You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Bias of Referees that favours big Teams
November 22 2026 7.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Bias of Referees that favours big Teams


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Swindy Flag Bromley 23 Jan 22 5.32pm

Our boys were in it today deep into the game and with a bit more luck/guile up front would have been at worst level.
Then the predictable 'refereeing' influence takes over, sucking out the spirit. Every week games are wrecked by moments like this and every week Kevin Friend 'to the big clubs' and all the other incompetents, Dean, Moss, Pawson etc carry on 'refereeing' without any explanation of their decisions or being taken to task and probably worse nothing is ever done over their barely-disguised leanings to the bigger club.
It has always been like this in the Premier league but the administrators always bottle it over the big clubs, particularly as they have already threatened to walk once and the Premier league was set up for the benefit of the big clubs.
You either swallow it or as a previous poster wrote, write off certain games.

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 23 Jan 22 6.17pm

Today against Liverpool ref was not good the Pen was not a Pen.The time wasting was obvious - Yet we lose the game not the Ref

 


Forever Palace Proud

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jan 22 10.38pm

Originally posted by Swindy

It has always been like this in the Premier league but the administrators always bottle it over the big clubs, particularly as they have already threatened to walk once and the Premier league was set up for the benefit of the big clubs.
You either swallow it or as a previous poster wrote, write off certain games.

so do we play our B team, whenever up against the big fish of the top Four ? And keep the A team fresh ? to crucify all the smaller clubs ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Jan 22 8.52am

This season players have been simulating contact to win penalties like nobody's business and they need to clamp down on it. Players are literally dangling a foot behind the ball just as defenders are about to clear the ball in order to win a pen (AWB and Andros have both fallen victim to this for their respective clubs as have others). Yesterday Jota's 'cleverness' should have earned him a yellow for simulation. Although the decision was wrong no-one seems to be giving Jota a hard time for cheating. Let's face it, if that was Zaha he would have been crucified by the media.

Are refs intentionally biased? My feeling when calm is probably not. Are they subconsciously influenced by the force of personality of players from bigger clubs and the attention they'll receive if they go against a big club? I would say probably yes in some cases. Nevertheless, corruption is rife in all walks of life and so if we can't trust our governments, our police, or any other more serious instrument of society, can we truly be confident there is not corruption in the game? Of course not.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Jan 22 9.10am

I don't think that Referees are intentionally bias but I do think at the back of their mind is the concern that if they don't give a marginal decision in favour of a big team there will be sh*t storm from that club, fans and the meeja.

I remember an article which pointed out certain referees had tangled with Sir Alex or other big team managers and they had not since ref'd them so definitely big team influence.

I wonder if they still goes on today certainly not at Palace they seem to delight in giving us a controversial ref.

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Jan 22 9.14am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

This season players have been simulating contact to win penalties like nobody's business and they need to clamp down on it. Players are literally dangling a foot behind the ball just as defenders are about to clear the ball in order to win a pen (AWB and Andros have both fallen victim to this for their respective clubs as have others). Yesterday Jota's 'cleverness' should have earned him a yellow for simulation. Although the decision was wrong no-one seems to be giving Jota a hard time for cheating. Let's face it, if that was Zaha he would have been crucified by the media.

Are refs intentionally biased? My feeling when calm is probably not. Are they subconsciously influenced by the force of personality of players from bigger clubs and the attention they'll receive if they go against a big club? I would say probably yes in some cases. Nevertheless, corruption is rife in all walks of life and so if we can't trust our governments, our police, or any other more serious instrument of society, can we truly be confident there is not corruption in the game? Of course not.

I agree, I don't think that referees are intentionally biased. As for corrupt, well they could be, but instinctively I don't think they are.

If we move on to competency, that's another matter. And in my view, where the Premier League is seriously lacking.

VAR being administrated by the same incompetents that officiate at games....is it any wonder that even with the technology available to them, they are still inconsistent in their application of the laws ?!

The performance of the three match officials plus Pawson on VAR yesterday highlighted everything that is currently wrong with EPL officiating.

I know what a hard job they have. I know they are only human and that mistakes will be made. But most referees in the EPL are not of the sufficiently high standard that is required. And that is reflected in the number invited to officiate at Euros/ World Cup.

The Premier League need to recognise and own this problem.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Jan 22 9.47am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I agree, I don't think that referees are intentionally biased. As for corrupt, well they could be, but instinctively I don't think they are.

If we move on to competency, that's another matter. And in my view, where the Premier League is seriously lacking.

VAR being administrated by the same incompetents that officiate at games....is it any wonder that even with the technology available to them, they are still inconsistent in their application of the laws ?!

The performance of the three match officials plus Pawson on VAR yesterday highlighted everything that is currently wrong with EPL officiating.

I know what a hard job they have. I know they are only human and that mistakes will be made. But most referees in the EPL are not of the sufficiently high standard that is required. And that is reflected in the number invited to officiate at Euros/ World Cup.

The Premier League need to recognise and own this problem.

There have been a lot of games across the PL this season with some very odd decisions, with this affecting most teams both big and small. I get the ref makes mistakes, but how does VAR make so many?

