This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I regard today as far more nuts than Britain was in 68. Today we have identity politics...well for some we have and it's a direct result of...well, frankly the path that Powell warned against all those years ago. I wouldn't deny that identity politics has gone too far, but you're as textbook and wayward as that gets yourself. Someone who says that a party leader should reflect a party, while simultaneously showing interest and praising a 'broad church' party led by a neo nazi (while doing a broad strokes of BLM as simply 'racist' There is no getting away from the derogatory language you've used to describe minority groups, nuts conclusions you reach about how terrible it is that kids should can be told in school that 'a woman can love another woman', inferences that people who were born here but are from abroad do not hold the same birthright you do and so on. Of course you would enjoy the words of a man like Powell who declares that 'the black man will have the whip hand over the white man' because the implication is that the white man holding it is a non event; not a problem. Your cathartic dream. From your upbringing experiences of racism you clearly got the 'minority experience'. Instead of recognising that for what it genuinely was and holding concern for those often in the exact same place regardless of colour and creed, you 'put a face to it'. You have warped the genuinely sad reality that few gave a damn about your experience and now spend a life vomiting out that very same cruel attitude onto minority groups you imagine are somehow deserving of it. Abused becomes abuser. It's an unfortunate approach to life and one that any parent should seriously reflect on, rather than simply indulge in and pass on. Individuals like Mark Collet see you coming a mile off. Vultures to the damaged. Grifters. Take a walk with others, instead of trying to get away from those who are often far more of whatever goodness remains within you than that joker and his dubious pals will ever be. The self declared 'nazi inspired' individual earlier (well one of...) is on record as stating that he personally attempts to ease people into beliefs to get them onboard with his, rather than go full throttle, with what can only be described as extreme views. Which yes are documented. Your rebuttal (below) is essentially do these people still hold their same ideas 'now' they're with PA? I mean seriously? A manifesto clearly has to exist within legal parameters to make an attempt at wide appeal. In my view they are a stepping stone, a 'gateway' with plenty of worrying connections - much like comparable groups from other demographics. I have no favourites when it comes to political or ideological fringes. The rest of your comments below are designed to fragment and distract from the realities and the gravity of what we're talking about. You can leap to the defence of Collet asking that he self declares himself a 'neo nazi' before you consider it a fact. I'll instead go with his admitted glee at the death of minorities due to 'friendly diseases', doubts about the holocaust, and stated admiration for Adolf Hitler. Specific claims that groups are non violent does not mean that they're not repugnant, or speak to where an interest can lead their members. They're a very small party but it's not difficult to find detailed information on supporters of them who are in support of direct violence against minorities. In absence of any remaining doubt, you have now been made aware of this. The clear message of PA is that there is not room for 'minorities' but there 'is' certainly room within for those who despise them. That doesn't much appear to bother you, but 'minorities' certainly do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I wouldn't deny that identity politics has gone too far, but you're as nuts at the other extreme. Someone who says that a party leader should reflect a party, while simultaneously showing interest and praising a 'broad church' party led by a neo nazi (while doing a broad strokes of BLM as 'racist' I'll state again, Britain in 68 was far less 'nuts' than it is today, and I'll also state that it was far more cohesive and at ease with itself. You 'wouldn't deny that 'identity politics has gone too far'....oh that's interesting to know. Well, it's come straight out of social liberalism with its ever strengthening leftish tinge. Well, that is your particular flagpole and it doesn't take much common sense to know that the genie isn't going back into the bottle. So as far as I'm concerned your politics is associated with the very aliment you apparently detest. Yet I've read you several times support the victimhood culture of minorities, which does of course indirectly create identity politics itself....but like the leftists you believe some is justified. Here yet again, you bring up PA, which wasn't part of this discussion. In my view previous experience has taught me that you aren't really a good faith person to discuss this subject with but for the benefit of those that are reading this I'll provide some ballast and tackle what you've said point by point. You try to say that because I believe that a leader should reflect its party (which I do) that this is somehow at odds with supporting Collet as PA leader. Yet I have never said that I support Collet as PA leader. I have said several times that I support the manifesto and hence logic should have led you to that conclusion. So, in rather plain language I don't think that PA has a leader that best reflects it. As I don't think you're thick I can only conclude that this is your usual bad faith rendition of my position possibly due to your emotive reactions. Next you claim that Collet is a neo Nazi....Has he actually said this? Or is this you speaking for him or the leftist sites that you have no doubt visited and regard as honest. Again, perhaps you should contact Collet himself instead of speaking for him. I will agree with you that he has views that I don't support, however I broached this point in another thread...a point