You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Wayne Rooney Vs Thierry Henry
November 22 2026 7.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wayne Rooney Vs Thierry Henry


Robert Heenan Flag East Cheshire 06 Aug 21 2.21pm

Around mid 2000's and especially around 2004-2006, the media would hype up Thierry Henry to be the best footballer not only in England, but the world. I remember the countless discussions and debates on talksport and on the BBC 606 forum regarding just how supposedly great Thierry Henry supposedly was. There were huge comparisons with Wayne Rooney but to me Henry was simply an arrogant bully. Thierry Henry had enormous pace and i believe that was his main attribute. He needed plenty of space in behind teams to work his one trick pony stuff. Against thick teams like little Fulham -it worked but against good teams like italian teams of that era then he was completeky nullified like in the 2006 world cup final.He certainly didn't have the technical ability and intelligence as Wayne Rooney had in huge abundance. Wayne Rooney was a phenomenon who, if he hadn't got injured at Stamford Bridge back in April 2006, would surely have been mentioned alongside Ronaldo and Messi as the greatest player of that generation. I believe Rooney could have surpassed both of them. Remember back in November 2005 when he ran rings around the great Roberto Ayala and completely outshone both Messi and Riquelme as he led England to a 3-2 win over Argentina in a very competetive friendly match. How about in Euro 2004 when he completely outshone Zidane until the disastrous last minute and injury time when David James and Heskey threw it away.

Wayne Rooney was a footballer head and shoulders above Henry in terms of pure footballing attribute. I also blame Sir Alex because he didn't let Rooney play with freedom. Wayne was selfless in just how committed he was in helping the cause...often tracking back to the left back position to help out. Just an outstanding talent who was handled disastrously.

I believe he would have been Englands answer to Maradona and single-handedly won England a world cup if he had been handeled correctly and not been injured back in April 2006

As far as Henry is concerned...not good enough to even lace Waynes boots.

Comparing Thierry "aloof" and "arrogant" Henry to Wayne Rooney is like comparing dog poo to Ice Cream.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Aug 21 2.24pm

Originally posted by Robert Heenan

Around mid 2000's and especially around 2004-2006, the media would hype up Thierry Henry to be the best footballer not only in England, but the world. I remember the countless discussions and debates on talksport and on the BBC 606 forum regarding just how supposedly great Thierry Henry supposedly was. There were huge comparisons with Wayne Rooney but to me Henry was simply an arrogant bully. Thierry Henry had enormous pace and i believe that was his main attribute. He needed plenty of space in behind teams to work his one trick pony stuff. Against thick teams like little Fulham -it worked but against good teams like italian teams of that era then he was completeky nullified like in the 2006 world cup final.He certainly didn't have the technical ability and intelligence as Wayne Rooney had in huge abundance. Wayne Rooney was a phenomenon who, if he hadn't got injured at Stamford Bridge back in April 2006, would surely have been mentioned alongside Ronaldo and Messi as the greatest player of that generation. I believe Rooney could have surpassed both of them. Remember back in November 2005 when he ran rings around the great Roberto Ayala and completely outshone both Messi and Riquelme as he led England to a 3-2 win over Argentina in a very competetive friendly match. How about in Euro 2004 when he completely outshone Zidane until the disastrous last minute and injury time when David James and Heskey threw it away.

Wayne Rooney was a footballer head and shoulders above Henry in terms of pure footballing attribute. I also blame Sir Alex because he didn't let Rooney play with freedom. Wayne was selfless in just how committed he was in helping the cause...often tracking back to the left back position to help out. Just an outstanding talent who was handled disastrously.

I believe he would have been Englands answer to Maradona and single-handedly won England a world cup if he had been handeled correctly and not been injured back in April 2006

As far as Henry is concerned...not good enough to even lace Waynes boots.

Comparing Thierry "aloof" and "arrogant" Henry to Wayne Rooney is like comparing dog poo to Ice Cream.

Be a good MMA match up. Not sure I agree, but I have been relatively impressed with Rooney's determination at Derby. Many would walk away.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 06 Aug 21 2.44pm

Why don't you get off the fence Robert, and tell us what you really think?

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Aug 21 3.27pm

Man u fan prefers wozza to tel Henry shock.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 06 Aug 21 3.40pm

It was more than a decade ago, I though something had happened between them now....

However, to say that Henry didn't have the technically ability or intelligence is just plan wrong.

Both world class but who would I want, at their best, in our squad, for the upcoming season???

Henry...

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Aug 21 4.35pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

It was more than a decade ago, I though something had happened between them now....

However, to say that Henry didn't have the technically ability or intelligence is just plan wrong.

Both world class but who would I want, at their best, in our squad, for the upcoming season???

Henry...

Agree, it's a decent comparison, but to suggest Henry was anything other than world class is way off.

To suggest he wasn't effective against good teams is just demonstrably untrue - his performance at the Bernebeau in 2006 jumps out straight away.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 06 Aug 21 5.18pm

There was a time when there was a debate about the relative merits of Rooney, compared to Ronaldo.

