You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 26 Apr 21 10.33pm

What I would like to ask Roy and I would be extremely interested to know his thinking on this subject : Why has this club bought two players on loan with the club paying I would imagine large loan fees for Mateta and Bats only to be bench warmers. Is it a case that Freedman has bought these players in without his agreement or is it a case that they are not to Hodgson liking.
I am miffed to see the understanding as with tonight’s match 2:1 down 10minutes plus to go and he brings on McCarthy for Milo and Townsend for Ayew, I’m sorry but I just cannot see the logic. For me I would have bought on Mateta for Ayew Bats for Benteke Townsend for Milo pushed Kouyate into midfield and given Leicester something to think about.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 26 Apr 21 11.01pm

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

What I would like to ask Roy and I would be extremely interested to know his thinking on this subject : Why has this club bought two players on loan with the club paying I would imagine large loan fees for Mateta and Bats only to be bench warmers. Is it a case that Freedman has bought these players in without his agreement or is it a case that they are not to Hodgson liking.
I am miffed to see the understanding as with tonight’s match 2:1 down 10minutes plus to go and he brings on McCarthy for Milo and Townsend for Ayew, I’m sorry but I just cannot see the logic. For me I would have bought on Mateta for Ayew Bats for Benteke Townsend for Milo pushed Kouyate into midfield and given Leicester something to think about.

I totally agree

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

BlackBallsEagle Flag Maidstone 26 Apr 21 11.22pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

would be fantastic news if he was to stay.

fingers crossed

Are you drunk?

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 26 Apr 21 11.35pm

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

What I would like to ask Roy and I would be extremely interested to know his thinking on this subject : Why has this club bought two players on loan with the club paying I would imagine large loan fees for Mateta and Bats only to be bench warmers. Is it a case that Freedman has bought these players in without his agreement or is it a case that they are not to Hodgson liking.
I am miffed to see the understanding as with tonight’s match 2:1 down 10minutes plus to go and he brings on McCarthy for Milo and Townsend for Ayew, I’m sorry but I just cannot see the logic. For me I would have bought on Mateta for Ayew Bats for Benteke Townsend for Milo pushed Kouyate into midfield and given Leicester something to think about.

This is a club issue and not a Roy issue. For me, the manager has to work with the recruitment team to play the system the manager wants to play. The recruitment team cannot be going off doing its own thing.

Roy’s number one objective is to keep the club in the league. He has passed with flying colours.

But the recruitment policy is way off for me. We spent 26m odd on Sakho for Frank de Boar. Sakho was never a FdB signing. Forced upon by the board because he had done well on loan.

We then spent on Camerasa, 1.5m loan fee plus 3.5m in wages
Max Meyer 15m in wages plus signing on fee
Batshuayi 6m in wages plus loan fee
Matata 2m in wages, 18 month loan

Regardless of who the manager is, if you sign players that they do not fancy then it’s unlikely going to be an good investment.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Apr 21 11.41pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

This is a club issue and not a Roy issue. For me, the manager has to work with the recruitment team to play the system the manager wants to play. The recruitment team cannot be going off doing its own thing.

Roy’s number one objective is to keep the club in the league. He has passed with flying colours.

But the recruitment policy is way off for me. We spent 26m odd on Sakho for Frank de Boar. Sakho was never a FdB signing. Forced upon by the board because he had done well on loan.

We then spent on Camerasa, 1.5m loan fee plus 3.5m in wages
Max Meyer 15m in wages plus signing on fee
Batshuayi 6m in wages plus loan fee
Matata 2m in wages, 18 month loan

Regardless of who the manager is, if you sign players that they do not fancy then it’s unlikely going to be an good investment.

You might have seen on SKY today Carragher praising Leicester for their recruitment, finding players to replace the likes of Maguire,Mahrez, Drinkwater, Chilwell.They reported that the 'Net Spend' whilst Brendan Rodgers has been at the club (Since Feb 2019) has been a mere £9 Mill.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Apr 21 11.59pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

If he stays I will not be attending

Same. I’ve been saying it for a while. Thankfully this season wasn’t possible. Just nothing of interest to watch.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 21 12.06am

Originally posted by Willo

You might have seen on SKY today Carragher praising Leicester for their recruitment, finding players to replace the likes of Maguire,Mahrez, Drinkwater, Chilwell.They reported that the 'Net Spend' whilst Brendan Rodgers has been at the club (Since Feb 2019) has been a mere £9 Mill.

Yeah well they have been selling their players for fortunes to help net spend figures. They have signed several unproven players in this league or level, but they weren’t cheap

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Apr 21 12.23am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yeah well they have been selling their players for fortunes to help net spend figures. They have signed several unproven players in this league or level, but they weren’t cheap

A player they did sign who was cheap was James Justin who I think was acquired for £6 Mill from Luton.

I recall meeting a Luton supporter on holiday and I was singing the praises of Justin when he was still at the club,having seen him play, indeed I lavished praise on him in this country to certain people.

Justin can play in both full-back positions and he played a lot of games for Luton at left-back even though he is right-footed.He has even played in a midfield 'Diamond'.I wish we had bought him !!

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 27 Apr 21 6.43am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

This is a club issue and not a Roy issue. For me, the manager has to work with the recruitment team to play the system the manager wants to play. The recruitment team cannot be going off doing its own thing.

Roy’s number one objective is to keep the club in the league. He has passed with flying colours.

But the recruitment policy is way off for me. We spent 26m odd on Sakho for Frank de Boar. Sakho was never a FdB signing. Forced upon by the board because he had done well on loan.

