kouyaté does not even make your bench? Think he has been a stand out performer in our defence.

quote=ex hibitionist;3568896]

3 at the back:

Guaita
Tompkins Cahill PVA
Townsend Luka Jairo Schlupp
Eze
Zaha Batshuayi

Bench: Ayew, McCarthy, McArthur, Dann, Ferguson, Banks, Butland

go on Roy, you know you want to.


No place for Cheikh with a back 3 I'm afraid, the best XI is not always the best eleven players.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 07 Nov 20 8.48pm

he did and look what happened - we may revert to being more defensive, I'm sure it just depends who we're playing, having more attacking threat was the right choice v Leeds, and McArthur played well today whereas he has been chasing the game against better sides lately, Jairo will keep his place no doubt, but MCarthy will parter him instead of McArthur at some point, and Schlupp will come back in, perhaps Eze may threaten Andros's place on the right side of midfield - we were less predictable today and I hope that's what continues

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Nov 20 8.10pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

he did and look what happened - we may revert to being more defensive, I'm sure it just depends who we're playing, having more attacking threat was the right choice v Leeds, and McArthur played well today whereas he has been chasing the game against better sides lately, Jairo will keep his place no doubt, but MCarthy will parter him instead of McArthur at some point, and Schlupp will come back in, perhaps Eze may threaten Andros's place on the right side of midfield - we were less predictable today and I hope that's what continues

Yes ..and it appears Roy is an exhibitionist.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Nov 20 11.27am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You only play 3 at the back if you have dynamic fullbacks capable of playing as wingbacks and they then become the most difficult roles on the pitch as they must play as both attacker and defender. PVA at his best maybe could play this role but we have no-one at right back at present who can.

Playing 3 at the back also requires your 3 to have a turn of speed which we lack from all ours who play there. So for numerous reasons we cannot IMO set up like that at the back.

The best we can hope for is that our full backs overlap our left and right side midfield a bit more and get some decent crosses in.


I think Andros could be converted to right wing back. His defending has improved and even Traore at Wolves plays there sometimes. A winger can definitely play that role.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy shake it all about