You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rating the centre backs
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rating the centre backs


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
jeeagles Flag 01 Nov 20 12.18pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Sakho

Positives: the best ball playing centre half we have. Negatives: he is poor in the air given his size and the position he plays.
Always liable to make a mistake (probably because of the positive mentioned).
His wages are high.
He's always injured.

On the balance the negatives far out weigh the positives.

I would say our best pairing at the moment is Kouyate and Cahill or Kouyate and Dann.

Kelly very underated and has never let us down.
Tomkins - the injuries are mounting up but an excellent centre half when fully fit.

We are lucky to have such experience, quality and depth in this position.

Agree that in terms of ability, Sakho is our best defender. His performances have dropped, but he's not isolated in that regard.

Personally, if a game was tight I'd take him off in that last 10-20 minutes as we know that's when his concentration starts to wonder off.

I also wouldn't play him with Kouyate/Mitchell as I dont really trust him to lead the back 4.

 

Mojo87 Flag 01 Nov 20 1.48pm

On their day and when fully fit, I reckon Cahill and Tomkins are our best and most consistent performance wise pairing.

Sakho should either be sold in the Jan window, otherwise be gone Summer 2021. 30 plus, injury-prone, high wages and above all else has too many clangers in his locker that almost inevitably leads to us conceding a goal.

Kouyate has been deputising brilliantly since making the transition and I see no reason why he can't make that his main role in the team and squad going forward

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Sakho
6. Kelly
7. Woods

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 20 2.28pm

In terms of consistency over a sustained period Dann has been great for us and is much underrated.
I can only recall a handful of bad games from him for us over a number of seasons.
He’s not as error prone as Sakho , is rarely beaten in the air and would continue to provide a threat in opposing boxes if the delivery from set pieces was better.
Cahill reads the game well and knows the positions to take defensively but Dann shares this attribute too.
The downside with him is age and lack of pace, but in fairness he rarely leaves himself vulnerable to one on ones.
I’m always comfortable to see Dann in our lineup and think it’s an insult to see him as a bit part player.

 

EddieMac Flag 02 Nov 20 3.32pm

Roy definitely has a dilemma on his hands now most of the players are fit, Sakho won’t even be in the squad very soon which I for one will be over the moon about. He is awful nowadays.

It will be interesting to see what Roy does with Kouyate. In my book he’s been our best player so far this season,

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Nov 20 7.44pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Roy definitely has a dilemma on his hands now most of the players are fit, Sakho won’t even be in the squad very soon which I for one will be over the moon about. He is awful nowadays.

It will be interesting to see what Roy does with Kouyate. In my book he’s been our best player so far this season,

If I were the manager I would consider moving him into centre mid for the Leeds game. I thought our midfield didn't compete enough Friday.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Nov 20 5.38pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

If I were the manager I would consider moving him into centre mid for the Leeds game. I thought our midfield didn't compete enough Friday.

No, he cannot pass, he is better then good with defending.

 

deleted 25 Flag 05 Nov 20 8.28pm

Tomkins
Kelly
Sahko
Dann
Cahill

Kouyate should stick to midfield

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rating the centre backs