that you completely ignored where I compared the Collet situation to that of Corbyn leading the Labour party. I stated that not only did Corbyn have controversial views well known in advance but tellingly he employed his long term friend McDonnell as his number two. McDonnell of course once admitted to being a communist and he went on to wave Mao's little red book in the commons.....Mao, murdered far more than Hitler or Stalin. All odious mass murderers. Yet I've never saw you on here writing about your distaste of Corbyn supporters for their acceptance of Corbyn and the far larger contingent of communists in their party. And of course Labour stood much more chance of gaining power than PA ever will. Next point, If a regional member made a joke about 'gassing kikes' then that is distasteful....but people made bad taste jokes everyday and no doubt also exist in other parties. I find your assertion that a member was in National Action more serious as PA isn't doesn't support violence towards its aims. Do you know that this person supports violence now? How do you know that your claims are even true? Are they from an objective source? Are you suggesting that PA supports violence because that is false. What I will say is that supporting a manifesto does not mean that you support the views of everyone in that organisation. As I said at the beginning a party should reflect its members and the manifesto reflects their agreed consensus positions. The PA manifesto nor I are in no way associated with National Action or neo Nazis and only a dishonest description could suggest it. Originally posted by BlueJay
There is no getting away from the derogatory language you've used to describe minority groups, nuts conclusions you reach about how terrible it is that kids should can be told in school that 'a woman can love another woman', inferences that people who were born here but are from abroad do not hold the same birthright you do and so on. Of course you would enjoy the words of a man like Powell who bemoans a reality where 'the black man will have the whip hand over the white man' because the implication is that the white man holding it is a non event; not a problem. Your cathartic dream. Here you make several tangled points that I'll try my best to answer. What derogatory language have I used to describe minority groups? Yes, I'm against the teaching of same sex relationships to young children. I'm very against it for several reasons. Yes, I would say broadly that similar to the Dalai Lama I support the rights of historical ancestry to land claims. This is commonplace all over the world and indeed it's your position that is the minority outside of the self destroying west. As for Powell and the 'Whip hand' context. You are not being accurate when you relate those words. His speech wasn't about having superiority over non whites or agreeing with treating non whites poorly. It was about the ancestral right of the British to protect and remain the majority within their own lands. There would be no 'whip hand' issue in a homogeneous society. Powell made it clear that The whip hand' would result from the very act of increasing the immigration population until they indeed held sway..an heterogeneous society.....something which indeed is happening now.....and I suggest that if there was an 'whip hand' being used by the British then all these foreigners would never have struggled desperately to get here. Originally posted by BlueJay
From your upbringing experiences of racism you clearly got the 'minority experience'. Instead of recognising that for what it genuinely was and holding concern for those often in the exact same place regardless of colour and creed, you put a face to it. You have warped the genuinely sad reality that few gave a damn about your experience and now spend a life vomiting out that very same cruel attitude onto minority groups you imagine are deserving of it. Abused becomes abuser. It's an unfortunate approach to life and one that any parent should seriously reflect on, rather than simply indulge in and pass on. Errrr....What I experienced was physical and could have taken my life without some luck, it wasn't something as tame as 'unkind attitudes' as you like to think.....what someone thinks of me has never been my motivation for taking a position. I'm far more interested in truth over convenience. Here you make several mistakes in a rather arrogant and simplistic attempt to analyse why I hold my positions. Firstly I'll make the observation that your statement here could be related to the entire non white identity movement....Yet all I've hear from you is you justifying why they think what they think and being lenient or not commenting when they show ethnic preference...which has been done quite a few times on this forum. I don't deny identity politics as a right for any group within heterogeneous societies.....Indeed, I regard that outcome as inevitable. What I do is point out hypocrisies, not deny people the right of ethnic association. I suggest that my view is a practical one while yours I contend is an ever decaying fantasy more akin to the old coke advert. My experiences in Brixton growing up of course provide a background to my views now. However, it's inaccurate to believe that they created them. Anyone who has read me over the years knows that back in 2009 (a good twenty three years after those events) I was a civic nationalist and pretty much a default nineties EU skeptic Tory who believed that cultural integration could work....if only the will was there. This is still the opinion of many conservatives today....mainly because they want it to be true, rather than having given it serious thought....it's easier to believe a convenient lie than it is to proclaim an unpleasant truth. My views largely changed once I started looking into the topic seriously around 2015/16 once I had more time to. You seem to be suggesting that I treat an individual's worse because of race. That's not true, and you won't find instances where I've done that. My positions are on group realities, ancestral rights, and on what I believe causes the least damage to western societies. Originally posted by BlueJay
