This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
But back to the topic at hand freedom of speech isn't freedom from consequence. If you're a 'brand ambassador' for people desperate to get their hands on designer underwear, a metrosexual audience at best', it's hardly money well spent if the person you'll paying millions to starts reeling off derogatory terms on daytime TV that decent minded people people aren't particularly interested in hearing. Upholding a very basic standard of behaviour isn't asking the world. One or two here might want to try it. Edited by BlueJay (16 Jan 2021 11.59pm) Exactly
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I get that viewpoint, but the difference here and what I was replying to originally is context. I still don't see how you'd expect nothing to happen in this scenario, which seems to be the inference of the OP. I'm sure people (unfortunately) use that word in a derogatory way all the time. The difference is they will most likely do so with likeminded individuals in earshot, not unknown members of the public or (initially) hundreds of thousands of viewers watching a golf tournament. I agree that it wasn't a positive word to be using. However, like I say society is overly focused upon some words over others based upon oppression narratives. I reject all that as bad for society in general. My attitudes is that you keep censorship as low as possible.....However, we don't live in that society anymore and I regard that as a significant downgrade for the freedom of the individual..
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Both Hitler and Stalin had similar attitudes to that. They had no problem with you saying what you wanted. You just had a consequence coming. Me pointing out that advertisers don't like people reeling off the word 'f****t' is worlds apart from that. They are a business, and they care about their bottom line. As others have said this stuff doesn't fly with advertisers and didn't even decades back.. it's damaging for a brand. You don't need to be 'woke' to realise that most people watching daytime TV don't want to hear this kind of thing. Maybe 40 or 50 years ago no-one would've cared less, but times move on. Maybe the catharsis someone like this golfer gets from reeling off "f****t" is worth the fact that once aired he may as well have been saying it to the faces of his gay family members or fans. People can say what they like, but advertisers aren't obliged to dish out millions to people who are actively damaging their brand, especially when the vast majority of people don't talk with this. It's naive to imagine that they would or should have acted differently.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Me pointing out that advertisers don't like people reeling off the word 'faggot' is worlds apart from that. They are a business, and they care about their bottom line. As others have said this stuff doesn't fly with advertisers and didn't even decades back.. it's damaging for a brand. You don't need to be 'woke' to realise that most people watching daytime TV don't want to hear this kind of thing. Maybe 40 or 50 years ago no-one would've cared less, but times move on. Maybe the catharsis someone like this golfer gets from reeling off "faggot" is worth the fact that once aired he may as well have been saying it to the faces of his gay family members or fans. Should we leaf through a book of challenges faced in life and look for the most negative words to used towards those already with enough on their plates. A disabled people 'oh a cripple', an aspie .. oh you mean 'a spaz', a 'nutter', a black person a n*gger. Afterall, just words aren't they. What does it matter if someone blurts them out on daytime TV? People can say what they like, but advertisers aren't obliged to dish out millions to people who are actively damaging their brand, especially when the vast majority of people don't talk with this. It's naive to imagine that they would or should have acted differently.
I see that buzz phrase used all the time, 'freedom of speech isn't freedom from consequences' so it's time to focus upon it. You say that the Hilter and Stalin comparison is over the top....Well, in the sense of death as a consequence it is, but in the sense that it describes significant repression for thoughts in societies it isn't. Neither Hitler nor Stalin killed everyone who said a word out of place....well, Stalin more so.... however there were always consequences. I'm against a significantly censored society and I'm an opponent of that for various stated reasons. I agree that advertieers can employ and sack who they like. Just like I agreed with a company being allowed to refuse to bake a cake. However the law doesn't actually agree with an employer being able to hire and fire when it sees fit or deny services as it sees fit. You can only sack people or deny services for reasons that the law agrees with So for me this argument falls down at that point.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Er... you do realise the context of this, right? It's not like he said it in earshot of a couple of members of the public walking down surrey street, now is it. What do you expect to happen – the commentator apologises and we all move on? The fact that it was clearly an automatic reaction which he said without thinking also adds even more on top – clearly part of a set of phrases he uses pretty often. He's probably a christian, so it makes sense. I would expect the viewing numbers at the time and post that run into the millions. Perfectly understandable that sponsors would pull or suspend contracts. Finally – the way you end your post implies that you think this sort of dross exits everyones mouth when annoyed or 'letting off steam'. Which is interesting. Ha ha to your last line. It must be very difficult to have such a perfect existence as yourself. I mean never making a mistake in your whole life.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
The world is going mad. A company and its PR department/agency are like 2 completely different companies these days. If anyone owns a Ralph Lauren polo t-shirt then all you’ll need to do is check the label and where it was made for a clue. Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Jan 2021 11.13am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
The world is going mad. This is the most sensible post I have read in response to this ridiculous situation. At the end of the day sponsors make more money from sponsoring players than the player does from wearing the shirt so who needs who more? They should all follow Justin Speith’s take on it who refuses to be logo’d up to the eyeballs and wears one manufacturers clothing because he finds it comfortable and for no other reason. The only players the sponsors want are the top 20 or so in the world and those players simply don’t need the money. If they find they are going to have to fall over themselves to apologise for a slip of the tongue here or there then they may decide the sponsorship deals are simply not worth it. Then let’s see how the big companies react.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
The world is going mad. Yes, maybe next week he'll start talking about how he's been "jewed down" and people will see him as a maverick in the sport and start frantically buying Ralph Lauren as result. As for Tiger Woods, various scandals engulfed him at one period of time and he lost tens of millions in sponsorship [Link] , with estimates in losses to shareholders into the billions [Link] Point being these partnerships come about in a bid to enhance the reputation of a company not damage it. Edited by BlueJay (17 Jan 2021 11.07am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes, maybe next week he'll start talking about how he's been "jewed down" and people will see him as a maverick in the sport and start frantically buying Ralph Lauren as result. As for Tiger Woods, various scandals engulfed him at one period of time and he lost tens of millions in sponsorship [Link] , with estimates in losses to shareholders into the billions [Link] Point being these partnerships come about in a bid to enhance the reputation of a company not damage it. Edited by BlueJay (17 Jan 2021 11.07am) People are people, more the fool the companies.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Yes and consequently they lose more money when there is negative publicity or partnerships. They get to make this call, not him or Tiger Woods and not those detached from their business and advertising models. He's in a massively privileged person above the average individual to be handed millions by advertisers to begin with. If you make that deal with the $$$ devil you become as much brand as person, and so anything that feeds into the public perception of you good or bad, can impact that relationship. Edited by BlueJay (17 Jan 2021 11.21am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes and consequently they lose more money when there is negative publicity or partnerships. They get to make this call, not him and not those who have no idea about their business of advertising models. He's in a massively privileged person above the average individual to be handed millions by advertisers to begin with. If you make that deal with the $$$ devil you become as much brand as person, and so anything that feeds into the public perception of you good or bad, can impact your earnings.
I think you are missing the point. Top 20 golfers, even top 100 golfers don’t need the money. So what if an endorsement walks out the door. Like you say, it damages the brand more than the individual. They make their money playing golf, anything else is a bonus. They are not all of a sudden going to be crap at golf because they lose sponsors.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I think you are missing the point. Top 20 golfers, even top 100 golfers don’t need the money. So what if an endorsement walks out the door. Like you say, it damages the brand more than the individual. They make their money playing golf, anything else is a bonus. They are not all of a sudden going to be crap at golf because they lose sponsors. I'm not saying it is the end of the world if they lose a sponsor, or that they need them. Their talent is a significant source of their income which is never a bad thing!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.