We then spent on Camerasa, 1.5m loan fee plus 3.5m in wages
Max Meyer 15m in wages plus signing on fee
Batshuayi 6m in wages plus loan fee
Matata 2m in wages, 18 month loan

Regardless of who the manager is, if you sign players that they do not fancy then it’s unlikely going to be an good investment.


I really don’t agree with that, so are you saying that the club ? watch the training and matches then tells Roy who to pick and who not to pick if that is the case what is Roy doing here, why have a manager at all This is not a club issue it’s Roy issue it’s Roy who picks the the starting 11 and subs. Its Roy and his staff that take training and Roy who has the final says in who plays who doesn’t. Even if we had everyone fit and still had Meyer and everyone you have mentioned on the books It would still be the same starting eleven and basically the same tactics and the same subs tactics.
Yes I agree that Roy’s job is to keep this club in the Premiership, but as Roy has said it is Dougie’s job to bring in the players not mine. So is there no communication between Freedman and Hodgson, is it Freedman who is basically saying I pick the players who come in and you have to work with them like it or not. Or is it someone higher up in the club that gives Freedman a list of players.

Everybody associated with this club from the supporters to management have only been to aware that we have been short in the striker position and we have been crying out for a decent striker for ages. We bought in Alexander Sorloth I believe on Roy’s recommendation and what a turnip he turn out to be.Yes he had a very good season on loan and everyone was questioning if the club had made a mistake, but once again he has bombed and playing now as a main substitute.
Mateta and Bats have been bought into this club on high fees as you have mentioned and basically what are they doing ! Flip all in my opinion two good strikers sitting like book ends on the bench when we have the likes of Ayew and Benteke being picked and playing week in week out. Now that is down to the manager no one else.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Apr 21 8.43am

Originally posted by The Heath Eagle

Say that you love me.

All of the time.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Apr 21 8.52am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

This is a club issue and not a Roy issue. For me, the manager has to work with the recruitment team to play the system the manager wants to play. The recruitment team cannot be going off doing its own thing.

Roy’s number one objective is to keep the club in the league. He has passed with flying colours.

But the recruitment policy is way off for me. We spent 26m odd on Sakho for Frank de Boar. Sakho was never a FdB signing. Forced upon by the board because he had done well on loan.

We then spent on Camerasa, 1.5m loan fee plus 3.5m in wages
Max Meyer 15m in wages plus signing on fee
Batshuayi 6m in wages plus loan fee
Matata 2m in wages, 18 month loan

Regardless of who the manager is, if you sign players that they do not fancy then it’s unlikely going to be an good investment.


This is a major point that clearly needs addressing. It’s not like one or two signings. There has to be harmony with the team selector and the buyer of players. I’m never one to challenge the manager selection. But this is ridiculous.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 27 Apr 21 9.01am

So Roy keeps us up (which is his remit btw) using the players he feels are best for that job, he does this with many games to spare and it's ridiculous that he's not using the players on the bench more?...


Edited by A89M (27 Apr 2021 9.02am)

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 27 Apr 21 9.09am

Originally posted by A89M

So Roy keeps us up (which is his remit btw) using the players he feels are best for that job, he does this with many games to spare and it's ridiculous that he's not using the players on the bench more?...


Edited by A89M (27 Apr 2021 9.02am)

He has kept us up. That we are 11 points above the zone is also due to our having played most of the bottom half teams twice already, coupled with a very poor bottom three teams making life a lot easier at this stage than in most seasons. Let’s see how far up the table we are after 38 games

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 27 Apr 21 9.35am

Another season like this? I know for some of you this is our most successful period in our history. Does it have to be so depressing?

I know this argument has been going on for ages but is Roy the ONLY hope we have of staying in the PL?
If he is, then God help us.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

slubglurge Flag welling 27 Apr 21 6.56pm

When we finally go down and we will, the only thing we will have gained from our PL tenure w the academy. SP will still be a sh*thole and we will be back to square one. Our natural position in the football food chain is the Championship anyway

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 28 Apr 21 1.42am

It's like a slow death watching the same old players do the same old stuff week in week out.

Roy is sucking the life out of the club.

I can't see how we'll ever fill the stadium if he stays any longer

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 28 Apr 21 3.06am

I think the majority of palace supporters would welcome Hodgson to stay. The problem is the style of football we are playing and the tactics IF we played more attractive football instead of this negative sit back and defend and he actually was a little more daring in his team section I don’t think there would be a problem on that aspect.

The club is in a stale state Steve Parish himself has stated he wants European football at Palace and be a top 10 club we will never get that with this squad of players nor will will get that with the style of football we play.
I was interested to find out what other Palace managers have achieved in a win percentage, to be honest I was quite surprised how low Hodgson score was, I was expecting a higher win rate to be honest Hodgson has a 33.33% win rate out of 156 games at present Won 52 drawn 37 Lost 67.
Two other Palace managers have achieved this win percentage
With far less games with Neil Warnock Tony Pullis and Sam Allerdyce fairing better.
games Won drawn lost
Kit Simmons 9. 3 3 3 33.33%
Keith Millen 3 1 0 2 33.33%
Tony Pullis 28. 12 5 11 42.86%
Sam Allardyce 24 9 3 12 37.50%
Neil Warnock first stint as manager
129 47 39 43 36.43%

Edited by manwitheagletattoo (28 Apr 2021 3.10am)

Edited by manwitheagletattoo (28 Apr 2021 3.10am)

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy