You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Championship a good thing
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Championship a good thing


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
davenotamonkey Flag 15 Feb 21 10.22am

There's nowt better than a 0-0 against PNE on a dark, rainy Monday night. Away. It cleanses the soul.

I doubt we'd beat them right now with the squad we have....

...but no thanks. Let's just clear out the dead / rotten wood. That involves spending and (IMO) ditching Dougie as well.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 15 Feb 21 10.25am

...having said that, by far my favourite ever season was our administration / relegation battle season in the Championship. Arriving at Newcastle to hear Victor Moses didn't take the flight. The desperate battles against Doncaster, Scunny, Sunderland. The epic finale. Football, and the very spirit of this club at it's very best.

Really shows how complacent we've become. Maybe a spell in the "real football" division might be best?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 21 10.29am

Would Parish push on with stadium redevelopment if we did happen to go down is the pressing question.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Feb 21 10.36am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

There's nowt better than a 0-0 against PNE on a dark, rainy Monday night. Away. It cleanses the soul.

I doubt we'd beat them right now with the squad we have....

...but no thanks. Let's just clear out the dead / rotten wood. That involves spending and (IMO) ditching Dougie as well.

I have no idea why, but the repetitive chanting of PNE is one of those football songs from opposing fans that I sometimes find myself singing in obscure moments.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 15 Feb 21 10.47am

Championship would be disastrous, what are you lot on about?! A good thing would be our Premiership survival, new manager, clear out the dead wood, make suitable replacements. If we stay up or go down, we still will need to rebuild anyway and a Premier league status is a better foundation for us to do this from.

 


La la la your mum

taylors lovechild Flag 15 Feb 21 11.08am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

...having said that, by far my favourite ever season was our administration / relegation battle season in the Championship. Arriving at Newcastle to hear Victor Moses didn't take the flight. The desperate battles against Doncaster, Scunny, Sunderland. The epic finale. Football, and the very spirit of this club at it's very best.

Really shows how complacent we've become. Maybe a spell in the "real football" division might be best?

While there is some truth in that, it brushes over what it was like to follow Palace through most of our second-tier years in recent history. How about the period when the club took to piping in crowd chants through the PA to make up for the lack of noise coming from the 13,000 odd of us watching a borderline pub football team punt it long in the hope of Alan Lee putting it in the net?

We are punching above our weight in the PL, but the reality is the same would be the case in the Championship. We are not Leeds, Newcastle or Villa. We wouldn't still draw big crowds in tier 2. We don't even have many saleable assets to cushion the blow financially. If we went down the club wouldn't suddenly decide to become a free-flowing and entertaining team, in fact more likely they'd resort to tried and tested as they desperately tried to claw their way back into the PL. There were periods under Taylor and Burley when I considered contacting the police to report abuse.


 

samprior Flag Hamburg 15 Feb 21 11.14am

Absolute no from me. Yes the football ar the moment is pretty woeful stuff but I've seen a fair amount of that in the championship as well.

Hopefully we'll crawl over the line this year and then the club has to decide where it wants to go.

 

EddieMac Flag 15 Feb 21 11.20am

If we end up in the Championship won’t be long before we are in league 2.

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 15 Feb 21 11.35am

Do we really want to go there?

Coventry had 34 consecutive years in the top flight (9 in the PL) until they dropped out in2001. Their fans said they would be back. After 11 seasons in Division One / the Championship, during which time their highest finish was 8th, they found themselves in League One. The club then went into administration. Four years later they were relegated to League Two.

They have now made their way back into the Championship, but they are homeless and having to ground share with Birmingham.

This is perhaps an extreme case, but you only have to look at the number of other clubs that have descended into the bottom two divisions after a spell in the PL.

It hasn’t done Manchester City or Leicester much harm and Wolves, Sheffield United, Leeds and Norwich also made their way back to the top. Blackburn, QPR and Sheffield Wednesday are in the Championship (the latter in the relegation places), but Oldham, Swindon, Ipswich, Bolton, Sunderland, Charlton, MK Dons, Bradford City, Hull, Portsmouth, Blackpool and Wigan are currently all in League One or Two.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Feb 21 11.56am

The Championship is far too competitive for us. Without a complete overhaul we would go straight down.

