You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ward, Townsend, Cahill
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ward, Townsend, Cahill


Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8
beak Flag croydon 22 Jul 21 12.07pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Lost Townsend,now Cahill has rejected a new deal.

Short sightedness by SP??

[Link]

Cahill is far to slow look at the Liverpool 7-0. Cahill got 3.91 from the BBC fan vote in thingy.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 22 Jul 21 12.09pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Not at all.

He was offered what we thought he was worth.

In my opinion his best playing days are well behind him although Cahill would have been useful for his experience when required.

But that doesn't justify meeting his financial demands

Yes this sums it up... his experience for the new young CBs would have been great, but it would have to be on our terms. I can't blame him for taking one last shot at glory with Rangers but it will be a loss even if that's just in the dressing room.

 

The Dolphin Flag 22 Jul 21 12.21pm

Cahill is/was a great player and it would be great to have him again next season if only for the experience he can bring to the squad.
however - for the first time - it seems - we have a structure which we intend to work to and his demands didn't match our expectations.
Great shame but we must cut our cloth - it will be better in the long run - as long as we stay up this season!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Jul 21 12.23pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Lost Townsend,now Cahill has rejected a new deal.

Short sightedness by SP??

[Link]

I would be surprised if Rangers can match our offer of money, maybe it's the glory or a longer contract?

 


One more point

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Jul 21 1.41pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Lost Townsend,now Cahill has rejected a new deal.

Short sightedness by SP??

[Link]

They were offered new deals in line with performances, they chose not to except.
Cahill is coming up 36 years old, is £65k a week a good deal for Palace. I doubt many will think so.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jul 21 1.48pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I would be surprised if Rangers can match our offer of money, maybe it's the glory or a longer contract?

Possibly both (certainly the former) but also how likely he is to play as well?

Geuhi will (presumably) play. Tomkins is fit again and should play. Kouyate could move back into the midfield of course, but equally, he could play at the back. A few on here seem to like the look of the young Australian lad the size of a small house from the u23s.

Rangers have good centre backs (Goldson I like), but not sure what their strength in depth is at the back, and if they get into the group stages of the CL, they will have more game sot share around a smaller pool than us.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Jul 21 1.59pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Lost Townsend,now Cahill has rejected a new deal.

Short sightedness by SP??

[Link]


No, SP is sticking to whatever the new wage structure is intended to be IMO. The gravy train for seasoned PL pros has now left Selhurst Park (hopefully for good). Neither Townsend nor Cahill were prepared to accept that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jul 21 2.05pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Possibly both (certainly the former) but also how likely he is to play as well?

Geuhi will (presumably) play. Tomkins is fit again and should play. Kouyate could move back into the midfield of course, but equally, he could play at the back. A few on here seem to like the look of the young Australian lad the size of a small house from the u23s.

Rangers have good centre backs (Goldson I like), but not sure what their strength in depth is at the back, and if they get into the group stages of the CL, they will have more game sot share around a smaller pool than us.

Connor Goldson, Ex-Brighton !!!
He used to go to Molyneux as a youngster.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Jul 21 2.15pm

. Deleted duplicate

Edited by doombear (22 Jul 2021 2.16pm)

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 22 Jul 21 2.20pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Lost Townsend,now Cahill has rejected a new deal.

Short sightedness by SP??

[Link]

He’s 35 , spent a fair time injured last season, worth a punt at maybe 20k a week as a back up tbh now , would be like Defoe at rangers a bit part player just taking cash in a sub standard league…I guess he can add the Scottish league to his cabinet..

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Jul 21 2.36pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Not at all.

He was offered what we thought he was worth.

In my opinion his best playing days are well behind him although Cahill would have been useful for his experience when required.

But that doesn't justify meeting his financial demands

Totally agree - i like Cahill but he wasn't fast when we bought him 2 years ago and is clearly slower now.

He's had a few injuries too and struggled in a few games last season when teams moved the ball quickly (Liverpool and Leeds spring to mind).

With Tomkins' (and to a lesser extent Kelly's) injury record i would not be opposed to him re-signing for 1 more year but it has to be the right financial package for the club and a lower basic with some performance bonuses was clearly the way to go.


He is perfectly entitled to decline the offer.

Can't see Rangers offering him more though - maybe a less demanding league and potential silverware makes some sense at his age.

Edited by palace99 (22 Jul 2021 2.37pm)

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 22 Jul 21 2.52pm

Agreed

Published figures may be out of course but his wages would be out of all proportion at Rangers - coming in as their highest earner possibly if I read Sportrac right. Looks a natural move for him but ...

Originally posted by palace99

Totally agree - i like Cahill but he wasn't fast when we bought him 2 years ago and is clearly slower now.

He's had a few injuries too and struggled in a few games last season when teams moved the ball quickly (Liverpool and Leeds spring to mind).

With Tomkins' (and to a lesser extent Kelly's) injury record i would not be opposed to him re-signing for 1 more year but it has to be the right financial package for the club and a lower basic with some performance bonuses was clearly the way to go.


He is perfectly entitled to decline the offer.

Can't see Rangers offering him more though - maybe a less demanding league and potential silverware makes some sense at his age.

Edited by palace99 (22 Jul 2021 2.37pm)

 

Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ward, Townsend, Cahill