You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pele - Overrated Charlatan
November 22 2026 7.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pele - Overrated Charlatan


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 27 Jul 21 5.15am

He's the football equivilent of Mother Theresa.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 28 Jul 21 6.11pm

Maradona may have been an odious piece of work but it cannot be denied he was a brilliant and mesmerizing footballer. Rarely can one man inspire a team the way he did.

He was skillful and although short, he was as strong as an ox.

Souness said that when he tried a hard challenge on Maradona, he "just bounced off".

He's at the top of my list.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 28 Jul 21 6.26pm

i think the main problem is that nobody in europe ever saw him play other than in a world cup, he played in an era where players played in their own country.

however, you cant argue with a goal a game over 650 apps for club and almost a goal a game at national level, still being brazils all time top goalscorer whilst lifting 3 world cups!


on a other note, if somebody offered me both ronaldo’s at their peak without injury i would take the brazilian one anyday.

Edited by braunstoneagle (28 Jul 2021 6.32pm)

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Orange1290 Flag 29 Jul 21 6.19am

He was a brilliant player, one of the very best. Far too many simply follow other people's viewpoint just to feel 'part' of something. It's become fashionable to criticise Pele's amazing footballing career just for criticism's sake and many doing so never even saw him play, particularly in his home league and country.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Jul 21 7.20am

Originally posted by Orange1290

He was a brilliant player, one of the very best. Far too many simply follow other people's viewpoint just to feel 'part' of something. It's become fashionable to criticise Pele's amazing footballing career just for criticism's sake and many doing so never even saw him play, particularly in his home league and country.

The treatment he got in 1966, I believe against Italy, probably outlines what a great player he was and how he was feared by any opponent.
People think Wilf and Grealish get kicked all over the park, try and find a video of that game, it was brutal but also criminal.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Jul 21 8.23am

Originally posted by Orange1290

He was a brilliant player, one of the very best. Far too many simply follow other people's viewpoint just to feel 'part' of something. It's become fashionable to criticise Pele's amazing footballing career just for criticism's sake and many doing so never even saw him play, particularly in his home league and country.

For once we agree.

I can separate the man from the player, the man has some questionable attitudes and arrogance the player was one of the greatest if not GOAT.

The thing about the 1000 goals was a publicity stunt by the Americans apparently Pele never gave much credence to it.

If he hadn't have been a great I don't think his reputation would have lasted, it has. You can argue who is GOAT but there is no doubt in my mind that he should be in the mix up.

 


One more point

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 29 Jul 21 10.57am

I have seen all the usual names listed play including Pele and the obvious factor is that people seldom agree about who is the best.

Pele played the bulk of his games in Brazil so was not watched by Europeans in the same way that competing players were.

Personally I enjoyed watching Cruyff a pure majestic player.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jul 21 11.46am

Pele certainly had a couple of great world cups but needed to play in the best leagues too, if he was going to be the greatest. Anyway, he must have done something right - we're still talking about him.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 29 Jul 21 5.01pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

The treatment he got in 1966, I believe against Italy, probably outlines what a great player he was and how he was feared by any opponent.
People think Wilf and Grealish get kicked all over the park, try and find a video of that game, it was brutal but also criminal.

Brazil didn't play Italy in 1966, so their serial fouling - expertly demonstrated in the Euro 2020 final - wasn't a factor on that occasion. Portugal certainly kicked him about in the final group game.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 29 Jul 21 5.07pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

The treatment he got in 1966, I believe against Italy, probably outlines what a great player he was and how he was feared by any opponent.
People think Wilf and Grealish get kicked all over the park, try and find a video of that game, it was brutal but also criminal.

From an article in The Guardian.

"Their best player, Pelé, was kicked so much in the first game against Bulgaria (“I think every team will take care of him in the same manner,” said their coach) that he could play no part in the second, a 3-1 defeat by Hungary when Brazil had two goals disallowed, and he then spent much of the third as a virtual spectator after Portugal’s João Morais fouled him and, when he tried to get up and play on, fouled him again a bit harder."

For what it is worth I think it is quite ridiculous to outrightly dismiss him as a player and to make meaningless comparisons with players from other eras.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 01 Aug 21 11.21am

You know a Brazilian that people always forget? Rivaldo. He was amazing, better than Ronaldo, Roberto Carlos and on par with Ronaldinho.
If I could pick any Brazilian to be in our current team it would be him (well, not current day Rivaldo, obviously)

 

crvenaeagle Flag 01 Aug 21 11.27am

Originally posted by ASCPFC
Anyway, he must have done something right - we're still talking about him.

The Simpsons put it perfectly;
[Link]

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pele - Overrated Charlatan