Ronaldo moved on to genuine greatness whereas Rooney stagnated in comparison.

I think Rooney did not fulfil his full potential.
Whether it was because of a lack of commitment on his part or poor management of his career or both, who knows.

I think Rooney should have been let loose to be a real 100% striker. He did score a lot of goals but his strike rate could have been prodigious.

I think most would choose Henry over Rooney.

Edited by Eaglehamster (06 Aug 2021 5.20pm)

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Aug 21 5.30pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

There was a time when there was a debate about the relative merits of Rooney, compared to Ronaldo.

Ronaldo moved on to genuine greatness whereas Rooney stagnated in comparison.

I think Rooney did not fulfil his full potential.
Whether it was because of a lack of commitment on his part or poor management of his career or both, who knows.

I think Rooney should have been let loose to be a real 100% striker. He did score a lot of goals but his strike rate could have been prodigious.

I think most would choose Henry over Rooney.

Edited by Eaglehamster (06 Aug 2021 5.20pm)

You're not wrong, but I think it's also quite telling that Rooney retired as England and Utd's all time top-scorer and is still probably considered to have underachieved. His talent was ridiculous.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 06 Aug 21 5.51pm

Another gauge would be, who would you want in your management team.

I think I saw a "report" in the click bait news that Henry was leaving the Belgium setup up to come and give Vieira a hand..

Can you imagine. You may as well remove the entrance door to the Academy and put water stations all along the road outside to deal with the queues of young players trying to get in.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 06 Aug 21 6.39pm

I believe the stats for prem all time goals scored And for prem all time assists....prove Rooney was far better.

Dunno why the BBC loves Thierry Henry so much ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Aug 21 8.50pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You're not wrong, but I think it's also quite telling that Rooney retired as England and Utd's all time top-scorer and is still probably considered to have underachieved. His talent was ridiculous.

Look at Jimmy Greaves England record.
Goals per game and goals per minute blow everyone else out of the water.
None of his England goals were penalties either.
That's a ridiculous talent.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 07 Aug 21 11.04am

Originally posted by sickboy

Look at Jimmy Greaves England record.
Goals per game and goals per minute blow everyone else out of the water.
None of his England goals were penalties either.
That's a ridiculous talent.

Well they're both ridiculous talents, yes.

Comparisons across generations like that are pretty pointless.

 

Yannick selassie Flag Penge 07 Aug 21 11.46am

Henry was unquestionably better at dribbling and most probably finishing his eye for a through ball was unreal his composure was second to none his first touch and hold up play was also up there with the best combine that all and tell me Rooney was a better player I think you’re having a laugh mate...you might not like Thierry as a person but to come here and announce that Rooney was a better player you must be chasing the dragon mate...if you hate Henry so much why don’t you send him a tweet instead of making random false proclamations on the holmesdale 🤷🏽‍♂️

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Aug 21 12.13pm

Originally posted by Yannick selassie

Henry was unquestionably better at dribbling and most probably finishing his eye for a through ball was unreal his composure was second to none his first touch and hold up play was also up there with the best combine that all and tell me Rooney was a better player I think you’re having a laugh mate...you might not like Thierry as a person but to come here and announce that Rooney was a better player you must be chasing the dragon mate...if you hate Henry so much why don’t you send him a tweet instead of making random false proclamations on the holmesdale 🤷🏽‍♂️

Or just have a different opinion. If that’s allowed.

 

SpyroCrystal 07 Aug 21 12.23pm

Rooney was epic 04-06 but overall Henry for me

 


Big up the Palace!!!!

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 07 Aug 21 12.57pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Well they're both ridiculous talents, yes.

Comparisons across generations like that are pretty pointless.

As are comparisons between 2 very different players in Rooney and Henry.
The only thing they have in common is their positions as forwards, and even those are only vague ,cover all, descriptions.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 07 Aug 21 1.09pm

Originally posted by sickboy

As are comparisons between 2 very different players in Rooney and Henry.
The only thing they have in common is their positions as forwards, and even those are only vague ,cover all, descriptions.

The only thing they have in common is that they played in the same position, in the same league, in roughly the same era.

It's obviously a much better comparison than someone who played in a different century.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 07 Aug 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

The only thing they have in common is that they played in the same position, in the same league, in roughly the same era.

It's obviously a much better comparison than someone who played in a different century.

Of course , because you are always right.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 08 Aug 21 8.51am

Originally posted by Yannick selassie

Henry was unquestionably better at dribbling and most probably finishing his eye for a through ball was unreal his composure was second to none his first touch and hold up play was also up there with the best combine that all and tell me Rooney was a better player I think you’re having a laugh mate...you might not like Thierry as a person but to come here and announce that Rooney was a better player you must be chasing the dragon mate...if you hate Henry so much why don’t you send him a tweet instead of making random false proclamations on the holmesdale 🤷🏽‍♂️

Rooney cheats in the bedroom. Thierry cheats on the pitch.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Wayne Rooney Vs Thierry Henry