You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 11 pts last 7 games, fantastic return
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

11 pts last 7 games, fantastic return


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
jeeagles Flag 05 Mar 21 7.53am

I generally work off the theory that to stay up you need to beat then 10 bottom half teams at home and draw with them away to get 40 points. Anything else is a bonus, but we should be aiming for about 50points.

Therefore, the bare minimum we needed from this run of games was 12 points.

On that basis, 11 points can't be described as a fantastic return as we now need to go to the bigger clubs and pick up points.

Our run in is dreadful. Fortunately, Fulham now need 11 points from 11 games to catch us. That's probably a bridge too far for them and we just need to aim to draw a few more games. It's going to a dreadful end to the season.

The real shame is we can't shift the mentality of looking over our shoulders at avoiding relegation and start looking up the league to see how high we can finish.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Mar 21 8.16am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3612146]

Originally posted by askyourself

I assume that whoever believes that Roy is no longer our best bet for manager, knows who we should replace him with.


Not pulling you up specifically, but...

..I read this a lot. The board did their job. They employed Roy Hodgson. They are not seeking change as far as we know. Why would they speculate who would be our best bet for manager, when they chose Roy Hodgson as our best bet for manager? If you want a different manager, fine. Offer your suggestions for debate. But to just say "Roy out" is not reasonable on it's own.

By the way, if the board give Roy another contract, will you back him?

edit: posted to doombear

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (05 Mar 2021 12.27am)

Roy out is a perfectly reasonable stance if you are not happy with the manner in which we play football and there are many who feel that way. Why do we have to come up with alternatives when we have absolutely zero impact on the decision of who should replace him. Wanting Roy out and who replaces him are two entirely separate subjects.

Would I back Roy for another year? Not with my money I won’t but the team will still get my support as it always does. The next time I visit SP will be when we have a different manager.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Mar 21 10.01am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3612146]

Originally posted by askyourself

I assume that whoever believes that Roy is no longer our best bet for manager, knows who we should replace him with.


Not pulling you up specifically, but...

..I read this a lot. The board did their job. They employed Roy Hodgson. They are not seeking change as far as we know. Why would they speculate who would be our best bet for manager, when they chose Roy Hodgson as our best bet for manager? If you want a different manager, fine. Offer your suggestions for debate. But to just say "Roy out" is not reasonable on it's own.

By the way, if the board give Roy another contract, will you back him?

edit: posted to doombear

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (05 Mar 2021 12.27am)


If the last question on your post is the 'edit' aimed at me, then yes, I would back Hodgson next season if the Board gave him an extension. Why?

Such extension might mean:
1) The summer window will see another small move toward a younger squad with perhaps 2 or 3 youngsters brought in and possibly a more experienced player in their mid 20s and the Board want Hodgson's proven safety-first approach to keep the club in the PL for one more year

or

2) The Board believe Hodgson is the best option available to them to oversee a more radical change to youth.

or

3) The other managerial options available don't measure up to what the board is looking for.

Do I want Hodgson to stay? I don't have any strong feeling either way although there's always that part of one that wants to see the next chapter, a young and charismatic manager who will take one's club on an exciting journey (we can dream).

Finally, in response to the OPs thread opener, I don't see 11 points out of the last 7 games as a 'fantastic return', given the opposition we played. It was an ok return - we should have done better against Burnley (probably our worst performance of the season IMO) and put up a better display against Leeds.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Mar 21 10.35am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Roy out is a perfectly reasonable stance if you are not happy with the manner in which we play football and there are many who feel that way. Why do we have to come up with alternatives when we have absolutely zero impact on the decision of who should replace him. Wanting Roy out and who replaces him are two entirely separate subjects.

Would I back Roy for another year? Not with my money I won’t but the team will still get my support as it always does. The next time I visit SP will be when we have a different manager.


The problem I find with so much of the Roy out, argument, is the attitude that . Palace, have found themselves playing negative backs to the wall football ,on many occasions , purely because of Roy.
When the problem is that the squad he works with is just not strong enough to not have to play that way if we are to remain a top league competitor .
The truth being . Roy has done what he can ,with what he has got.
The bottom line is without drastic restructuring of the squad, there is not a manager you could hang your hat on to actually be successful in any real way, at CPFC.
It’s strange so many of the candidates put up are failures in their own right. Because they are supposed to be preferable to someone that has succeeded in difficult circumstances.
This is a repeat of what happened at Stoke. Teams like us need to be able to fall back on basics, when needed. It’s a fact we have to do it to often right now. So answer better players. Not get rid of the manager that gets performances out of average players, where many, including most put forward here for the job , wouldn’t.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Mar 21 11.01am

Originally posted by Putitout


The problem I find with so much of the Roy out, argument, is the attitude that . Palace, have found themselves playing negative backs to the wall football ,on many occasions , purely because of Roy.
When the problem is that the squad he works with is just not strong enough to not have to play that way if we are to remain a top league competitor .
The truth being . Roy has done what he can ,with what he has got.
The bottom line is without drastic restructuring of the squad, there is not a manager you could hang your hat on to actually be successful in any real way, at CPFC.
It’s strange so many of the candidates put up are failures in their own right. Because they are supposed to be preferable to someone that has succeeded in difficult circumstances.
This is a repeat of what happened at Stoke. Teams like us need to be able to fall back on basics, when needed. It’s a fact we have to do it to often right now. So answer better players. Not get rid of the manager that gets performances out of average players, where many, including most put forward here for the job , wouldn’t.

I’m afraid you have fallen for, along with the Roy in lot the, “only Roy could have done what he has done” argument, which in a way is the perfect argument because it can never be disproved. I just don’t happen to agree with it.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Mar 21 12.53pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I’m afraid you have fallen for, along with the Roy in lot the, “only Roy could have done what he has done” argument, which in a way is the perfect argument because it can never be disproved. I just don’t happen to agree with it.

It’s more an argument of. Only someone prepared to slum it regarding style as Roy has, will keep us in this division, without some major financing of a better squad of players. It’s not an , “I love Roy “, under any circumstance thing.
Give a manager the right financial support in the shape of a better squad and a change could be the right move. It’s not provable , one way or another, but there has been many comparisons to go by that would suggest , the transition to a successful, emphasis on a , “successful”, team, is very rarely achieved in one manager change, by teams of limited means.
Any way, Eagle, one of the beauties of football is the exchange of opinion and yours is every bit as valid as mine..I respect that.


 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 11 pts last 7 games, fantastic return