This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Top celebrity hypocrite. I hope he falls. I doubt it though. His worshippers are too thick, whether they’re wokies or armchair football gazers.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
The criteria are relatively clear and have not changed in decades despite the rhetoric I have won significant cases of this type against HMRC and also the Spanish tax authorities. They struggle to understand their own rules On the other hand, as an outsider it doesn’t look like lineker is clearly outside IR35. Time to get the popcorn out. The whole issue seems ridiculously complicated, interesting the some “celebs” have been successful whilst others failed. It would seem Lineker admits”owing some”. Get the popcorn out indeed
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
In the US the IRS got Congress to pass a law that any tax avoidance scheme has to be approved by them. So if a clever accountant comes up with a wheeze he has to get it approved by the IRS. We need something similar over here. The default should be if in doubt check before you proceed and get HMRC approval. It would save a lot of pain for the taxpayer and also the person involved would know that what they are doing is legal. Obviously this type of thing would impact impact a minority of people as the rules for the rest of us are pretty clear. The IRS is worse by far than HMRC. And in the US you also have State and City taxes. Crossing State boundaries is a nightmare. The problem largely is that HMRC hires low capability people and those that are able tend to jump sides and work in tax planning. For example, only two people in HMRC understand how it works if you do some work in Jersey and some on the mainland. And one of those is on long-term sick leave with stress. Edited by Mapletree (07 May 2021 9.54am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
The IRS is worse by far than HMRC. And in the US you also have State and City taxes. Crossing State boundaries is a nightmare. For example, only two people in HMRC understand how it works if you do some work in Jersey and some on the mainland. And one of those is on long-term sick leave with stress. Edited by Mapletree (07 May 2021 9.54am) Yup I get that because if you are any good you work on the other side. That's why I made my suggestion accountants will always push the envelope but if they are required to get approval both they and their clients will know what they are getting into and HMRC has to decide if it wants to fight a scheme or not. The other thing to do is to simplify the tax system the more complicated it is the more it favours the tax dodgers. Dumb it down so you don't need rocket scientists at HMRC just good people.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by mezzer
If he loses his home will that make the asylum seeker he took in homeless? Or will a homeless person take him in? And I'm not getting the popcorn out. I've a MASSIVE bag of Walkers though. I believe said gentleman stayed a Chez Gary for a number of weeks we on the other hand will have to support him for a lifetime.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Yup I get that because if you are any good you work on the other side. That's why I made my suggestion accountants will always push the envelope but if they are required to get approval both they and their clients will know what they are getting into and HMRC has to decide if it wants to fight a scheme or not. The other thing to do is to simplify the tax system the more complicated it is the more it favours the tax dodgers. Dumb it down so you don't need rocket scientists at HMRC just good people. We operate on common law not a Napoleonic system. You can’t legislate for every twist and turn.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Yup I get that because if you are any good you work on the other side. That's why I made my suggestion accountants will always push the envelope but if they are required to get approval both they and their clients will know what they are getting into and HMRC has to decide if it wants to fight a scheme or not. The other thing to do is to simplify the tax system the more complicated it is the more it favours the tax dodgers. Dumb it down so you don't need rocket scientists at HMRC just good people. HMRC should hire from the private sector. I applied for a job, rejected as I didn’t have a degree. Qualified Chartered Accountant but no degree = failed at first sift!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I believe said gentleman stayed a Chez Gary for a number of weeks we on the other hand will have to support him for a lifetime. I wonder how that's treated for tax purposes. Can he write it off under marketing expenses?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.