You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zion Atta
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zion Atta


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
taylors lovechild Flag 25 Jan 21 11.29am

As much as it would be hard to see a real talent leave, he is still a kid and if he and those around him think it is in his interests to move then so be it. Looking at the German and Dutch leagues there certainly seems to be more of a direct route to the first team for young players and that lure is strong even for youngsters at the big six clubs.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jan 21 12.25pm

There are several posters on here who would still be picking Gareth Barry, and letting Foden go on a free. How do you think young players start a successful career? Perhaps McArthur and Co can play into their forties and we can get some more past their sell by date players on frees. In the meantime our rated youngsters can just go on frees because they're kids.

 


Red and Blue Army!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 25 Jan 21 12.52pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

There are several posters on here who would still be picking Gareth Barry, and letting Foden go on a free. How do you think young players start a successful career? Perhaps McArthur and Co can play into their forties and we can get some more past their sell by date players on frees. In the meantime our rated youngsters can just go on frees because they're kids.

I'll tell you how young players start a successful career - they sign a professional contract. In Atta's case, he has rejected one with Palace so that he can move elsewhere.

It's the system that enables them to go for nothing / little or no compensation.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Jan 21 1.10pm

Not the first time it's been said, but has it not occurred to anyone that the reason we stuck with older players is that the youth team aren't good enough to replace them?

When it came to playing first team football they used to say that if you were good enough you were old enough, but some on here seem to think that if you're young enough then you're good enough.

It doesn't work that way. Never has. Look at every England youth team to win a youth tournament - half of them don't even become professional footballers. A youth team isn't some gold mine of under appreciated assets - its a highly speculative venture which has always been understood to fail far, far more often than it succeeds.

And please don't say we'll never know if we don't give them a chance. They get the chance every single day at training, and in u23 games. The club is painfully aware of the standard of the youth teams relative to the required standard, hence all the expenditure.

Even if this kid Zion is exceptional for his age, the chances of him ever being an improvement on our first team options are, by their very nature, slim at best. The idea that we create pathways for kids who are good enough makes perfect sense, but to create pathways simply so we don't lose every kid who threatens to explore alternative options is all wrong. Every half decent kid at the club would have us over a barrel in no time.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (25 Jan 2021 1.33pm)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 25 Jan 21 1.57pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Not the first time it's been said, but has it not occurred to anyone that the reason we stuck with older players is that the youth team aren't good enough to replace them?

When it came to playing first team football they used to say that if you were good enough you were old enough, but some on here seem to think that if you're young enough then you're good enough.

It doesn't work that way. Never has. Look at every England youth team to win a youth tournament - half of them don't even become professional footballers. A youth team isn't some gold mine of under appreciated assets - its a highly speculative venture which has always been understood to fail far, far more often than it succeeds.

And please don't say we'll never know if we don't give them a chance. They get the chance every single day at training, and in u23 games. The club is painfully aware of the standard of the youth teams relative to the required standard, hence all the expenditure.

Even if this kid Zion is exceptional for his age, the chances of him ever being an improvement on our first team options are, by their very nature, slim at best. The idea that we create pathways for kids who are good enough makes perfect sense, but to create pathways simply so we don't lose every kid who threatens to explore alternative options is all wrong. Every half decent kid at the club would have us over a barrel in no time.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (25 Jan 2021 1.33pm)

Well said Sir !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jan 21 2.04pm

Didn't James Vaughan score against us when he was 16? Something like that anyway. I agree that 99% don't make it. Some do though. I could name a few but why bother as we can have solid professionals forever.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zion Atta