 


Red and Blue Army!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 15 Feb 21 12.21pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

There's no good time to get relegated, but this would certainly be the worst of times.

All clubs are suffering financially due to COVID and Palace haven't been exactly awash with cash these last few years.

I see no positives in inviting relegation.


Exactly this. Relegation will set us back years because of the financial implications and the current player situation. Yes, most of our ageing squad would leave if we went down, but our youngsters aren't yet ready for the Championship never mind the PL. If we go down this year, I would see us as favourites to drop into League 1 next year. Also, how many of our promising youngsters (U18 and below) will stay with us then? Also, are our own 1st team youngsters going to stay? Won't they be lured away by other PL clubs?

We need to hang in there for a couple of years or so until our better younger players (U18s etc.) are developed and we see what they're made of. If we bring in a couple of younger players this summer to join Eze, Mitchell, Riedewald and Ferguson (along with a new manager, of course), we will be moving in the right direction.

Edited by doombear (15 Feb 2021 12.22pm)

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 15 Feb 21 12.28pm

Get the new stand built. Get some assets in place and then going down (which we will some time soon) wont be so bad because we will have a solid platform for getting back.
Go down now and I think we will plummet and it will take another minor miracle to get us back where we want to be.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 21 1.05pm

It's funny, some posters saying how we aren't ready for the Championship, we won't be able to compete giving the current state of affairs.
Question: Given the current state of affairs how will we be able to compete in the Premiership if we manage to avoid relegation? A complete overhaul is due whatever way you look at it, whether it's in the Premiership or the Championship.

 

nectoneagle Flag necton 15 Feb 21 1.34pm

Just hang on guys , whilst I agree that we are very poor it is probably easier to stay in Premier than gain promotion from championship.
Yes Norwich have done well again this year I live in Norfolk and the locals know they will struggle again next year if promoted.
Please look through Div.1 and Div2 to see clubs that have been in the top div in recent years , don't think it can't happen to us, just look at clubs such as Sunderland and Bolton

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 15 Feb 21 1.47pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Would Parish push on with stadium redevelopment if we did happen to go down is the pressing question.

If he wants to sell the club he's got to. May take a while to regain momentum in the league if we are relegated but a good stadium is the biggest asset a club can have.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Feb 21 2.00pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

If he wants to sell the club he's got to. May take a while to regain momentum in the league if we are relegated but a good stadium is the biggest asset a club can have.

Unless the original American investment was and is truly ring fenced for stadium development, I would say there's little chance of it happening if we are in the Championship.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

TheBigToePunt Flag 15 Feb 21 3.11pm

Championship football is more evenly matched and less predictable, so I get the appeal.

At the same time, I can't believe anyone would seriously debate the idea that relegation would benefit the club overall.

Some numbers:

42 of the 49 teams to have played in the Premier league have been relegated at some stage.

Of those 42 clubs, a whopping 22 ended up playing League One football or lower.

Although 16 of the 42 relegated clubs came straight back up for at least one more top flight season, 13 of them got relegated again in the end, with only Man City, Leicester and Newcastle remaining in the top flight at present. Also, being a yo-yo club doesn't work. Whilst 16 clubs have bounced back in one year, only four have managed to do it twice.

Conclusion:
Relegated clubs mostly end up staying out of the league, and even if they pop back in again for a season or two, that's almost always just a temporary reprieve.


The only relegated clubs to now be noticeably stronger than when they got relegated are Man City, Wolves, Leicester, and perhaps West Ham (this season anyway?). The common denominator is clear - the first three were taken over by very rich investors, and the fourth got a 60,000 stadium for next to nothing. There isn't a single example of a club being made stronger by relegation itself.

Overall, this is like being a mountaineer.

Following an epic struggle I've made it halfway up this mountain, it's been incredibly difficult, and will only get harder from here as the air gets thinner, the weather gets colder, and the terrain becomes steeper. Even staying here is difficult, and I really don't know how I'll climb any higher.

I know, I'll fall down to the bottom and start again. At base camp I could regain my strength and pack some better equipment. All I need to do is survive the fall. From this great height. Onto the rocks below...

It just doesn't work.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Championship a good thing