This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| glaziermart |
|
|---|---|
|
Outstanding talent, but still only just 18. No reason to rush him yet
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jaha
Hey guys, Just wondering if you guys knew why Omilabu wasn't featured the other day? Looks like Rob Street is getting the nod ahead of him at the moment. Obviously Omilabu was lethal last season for the U18's and 21's. Do you guys think its too early for him? Is he injured? From what I've seen of him, he looks positionally very good, kind of similar to Defoe I feel. What do you guys think? I believe he had a slight injury but not sure he quite ready for step up yet
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every single one of them is ready when they're ready, if they're ever ready at all. As long as I can remember Palace have had promising youngsters at the club, but the chasm between that status and being not only a professional footballer, not only a top flight player, but one who will improve a solid mid table side more than anything we can get on the market, well, that's more than most can ever navigate. We shouldn't mislead ourselves into believing that the new academy is a guarantee of first team players. It's remarkably hard to make it. Any kids that do are still a bonus, not an entitlement. Very astute post. Why is that Toe Punt? What is that fine line that makes Saka good enough for England but our boy not ready for PalAce if ever? Got to be honest and say if I watch a game of our juniors I just think half of them should be in the first team. I’m definitely not football management material.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every single one of them is ready when they're ready, if they're ever ready at all. As long as I can remember Palace have had promising youngsters at the club, but the chasm between that status and being not only a professional footballer, not only a top flight player, but one who will improve a solid mid table side more than anything we can get on the market, well, that's more than most can ever navigate. We shouldn't mislead ourselves into believing that the new academy is a guarantee of first team players. It's remarkably hard to make it. Any kids that do are still a bonus, not an entitlement. I garland these comments with praise and concurrence. In terms of young players, Eze was rejected as a youngster by Arsenal,Fulham and Reading and he failed to get a professional contract at Millwall after 2 years at the club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
Since we got Category one status for our academy last year, I certainly feel a lot more confident we will see more stars of the future coming through. We are now nicking youngsters that used to go to Chelsea and Arsenal. Steve Parish has said we will have an academy that will rival Man City in the future
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every single one of them is ready when they're ready, if they're ever ready at all. As long as I can remember Palace have had promising youngsters at the club, but the chasm between that status and being not only a professional footballer, not only a top flight player, but one who will improve a solid mid table side more than anything we can get on the market, well, that's more than most can ever navigate. We shouldn't mislead ourselves into believing that the new academy is a guarantee of first team players. It's remarkably hard to make it. Any kids that do are still a bonus, not an entitlement. Totally agree. I do sense a mentality switch at Palace which could see younger prospects fast tracked. That wasn't happening over the past few years, but the advent of the Academy development has coincided with a promising crop of youngsters.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Very astute post. Why is that Toe Punt? What is that fine line that makes Saka good enough for England but our boy not ready for PalAce if ever? Got to be honest and say if I watch a game of our juniors I just think half of them should be in the first team. I’m definitely not football management material. Saka is ready for England because that's how good he is. The only common denominator between him and Omilabu is that they are young footballers - hundreds and hundreds of them up and down the Country didn't play for England and never will. The proportion of young pros who play for England is probably about the same as the proportion of youth players who get to the first team - i.e. tiny. I'm sure you don't need me to tell you that on those days when you've seen the youth team look really good, they were playing against other youth teams, not against senior players in a premier league game. I hate to piss in anyone's cornflakes, but above and beyond needing a young team, we need a good one. Too many seem inclined to mistake the former for the latter. I've no reason to say that the best of the current crop won't make it - I hope they do, and at Palace too - but the upgrades to the academy are simply an exercise in giving us a level playing field when it comes to attracting and retaining players in the hideously competitive cattle market of youth football. That's vital, and the club is right to do it, but we should be clear that whilst academy investment increases the chances of producing first-team players, no amount of facilities and coaches can bring certainty to the development of young footballers. The club can actively pursue a business plan of leaving gaps in the squad for your graduates, offering both a pathway for in-house youth, a sales-pitch to the likes of Olise, and a sensible economic strategy, but nothing can overcome the simple basic fact that very few young players make it. Edited by TheBigToePunt (27 Jul 2021 12.28pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Saka is ready for England because that's how good he is. The only common denominator between him and Omilabu is that they are young footballers - hundreds and hundreds of them up and down the Country didn't play for England and never will. The proportion of young pros who play for England is probably about the same as the proportion of youth players who get to the first team - i.e. tiny. I'm sure you don't need me to tell you that on those days when you've seen the youth team look really good, they were playing against other youth teams, not against senior players in a premier league game. I hate to piss in anyone's cornflakes, but above and beyond needing a young team, we need a good one. Too many seem inclined to mistake the former for the latter. I've no reason to say that the best of the current crop won't make it - I hope they do, and at Palace too - but the upgrades to the academy are simply an exercise in giving us a level playing field when it comes to attracting and retaining players in the hideously competitive cattle market of youth football. That's vital, and the club is right to do it, but we should be clear that whilst academy investment increases the chances of producing first-team players, no amount of facilities and coaches can bring certainty to the development of young footballers. The club can actively pursue a business plan of leaving gaps in the squad for your graduates, offering both a pathway for in-house youth, a sales-pitch to the likes of Olise, and a sensible economic strategy, but nothing can overcome the simple basic fact that very few young players make it. Edited by TheBigToePunt (27 Jul 2021 12.28pm) My views entirely.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.