You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Most important player
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Most important player


MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 18 Oct 21 1.53pm

For the last couple of years Zaha has been far and away our best and most important player. Seeing a team sheet without his name on it, would automatically make me think we’re certain to lose.

We also rarely had set partnerships, CBs were different every game, CM was rarely settled.

Now alongside Zaha, I’d add in Anderson, Guehi, Gallagher (and Eze) to that group that would be sorely missed.

But it begs the question, who is most important to us?

At the min I’d go for Gallagher or Anderson.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 18 Oct 21 2.47pm

I like this topic. And I think that any new manager coming in (other than the mercenary type of manager) would see the danger in being over-reliant on one player. So I'm very happy that we've corrected that for the immediate benefits and the future when the time cometh for Wilf to leave, or decline in ability. Also takes some pressure off of him too.

I think where we'll get to, sooner than many had expected, is that we are not over-reliant on a few flare players, and have a united and cohesive squad that understand how to play the press from front to back. The overall quality has gone up for sure, and a few new players and philosophy has dragged everything up a notch or two. I also think that we might not have seen our most important players yet, which is also really exciting - Edouard, Olise, Eze in his second season, Hughes. They could all be really important, and match-winning components of this chapter in our history/future.

I dodged the question, and will dodge it a little more. I think PV is most important person in the mix. It's his vision and philosophy. If he goes, the project stalls or disappears.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (18 Oct 2021 2.49pm)

 

EddieMac Flag 18 Oct 21 3.03pm

James McCarthur for me. First name on the team sheet. We were lost without him in the second half of last season.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 18 Oct 21 3.20pm

Yes, an interesting topic MrRobbo, but you can't name two as the most important player! That's a cop out. Although I don't disagree with your two nominees, however it has to be Gallagher of the two you put forward.

I'm with EddieMac, McArthur is immense in the team. Often ignored in MOTM awards etc, but such a solid and reliable team member. As much as we all love to see Wilf in full flight or Eze (and now Olise) glide through defences, James McArthur is for me, our most important player.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 18 Oct 21 3.38pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I like this topic. And I think that any new manager coming in (other than the mercenary type of manager) would see the danger in being over-reliant on one player. So I'm very happy that we've corrected that for the immediate benefits and the future when the time cometh for Wilf to leave, or decline in ability. Also takes some pressure off of him too.

I think where we'll get to, sooner than many had expected, is that we are not over-reliant on a few flare players, and have a united and cohesive squad that understand how to play the press from front to back. The overall quality has gone up for sure, and a few new players and philosophy has dragged everything up a notch or two. I also think that we might not have seen our most important players yet, which is also really exciting - Edouard, Olise, Eze in his second season, Hughes. They could all be really important, and match-winning components of this chapter in our history/future.

I dodged the question, and will dodge it a little more. I think PV is most important person in the mix. It's his vision and philosophy. If he goes, the project stalls or disappears.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (18 Oct 2021 2.49pm)

Very good post, John Textor and PV

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 18 Oct 21 4.57pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I like this topic. And I think that any new manager coming in (other than the mercenary type of manager) would see the danger in being over-reliant on one player. So I'm very happy that we've corrected that for the immediate benefits and the future when the time cometh for Wilf to leave, or decline in ability. Also takes some pressure off of him too.

I think where we'll get to, sooner than many had expected, is that we are not over-reliant on a few flare players, and have a united and cohesive squad that understand how to play the press from front to back. The overall quality has gone up for sure, and a few new players and philosophy has dragged everything up a notch or two. I also think that we might not have seen our most important players yet, which is also really exciting - Edouard, Olise, Eze in his second season, Hughes. They could all be really important, and match-winning components of this chapter in our history/future.

I dodged the question, and will dodge it a little more. I think PV is most important person in the mix. It's his vision and philosophy. If he goes, the project stalls or disappears.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (18 Oct 2021 2.49pm)

Its a v good point, philosophy above individuals. bBet he could still do a job if needed too!


 

Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Oct 21 5.59pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

James McCarthur for me. First name on the team sheet. We were lost without him in the second half of last season.

For me too . J Mac is and has been the heartbeat of the side for a few years now . Replacing him will not be easy .

 

TheGantry Flag 18 Oct 21 5.59pm

Hi all,
In our latest article on The Gantry, we explain why Crystal Palace are the team to watch this season!
Read more at the link below:
[Link] or follow us on Twitter @thefootygantry

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Oct 21 8.19am

We haven’t a most important player, we are now playing as a team.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Oct 21 8.26am

Originally posted by Painter

We haven’t a most important player, we are now playing as a team.

Exactly whilst I love Wilf we have to move away from being a one man team and I think we slowly are.

 


One more point

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Oct 21 9.22am

Originally posted by Painter

We haven’t a most important player, we are now playing as a team.

we definitely are, which is great. My only worry is about losing one of the CB's or Connor.

Would we be able to pass out of the back with JT?

Would we be able to do the high press without Connor (he won the ball for the 2nd goal, and started the press which lead to our first).

We've proved that we can work without Wilf, I'm hoping Hughes will be decent cover for Connor, but CB cover leaves me worried.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 21 Oct 21 3.19am

I don't think were have ever been a one man team but there was a definite move to get the ball to Zaha at all costs as he was our best forward. One of the differences this season has been the threat we are now offering from the central midfield players which we hardly ever had under Roy ( Loftus-Cheek loan period aside ) Main difference is Connor Gallagher.
When Zaha was out it really interfered with out game play hence why we suffered not only because our best player was not in the team but also we had no replacement who could play that roll. Eduoard showed use he can be that player though i think Olise will also be able to do the same in the not to distant future.

 

deleted 25 Flag 25 Oct 21 4.29pm

Olise I'd say is our biggest asset from what I've seen

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 25 Oct 21 5.04pm

Right now it is not a player but the combination of Macca and Gallagher - they're the engine of the team and work as a pair. Pressing is a joint endeavour and one can't work without the other in closing down spaces.

Pretty much all out games have been "won" by winning the midfield war - we're not just getting possession but possession upfield in good spots. This is the City way and PV is very much a City manager who owes his philosophy to Pep. All we have to do now is turn that possession and territory into good final balls and finishing.

Olise looks a diamond and good for a couple of golden passes a game. I'm wondering though whether he may not supplanted by Eze. It's really tricky to fit Eze into midfield and not interrupt the engine of the team. Take one of those 8s out and we'd be a different outfit. Perhaps in our run of matches from Burnley on we can afford an 8 and a 10.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Most important player