Individuals like Mark Collet see you coming a mile off. Vultures to the damaged. Grifters. Take a walk with others, instead of trying to get away from those who are often far more of whatever goodness remains within you than that joker and his extremist pals will ever be. Edited by BlueJay (02 Oct 2021 3.09am) Again, this suggestion that I'm somehow fooled by Mark Collet, someone I've heard probably far more than you have. There are legitimate criticisms and there are people in PA I don't agree with but I wager my view of PA is more accurate than your obsession with that photo. I'm not even a member of it, hell I could talk about Britain first for example. You have built a reductionist understanding of my motivations for agreeing with ancestral rights, even though once again your viewpoint finds itself in a minority outside of the west....So are they all neo Nazi supporters too? In my view this is because you're fundamentally an egalitarian who wants social liberalism to work. You're willing to ignore the evidence to the contrary because it fits your fragile emotional make up.....which I suggest runs rather too freely and is willing to make ugly and malformed arguments when the shaky ground of your ideology is challenged. There you go Wordy...have some quick and easy assumptions made about you...I wager they are more accurate than yours. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Oct 2021 5.45am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Again, this suggestion that I'm somehow fooled by Mark Collet, someone I've heard probably far more than you have. There are legitimate criticisms and there are people in PA I don't agree with but I wager my view of PA is more accurate than your obsession with that photo. I'm not even a member of it, hell I could talk about Britain first for example. You have built a reductionist understanding of my motivations for agreeing with ancestral rights, even though once again your viewpoint finds itself in a minority outside of the west....So are they all neo Nazi supporters too? In my view this is because you're fundamentally an egalitarian who wants social liberalism to work. You're willing to ignore the evidence to the contrary because it fits your fragile emotional make up.....which I suggest runs rather too freely and is willing to make ugly and malformed arguments when the shaky ground of your ideology is challenged. There you go Wordy...have some quick and easy assumptions made about you...I wager they are more accurate than yours. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Oct 2021 5.45am) I think the victim protests too much. If you support PA's racist manifesto, you support PA. Mark Collett is a neo-nazi. You keep trying to claim I have a low IQ. But you run away from debates and chuck around petty insults. I think you should get councilling from a professional about your issues growing up. Plenty of people grew up in Brixton without holding racist grudges. Once upon a time you had a bone broken. Get over it. There's never been any context on this story. Judging by your views, I'd say there was a high likelihood that it was a fight you started. Now you spend all day, everyday, posting spamming these boards. It seems the HoL is your last hiding place, as your views aren't welcome in a modern Britian.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Anyway, this is a thread about Geoff Hurst. Not another Stirlingsays threat about how he feels sorry for himself.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Anyway, this is a thread about Geoff Hurst. Not another Stirlingsays threat about how he feels sorry for himself. You are ruining all the threads with your constant adversarial nonsense. Relax. It's just a football site. I don't want to change your mind, and you have zero chance of changing mine (or Stirling's).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Thank the heavens we now live in a world where you can't go on mainstream TV, sat next to a black man and use phrases like "ni**a in the woodpile." It was racist then and it's racist now, but thanks to a lack of education people didn't either realise, or care... much like folks used to excuse sexual harassment and assault as "a bit of fun", "banter" etc. What I find equally hilarious is 99% of the time I see posts and threads pop up like this, it's NEVER a woke youngster, but rather some middle aged and older white bloke from the "university of life" trying to find tenuous ways and examples to excuse and validate their own racist, outdated and embarrassing opinions. The obvious point is that using such phrases was common place back then. Now we have an increasing number of immigrants here, and they are influencing how we think. It's clear that the use of such phrases was not intended to be offensive. I think it's fairly obvious when someone is trying to be. Retrospective judgement of past attitudes is completely pointless in itself. It is all about controlling language and thoughts. Be careful what you wish for.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Thank the heavens we now live in a world where you can't go on mainstream TV, sat next to a black man and use phrases like "ni**a in the woodpile." It was racist then and it's racist now, but thanks to a lack of education people didn't either realise, or care... much like folks used to excuse sexual harassment and assault as "a bit of fun", "banter" etc. What I find equally hilarious is 99% of the time I see posts and threads pop up like this, it's NEVER a woke youngster, but rather some middle aged and older white bloke from the "university of life" trying to find tenuous ways and examples to excuse and validate their own racist, outdated and embarrassing opinions. You don't specify exactly what opinion you have an issue with you just poison the well. I find that there's a lot of that, people who just want to make a virtue signalling statement without actually debating a specific point. Youngsters are subject to indoctrination and told what they should think, just like I was when I was younger. It seems that if practical experience informs you differently as you get older then that's embarrassing. I've noticed that a lot of people have a desperate need to believe in mainstream concepts like egalitarianism, which I've found to be a half truth in reality and they teach it to their children like they do Santa Claus....the difference with Santa Claus is that it is harmless. I'd rather be embarrassing to people like yourself than a pusher of convenient lies.