You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The real reason............
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The real reason............


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 17 May 21 10.36pm

This really does get tedious, if Roy thought we had youngsters good enough to play he would pick them. Why on earth would he do otherwise?

He has his favourites yadda yadda yadda, he sees the players in training unlike any of us, and surprisingly he picks the players he thinks are best suited to win the game.


Some on here really do need to give their head a wobble!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 17 May 21 10.52pm

Originally posted by kev64

Tragic post .. big Sam bought JS , Pva and Luka in 17 , 4 years later they are regular prem first team players with relatively little outlay .. Pva I would say is off, JS is actually missed when not playing and Luka may be past his best but he cost 6m, so we real value tbh.

Roy didn’t spend big on Tekkers or Sakho .. in fact the only real purchases have been Sorloth (some how we hoodwinked RBL into 20m) and Eze last season who will seem a bargain at 20 mill or so.

Roy’s remit is to keep us in the PL that’s it , it’s about hard cash .. ask any Sunderland, Portsmouth etc etc if they would like to be bored with PL football or stuck in Div 1 for years. Unless there is big investment in the team then Roy will stick with what he has as it works and that’s the job he’s given by our board.

So yes it’s hard to watch but until we get 37-40 points on the board we will predominately play the percentages and win ten against the bottom ten and pick up a few points against the top 6 .. winning at old Trafford etc. Every team in from 10th place down is in exactly the same position ..

You have hit the nail on the head. The lower divisions are littered with former premier teams that would give their right arm to swap places.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 May 21 11.03pm

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

Surely one could make a case for a youngster showing his potential once he is in the first team. Would AWB have been put on the field otherwise if we weren't rife with injuries or Mitchell ?

I sometimes feel that giving a youngster the limelight sometimes prompts them into showing what ability they have and some will be up to standard and some won't.

What i dont understand is the reluctance to try 1 or 2 in the last 10 mins when he usually feels is the right time for a sub. Especially now we are safe it would be nice to see a couple of the upcoming talents. I mean they have shown the possess some great qualities in their respective divisions in U18 and U23.

Is it not quite feasible that our manager hasn't the option to try these youngsters, he is answerable to his actions the same as any employer, nobody really has any clue what happens behind the scenes.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 May 21 11.04pm

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

This really does get tedious, if Roy thought we had youngsters good enough to play he would pick them. Why on earth would he do otherwise?

He has his favourites yadda yadda yadda, he sees the players in training unlike any of us, and surprisingly he picks the players he thinks are best suited to win the game.


Some on here really do need to give their head a wobble!

Sadly too many.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 May 21 11.20pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Really ? Could you honestly see Roy doing what Leicester done on Saturday and stick in a 19 year old in the cup final, or what Sheff Utd did yesterday by playing a 17 year old up front ?

I read somewhere today in one of those 'News Now' features, he was trying to justify having three goalkeepers in yesterday's squad, and saying that he could have put one of the U23's on the bench but it was pointless as they wouldn't have played no matter what.

Leicester are quite a bit above us in the pecking order and because of this they are able to attract the desired youngster's, Sheff.U are completely stuck in the position they are currently in ..we can move upwards and did.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 17 May 21 11.44pm

I don't think we over paid for Benteke. Perhaps Sakho to some extent. That's what players cost of that standard. Players that are proven, available and willing to join Crystal Palace would not be falling over themselves to join.

Many clubs buy players that cost more and fail but we do not scrutinise them.

[Link]

Islam Slimani was linked with us. That would have been a disaster. Arguably Benteke and Sakho made us a lot stronger at points.

I do think we should have better networking. Brentford have better recruitment knowledge than we do.

 

EddieMac Flag 18 May 21 6.33am

Originally posted by glaziermart

No it won't change my mind. Compared to what Pulis inherited, it was by contrast an embarrassment of riches. We also had players like Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek in addition to most of the players we have now who were younger. I'm sorry, but those of us with longer memories cannot remember squads as talented as this with internationals everywhere

In my view comparing what Pulis had to now is not really worth comparing. Every team in the division has strengthened massively over those years which leaves us basically in the same position. I am not disagreeing that on the face of it it looks like we have the best squad ever assembled at Palace but the flaws are massive.

 

EddieMac Flag 18 May 21 6.39am

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I don't think we over paid for Benteke. Perhaps Sakho to some extent. That's what players cost of that standard. Players that are proven, available and willing to join Crystal Palace would not be falling over themselves to join.

Many clubs buy players that cost more and fail but we do not scrutinise them.

[Link]

Islam Slimani was linked with us. That would have been a disaster. Arguably Benteke and Sakho made us a lot stronger at points.

I do think we should have better networking. Brentford have better recruitment knowledge than we do.

We certainly didn’t pay over the odds for Benteke. Brewster, Solanke, McBurnie come to mind as recent signings around the 20 mill mark.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 May 21 9.53am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Leicester are quite a bit above us in the pecking order and because of this they are able to attract the desired youngster's, Sheff.U are completely stuck in the position they are currently in ..we can move upwards and did.

Also, Leicester have better players to enable youngsters to come through, like Chelsea.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 May 21 9.57am

Originally posted by EddieMac

We certainly didn’t pay over the odds for Benteke. Brewster, Solanke, McBurnie come to mind as recent signings around the 20 mill mark.

Sakho was also priced and salaried at his market rate. While I do appreciate his one-moment-madness EVERY game, he would have been first name on the team sheet and something of a Palace legend had he stayed fit. Now he is just that bloke who cost £££, gave the ball away to Vardy, and was always injured.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 18 May 21 12.06pm

If I have to read the words "young hungry" one more time on this forum I'll break my balls in the car door.

 

billy pete Flag bridgend - near cardiff 18 May 21 12.30pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

If I have to read the words "young hungry" one more time on this forum I'll break my balls in the car door.

Is that because you're old & jealous lol

 


always n' forever red n' blue !!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The real reason............