This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| waddy |
|
|---|---|
|
Today against Liverpool ref was not good the Pen was not a Pen.The time wasting was obvious - Yet we lose the game not the Ref
Forever Palace Proud |
|
|
Originally posted by Swindy
It has always been like this in the Premier league but the administrators always bottle it over the big clubs, particularly as they have already threatened to walk once and the Premier league was set up for the benefit of the big clubs. so do we play our B team, whenever up against the big fish of the top Four ? And keep the A team fresh ? to crucify all the smaller clubs ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
This season players have been simulating contact to win penalties like nobody's business and they need to clamp down on it. Players are literally dangling a foot behind the ball just as defenders are about to clear the ball in order to win a pen (AWB and Andros have both fallen victim to this for their respective clubs as have others). Yesterday Jota's 'cleverness' should have earned him a yellow for simulation. Although the decision was wrong no-one seems to be giving Jota a hard time for cheating. Let's face it, if that was Zaha he would have been crucified by the media. Are refs intentionally biased? My feeling when calm is probably not. Are they subconsciously influenced by the force of personality of players from bigger clubs and the attention they'll receive if they go against a big club? I would say probably yes in some cases. Nevertheless, corruption is rife in all walks of life and so if we can't trust our governments, our police, or any other more serious instrument of society, can we truly be confident there is not corruption in the game? Of course not. I agree, I don't think that referees are intentionally biased. As for corrupt, well they could be, but instinctively I don't think they are. If we move on to competency, that's another matter. And in my view, where the Premier League is seriously lacking. VAR being administrated by the same incompetents that officiate at games....is it any wonder that even with the technology available to them, they are still inconsistent in their application of the laws ?! The performance of the three match officials plus Pawson on VAR yesterday highlighted everything that is currently wrong with EPL officiating. I know what a hard job they have. I know they are only human and that mistakes will be made. But most referees in the EPL are not of the sufficiently high standard that is required. And that is reflected in the number invited to officiate at Euros/ World Cup. The Premier League need to recognise and own this problem.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I agree, I don't think that referees are intentionally biased. As for corrupt, well they could be, but instinctively I don't think they are. If we move on to competency, that's another matter. And in my view, where the Premier League is seriously lacking. VAR being administrated by the same incompetents that officiate at games....is it any wonder that even with the technology available to them, they are still inconsistent in their application of the laws ?! The performance of the three match officials plus Pawson on VAR yesterday highlighted everything that is currently wrong with EPL officiating. I know what a hard job they have. I know they are only human and that mistakes will be made. But most referees in the EPL are not of the sufficiently high standard that is required. And that is reflected in the number invited to officiate at Euros/ World Cup. The Premier League need to recognise and own this problem. There have been a lot of games across the PL this season with some very odd decisions, with this affecting most teams both big and small. I get the ref makes mistakes, but how does VAR make so many? I do also think there is a disconnect between what happens in the box and what happens outside of it. This season (rightly so in my view) refs have been letting things go and are not stopping the game every time a player gets some contact, but if anything, when it comes to the 18-yard box they've become even more stringent. This of course has not been helped by VAR micro analysing some decisions and ignoring others. Consistency being the other issue of course and the fact we are seeing VAR take 5 minutes to decide if something is 'clear and obvious', which seems a contradiction in terms. The one thing I'd really love to see go is the pitch side monitors. It basically seems they are being used to show the referee why they are wrong. I don't think I've seen one occasion this season where the ref has stuck to his original decision. Can you imagine having to go over to a monitor with a wall of faces glaring at you and players talking in one ear and VAR in the other. It's ridiculous and just seems to undermine the referee.
|
|
|
I actually wondered what would happen if after the penalty award we just said, right everybody off & took the team off in protest, for sure we would get castigated by the FA but would it be worth it ? Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
so do we play our B team, whenever up against the big fish of the top Four ? And keep the A team fresh ? to crucify all the smaller clubs ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Yesterday KF didn't give the penalty at first - his best and most honest decision of the game and yet 5 mins later it is all over and he and Pawson have just made a mockery of technology. I thought exactly the same. When City dropped points, Liverpool had to win to keep the title race in anyway alive. Add in the Man Utd game one nil (any controversy - don't know?) Then see Chelsea winning (the Kane disallowed goal - any others?) and it's a more exciting title race. At the expense of inconvenient clubs like us, of course. I've thought it has been about product and entertainment value over football for quite some time. A continuation of PGMOL and Clattenberk rubbish. Only probably worse (which did not seem possible). VAR needs to be scrapped now. Fans have to eventually stand up to this.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.