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The obvious point is that using such phrases was common place back then. Now we have an increasing number of immigrants here, and they are influencing how we think. It's clear that the use of such phrases was not intended to be offensive. I think it's fairly obvious when someone is trying to be. Retrospective judgement of past attitudes is completely pointless in itself. It is all about controlling language and thoughts. Be careful what you wish for. I would totally agree that GH probably didn't see it, or mean it as racist... but it was then, and is now. I don't blame him for saying it, but equally I'm thankful we've moved on a society and understand actually it's wrong. Certainly increased exposure to different cultures and people through immigration has helped make us more worldly and aware of the feelings of others in regards language, but just like we've done with language and attitudes to women and equally those with disabilities, it also happens regardless of increased exposure to women or people with additional needs. Having said that, even if there weren't more BAME individuals around, I think we would still be in a much better place. I grew up telling "*Pa*i jokes" in the playground, it was racist then and is still racist, but I don't need to be around more asian people to recognise that, so I don't agree with the tone of your point that it's like we've only changed because there are more of "them" around... I would like to think personal growth can happen even without that through other mechanisms, the media, social media, politics and events etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You don't specify exactly what opinion you have an issue with you just poison the well. I find that there's a lot of that, people who just want to make a virtue signalling statement without actually debating a specific point. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Oct 2021 1.24pm) 1 - "shows just how correct Powell was when he said fifty years ago how the 'whip hand' would change." a --- This is just absolutely incorrect on any measurable level. People from a BAME background are PROVEN to be at a greater disadvantage in almost every measurable sociologists can measure.
I totally disagree with you that the idea of him being demonised and hated would be wrong.... Sorry, if someone in 2021 goes on national TV and starts using racist language they deserve what's coming to them. But this ties in with point one that you imply that; IF it were to happen and IF Hurst was dragged over the coals and hated, that this would be an example of the "whip hand changing". Are you serious? So you equate white folks not being able to be openly racist on TV in 2021 as us being somehow subjugated to the Black man. That's the points I disagree with specifically.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Thank the heavens we now live in a world where you can't go on mainstream TV, sat next to a black man and use phrases like "ni**a in the woodpile." It was racist then and it's racist now, but thanks to a lack of education people didn't either realise, or care... much like folks used to excuse sexual harassment and assault as "a bit of fun", "banter" etc. What I find equally hilarious is 99% of the time I see posts and threads pop up like this, it's NEVER a woke youngster, but rather some middle aged and older white bloke from the "university of life" trying to find tenuous ways and examples to excuse and validate their own racist, outdated and embarrassing opinions. They've dug up a week old thread. I think they were fishing for a woke reaction where people would call Geoff Hurst racist. Unfortunate, Geoff Hurst isn't racist, he just made a racist comment. After the Euro's he went on the BBC making clear anti-racism statements. I agree that it's obvious, and clear to most many on these board, is why time after time there's 3 posters that protest against any form of tolerance. Fortunately, their egos are too inflated to realise everyone see through it. One of them described the abuse Zaha received as "hurty words". The disparity of the reactions between minor news articles and issues that effect Crystal Palace players just go to assist the reader to identify their agenda. Anyway, I'm abroad, enjoying different cultures and seeing new things. Life's great, have an excellent weekend IE.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
I would totally agree that GH probably didn't see it, or mean it as racist... but it was then, and is now. I don't blame him for saying it, but equally I'm thankful we've moved on a society and understand actually it's wrong. Certainly increased exposure to different cultures and people through immigration has helped make us more worldly and aware of the feelings of others in regards language, but just like we've done with language and attitudes to women and equally those with disabilities, it also happens regardless of increased exposure to women or people with additional needs. Having said that, even if there weren't more BAME individuals around, I think we would still be in a much better place. I grew up telling "*Pa*i jokes" in the playground, it was racist then and is still racist, but I don't need to be around more asian people to recognise that, so I don't agree with the tone of your point that it's like we've only changed because there are more of "them" around... I would like to think personal growth can happen even without that through other mechanisms, the media, social media, politics and events etc.