I do also think there is a disconnect between what happens in the box and what happens outside of it. This season (rightly so in my view) refs have been letting things go and are not stopping the game every time a player gets some contact, but if anything, when it comes to the 18-yard box they've become even more stringent. This of course has not been helped by VAR micro analysing some decisions and ignoring others. Consistency being the other issue of course and the fact we are seeing VAR take 5 minutes to decide if something is 'clear and obvious', which seems a contradiction in terms.

The one thing I'd really love to see go is the pitch side monitors. It basically seems they are being used to show the referee why they are wrong. I don't think I've seen one occasion this season where the ref has stuck to his original decision. Can you imagine having to go over to a monitor with a wall of faces glaring at you and players talking in one ear and VAR in the other. It's ridiculous and just seems to undermine the referee.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 24 Jan 22 9.52am

I actually wondered what would happen if after the penalty award we just said, right everybody off & took the team off in protest, for sure we would get castigated by the FA but would it be worth it ?

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

so do we play our B team, whenever up against the big fish of the top Four ? And keep the A team fresh ? to crucify all the smaller clubs ?

 

The Dolphin Flag 24 Jan 22 10.53am

Yesterday KF didn't give the penalty at first - his best and most honest decision of the game and yet 5 mins later it is all over and he and Pawson have just made a mockery of technology.
I was with a Liverpool fan at the game yesterday and we watched it straight after the game.
He is as biased as I am but he was shocked at the decision.
Bias or corruption who knows but questions will start to be asked.
Palace would not have got that penalty yesterday but giving Liverpool three points sort of keeps the League alive.
Make up your own mind!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 24 Jan 22 2.28pm


Howard Webb. World cup final.

Netherlands kung fu team vs Spain.


to me, it was evidence that Refs bend the rules to keep the spectacle going.. After 115 minutes of violence, Webb finally sent off a Dutchman.

i had thought Webb was asleep.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Jan 22 2.33pm

I have e-mailed the FA - I tried to keep things as brief and to the point as possible. Will I get a reply ? Not holding my breathe...

Dear Sirs,

I write to register my disappointment and frustration with the level of competency displayed by the officials at the above match.

There were a number of issues that I believe were not handled properly and in accordance with the rules of the game.

1. Referee Friend did not stop the game when Olise of Crystal Palace landed heavily following an attempt to win the ball in the air in which he sustained a blow to the head. Friend appeared to gesture to the player to get up and carry on with the game. Surely Friend had a responsibility to ensure the safety of the players welfare ?

2. During the build up to the second Liverpool goal, their forward, Firmino, was in an offside position when the ball was played. He attempted to make contact with the ball, therefore he could be considered to be ' active '. The fact that he failed to make contact should not have made any difference and I believe the outcome should have been a free kick for offside. Instead, play was allowed to continue resulting in a goal being scored. Was there a VAR check for that situation ? Should there have been ?? It is evident that VAR is being used to scrutinise even those events that do not look to be ' clear and obvious errors ' by the on-field officials, so I think it's fair to challenge why VAR wasn't employed on this occasion.

3. The Liverpool penalty awarded against the Palace goalkeeper. This incident has attracted more than enough comment and media attention so I will merely ask this ; if that was a clear and obvious error by the referee, why did VAR take so long to recommend that the referee review it on the pitch side monitor ? My perception is that this was reviewed numerous times by the VAR official prior to that recommendation being made - so ' clear and obvious ' ? - I don't think so. And it would appear that the only two people outside of Liverpool FC themselves that thought it a penalty was Pawson and, eventually, Friend.

There are a growing number of people, Players, Managers, The Media and ( last as always ) the paying public, that think that refereeing standards are slipping badly. The advent of VAR appears to be being used as some sort of ' comfort blanket ' by some. And the application of VAR - with yesterdays game being a prime example - is becoming as inconsistent as the referees themselves. I would add that I have long thought that Kevin Friend is a poor referee, an opinion held by supporters of numerous clubs. Yesterday merely reminded me of that.

The Premier League attracts some of the best players and managers in the world. It is marketed and priced as a Premium Product. At the moment it is being badly let down by the standard of officiating.

I imagine that you will have received a significant amount of mail relating to yesterdays game. However, I ask you the courtesy of a response. In particular I am interested to know your thoughts on standards , how to improve them, and what further improvements can be made when VAR is employed during games.

I look forward to hearing from you

Regards

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Jan 22 6.27pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Yesterday KF didn't give the penalty at first - his best and most honest decision of the game and yet 5 mins later it is all over and he and Pawson have just made a mockery of technology.
I was with a Liverpool fan at the game yesterday and we watched it straight after the game.
He is as biased as I am but he was shocked at the decision.
Bias or corruption who knows but questions will start to be asked.
Palace would not have got that penalty yesterday but giving Liverpool three points sort of keeps the League alive.
Make up your own mind!

I thought exactly the same. When City dropped points, Liverpool had to win to keep the title race in anyway alive. Add in the Man Utd game one nil (any controversy - don't know?) Then see Chelsea winning (the Kane disallowed goal - any others?) and it's a more exciting title race. At the expense of inconvenient clubs like us, of course. I've thought it has been about product and entertainment value over football for quite some time. A continuation of PGMOL and Clattenberk rubbish. Only probably worse (which did not seem possible). VAR needs to be scrapped now. Fans have to eventually stand up to this.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Bias of Referees that favours big Teams