This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Back 3?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
deleted 25 21 Sep 21 4.41pm |
|
|
Think the 3 Liverpool goals originated from set pieces so think maybe we could do with something a bit like Chelsea employ
Think Tomkins inbetween our current centre backs who are both useful on the ball would give us better defence against teams with height advantage keeping in mind we have Brighton next
Wing backs are fine in a midfield 4.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 21 Sep 21 4.57pm |
|
|
Not sure we have any wingbacks.....
And who would drop out?
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Sep 21 5.17pm |
|
|
I just don't think we can implement this until we're a bit safer in the table. We certainly have a couple who could go into the three. However, we wouldn't have the wing backs for the usual system. I wouldn't fancy Ward and Mitchell to bomb forwards and backwards for most of the game. Mitchell a work in progress - looks good sometimes. Ward fine, but not the best going forward. Currently, we'd be losing an attacking player or midfielder if we did it and not gaining much from the wing backs. I think Banks plays as a wing back sometimes, but he's not great at defending, in my opinion, and probably not quite ready. Later in the season with 38 points on the board, I can imagine seeing it. I think we need to get the current system going a bit more first. There are definite changes in roles and patterns that we haven't quite got fully used to yet.
Red and Blue Army!
|
deleted 25 21 Sep 21 5.55pm |
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Not sure we have any wingbacks.....
And who would drop out?
Wingbacks could be Mitchell and Ward / another
Could be Kouyate and maybe Ayew for Milovejic
|
deleted 25 21 Sep 21 6.04pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I just don't think we can implement this until we're a bit safer in the table. We certainly have a couple who could go into the three. However, we wouldn't have the wing backs for the usual system. I wouldn't fancy Ward and Mitchell to bomb forwards and backwards for most of the game. Mitchell a work in progress - looks good sometimes. Ward fine, but not the best going forward. Currently, we'd be losing an attacking player or midfielder if we did it and not gaining much from the wing backs. I think Banks plays as a wing back sometimes, but he's not great at defending, in my opinion, and probably not quite ready. Later in the season with 38 points on the board, I can imagine seeing it. I think we need to get the current system going a bit more first. There are definite changes in roles and patterns that we haven't quite got fully used to yet.
Assuming we get to 38 points. I'm not suggesting the current system isnt producing opportunities but if you don't stick them away.....
I've not seen much of Brighton this season but they have a couple of lanky defenders who come up for set pieces which Liverpool exploited with van dyke
Playing a back 3 isn't much of a change considering how we are now playing out from the back, wing backs just have to be flexible
Just an idea anyway.
|
Bearcage Welling 21 Sep 21 10.12pm |
|
|
Back 3 or 4 (or any other formation) should be irrelevant for set pieces. It’s the one time you have the opportunity to get every player needed involved, they then need to do their job and mark and track players. It’s not complicated, just takes organisation, concentration and discipline.
|
sprites Auckland 22 Sep 21 12.08am |
|
|
I do like that it gives us the ability to play two up top but still own the midfield. For example:
Ward Andersen Tomkins Guehi Mitchell
Luka McArthur Gallagher
Benteke Wilf/Olise
|
beak croydon 22 Sep 21 9.26am |
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Not sure we have any wingbacks.....
And who would drop out?
Eagles should have wing backs.
|
Painter Croydon 22 Sep 21 10.21am |
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
Think the 3 Liverpool goals originated from set pieces so think maybe we could do with something a bit like Chelsea employ
Think Tomkins inbetween our current centre backs who are both useful on the ball would give us better defence against teams with height advantage keeping in mind we have Brighton next
Wing backs are fine in a midfield 4.
None of the goals had anything to do with height, it was not competing for loose ball in the box. Reidewald was culpable for 2 of the goals, not picking up Salah and being in no mans land for the 3rd. Vieira has set out the formation, I doubt if he is going to change anytime soon.
|
rikz Croydon 22 Sep 21 10.38am |
|
|
5 3 2 never works unless you have the right players for each position, like when Chelsea won the title they had alonso and moses who were both better going forward, ward and Mitchell are both terrible, they also had Luiz as a sweeper and azpilicueta who could just go right back and turn into a back 4, we don't have any of these players.
|
stayloa Beckenham 22 Sep 21 1.20pm |
|
|
Playing 5-3-2 doesn't really achieve much more for us in defending corners. Kouyate would be most likely to slot in to the 3xCB part and he's on the field anyway as a DM.
We did seem to be playing 5-3-2 against Chelsea in parts of the second half though.
Mainly, we just need to work on defending set pieces!
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 22 Sep 21 1.38pm |
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
Wingbacks could be Mitchell and Ward / another
Could be Kouyate and maybe Ayew for Milovejic
Whilst I like the formation for the right team, I don't think they are the right players for the job. As they effectively need to provide all the width.
If we still had PVA you might be able to convince me
|
deleted 25 11 Oct 21 7.53am |
|
Originally posted by sprites
I do like that it gives us the ability to play two up top but still own the midfield. For example:
Ward Andersen Tomkins Guehi Mitchell
Luka McArthur Gallagher
Benteke Wilf/Olise
I thought we were defensively open at the back v Leicester. They didn't have to work too hard to score
I'd be generally in favour of Tomkins playing in a back 3/5 ; or could play a back 4 with two defensive midfielders? Luka and Hughes
I think England / Liverpool play the back 4 formation and Chelsea / Scotland the back 3/5
|