I hear Black people regularly spouting racist nonsense on TV and no one bats an eyelid. I am personally tired of hearing how racist we are. We even have people trawling history to find racism. It's pathetic, quite frankly. Whether people believe or not, this is a power game. The details are secondary. Racism is a universal reality, and White people are probably the least racist of the lot. What is most pathetic is hearing some 'woke' White people trying to make others share their guilt trip.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
1 - "shows just how correct Powell was when he said fifty years ago how the 'whip hand' would change." a --- This is just absolutely incorrect on any measurable level. People from a BAME background are PROVEN to be at a greater disadvantage in almost every measurable sociologists can measure. As an answer it's another very generalised statement. You make that sociological statement yet it's pretty significant that working class white children are at the bottom of the education tables, it follows the funding....and been that way for years now yet there's very little concern shown. Powell's statement rings true and I'm happy to debate specifics in any area you like. Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
2 - Said [SIC] now this national icon would be demonised and hated....led by the Twitter and corporate/political activists. I totally disagree with you that the idea of him being demonised and hated would be wrong.... Sorry, if someone in 2021 goes on national TV and starts using racist language they deserve what's coming to them. But this ties in with point one that you imply that; IF it were to happen and IF Hurst was dragged over the coals and hated, that this would be an example of the "whip hand changing". Are you serious? So you equate white folks not being able to be openly racist on TV in 2021 as us being somehow subjugated to the Black man. That's the points I disagree with specifically.
Well, your point was general but this second one allows for actual focus. You actually prove in your last two paragraphs how the 'whip hand' has indeed changed because the mainstream power structures would now destroy Hurst over what was essentially a generational language slip. I would agree with you however....as it was originally stated that it's an unfortunate phrase of the past that's inappropriate.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I hear Black people regularly spouting racist nonsense on TV and no one bats an eyelid. I am personally tired of hearing how racist we are. We even have people trawling history to find racism. It's pathetic, quite frankly. Whether people believe or not, this is a power game. The details are secondary. Racism is a universal reality, and White people are probably the least racist of the lot. What is most pathetic is hearing some 'woke' White people trying to make others share their guilt trip. Agree, where Powell was incorrect was on time scales and on who would be leading the inquisition and power changes. The woke left are mainly whites, it benefits them within their own peer group bubbles to attack anything that suggests a white identity. However most of them are fine with non white identities and their promotion it's their own form of 'racism' which they defend with appeals to victimization. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Oct 2021 2.02pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, your point was general but this second one allows for actual focus. You actually prove in your last two paragraphs how the 'whip hand' has indeed changed because the mainstream power structures would now destroy Hurst over what was essentially a generational language slip. I would agree with you however....as it was originally stated that it's an unfortunate phrase of the past that's inappropriate. Hurst would not say it now - therefore, the mainstream media would not destroy him. I keep hearing stories that compared to urban areas, rural and costal areas with the highest percentage of white puples are struggling to attract good quality teachers. Adding to that, large numbers of working class white parents take education for granted and treat schools like day care centres.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie
and yet back in 1990 not even a flicker of a reaction in the studio. If this was said today his World Cup winning hat-trick would be expunged from history and the 1966 World Cup would be awarded to West Germany. I expect all of history to be re-written sometime very soon.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Thank the heavens we now live in a world where you can't go on mainstream TV, sat next to a black man and use phrases like "ni**a in the woodpile." It was racist then and it's racist now, but thanks to a lack of education people didn't either realise, or care... much like folks used to excuse sexual harassment and assault as "a bit of fun", "banter" etc. What I find equally hilarious is 99% of the time I see posts and threads pop up like this, it's NEVER a woke youngster, but rather some middle aged and older white bloke from the "university of life" trying to find tenuous ways and examples to excuse and validate their own racist, outdated and embarrassing opinions. Well stated. Contrived, unsustainable perspectives.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.