You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Air Source heat pumps
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Air Source heat pumps


doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 19 Oct 21 11.17am

I am not too sure if these will be acceptable to the country.

It will mean having a big, noisy box outside. Ignoring the aesthetics of the sight of the box, the noise will annoy the residents and neighbours.

In 2009 I had a ground-source heat pump installed in a newly converted barn with underfloor heating. They worked well together as the temperature required was lower for underfloor than radiators.

Maybe technology has moved on, but my compressor and heat storage took more space than two domestic fridge/freezers.

Finally ( and this is the really stupid thing ) when I recently sold my barn the EPC was down-graded as it used electricity to drive the GSHP. It would have been better if I was using gas.

In 2009, it cost me £10k to try and be more efficient. The underfloor heating was great. The new home has a gas boiler and radiators and will work out cheaper to run. It is warmer too.

This new initiative is a knee-jerk reaction to the current crisis.

My advice......avoid.

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 19 Oct 21 1.14pm

Totally agree. This has the makings of a typical Government spin exercise of a loud fanfare and everyone jumping on the momentum of the bandwagon to guilt the public into doing this. Except...remember how we were all told to buy diesel cars a couple of decades ago. Now the science says otherwise so I too will be avoiding this and relying on my new gas boiler (installed just over a year ago). Thanks but no thanks.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 19 Oct 21 4.41pm

Typical badly-thought knee-jerk, headline-grabbing,... tosh

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

dannyboy1978 Flag 19 Oct 21 5.03pm

These will be about £3500 when available next year.
Hardly rocket science to microwave your water!what a great idea and a British invention
[Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Oct 21 5.09pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

These will be about £3500 when available next year.
Hardly rocket science to microwave your water!what a great idea and a British invention
[Link]

Makes you wonder why this route wasn't chosen decades ago.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Oct 21 5.15pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

These will be about £3500 when available next year.
Hardly rocket science to microwave your water!what a great idea and a British invention
[Link]

You can just put your wireless router next to the water tank.

 


Red and Blue Army!

BlueJay Flag UK 19 Oct 21 5.46pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

These will be about £3500 when available next year.
Hardly rocket science to microwave your water!what a great idea and a British invention
[Link]

That sounds like a significant drop, so I'd welcome it. No such thing as a free lunch in this country though (well.. for most), so my cynical take would be that they'll be about 5k in a years time and the grant will have disappeared! Hopefully I'm wrong though, as this definitely looks like a positive step forward.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 19 Oct 21 7.22pm

The main problem is that the temperatures aren't the same as gas boilers deliver. Typically 82*c flow (out water temp)
and 71*c ( back water temp) return water temperature to the boiler. Hence the present radiator sizes required to heat the space ( room volume). Heat pumps deliver about 65*c flow which will mean up sizing radiators by at least 50%.
Ie a single will be a double and a double will be a treble. That's if they are sized correctly of course. Later for the basic calculations.
The outdoor units are much quieter than the older ones but take up a lot of space and still need power to run. An average of 8kw at the low end. That's 32 amps and many fuse boards are at the limit now so compared to a boiler at max 5 amps there are problems with the 'load' already.
The calculations for radiator sizing which I use are.
Living and dining rooms 5 BTU per cubic foot.
Bedrooms 4 BTU per cubic foot.
Bathrooms and ensuites 3 BTU per cubic foot.
BTU = British thermal units
3412 BTU = 1 kw or 1000 Watts.
Ie a lounge 10ft long x 15ft wide x7ft tall.
10 x 15 x 7 = 1050 x 5 = 5250 BTU or thereabouts
Different calcs for different rooms but same process.
If your heating with a boiler needs to be on longer than 20 minutes to warm your drum your rads are undersized I'm afraid.
I oversized mine by 20 % so 5 minutes and my place is steaming.
Most merchants brochures have radiator sizes and outputs so check if your rads are the correct size for a boiler system.
A rough measurement and type of radiator ( K1,K2 etc) will be close enough.
Then add 50% to the correct size for a boiler system to a heat pump system and watch your wall disappear for when you get a heat pump.
That's aside of an electric element in your hot water cylinder at
12amps (3 kw) to trim your hot water to 55*c and the problems gets bigger. Sadly hmg have not done any presearch or spoken to the pros and the tree huggers don't even get it either I'm afraid.
Pm me if you have any questions ref your rads.

 

becky Flag over the moon 19 Oct 21 8.36pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

These will be about £3500 when available next year.
Hardly rocket science to microwave your water!what a great idea and a British invention
[Link]

Bloody silly idea - just tried it with disastrous results

Filled the bath with cold water, sat hubbie in it and plugged in the microwave to heat the water.

Anyway, the funeral is next week.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Oct 21 8.42pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The main problem is that the temperatures aren't the same as gas boilers deliver. Typically 82*c flow (out water temp)
and 71*c ( back water temp) return water temperature to the boiler. Hence the present radiator sizes required to heat the space ( room volume). Heat pumps deliver about 65*c flow which will mean up sizing radiators by at least 50%.
Ie a single will be a double and a double will be a treble. That's if they are sized correctly of course. Later for the basic calculations.
The outdoor units are much quieter than the older ones but take up a lot of space and still need power to run. An average of 8kw at the low end. That's 32 amps and many fuse boards are at the limit now so compared to a boiler at max 5 amps there are problems with the 'load' already.
The calculations for radiator sizing which I use are.
Living and dining rooms 5 BTU per cubic foot.
Bedrooms 4 BTU per cubic foot.
Bathrooms and ensuites 3 BTU per cubic foot.
BTU = British thermal units
3412 BTU = 1 kw or 1000 Watts.
Ie a lounge 10ft long x 15ft wide x7ft tall.
10 x 15 x 7 = 1050 x 5 = 5250 BTU or thereabouts
Different calcs for different rooms but same process.
If your heating with a boiler needs to be on longer than 20 minutes to warm your drum your rads are undersized I'm afraid.
I oversized mine by 20 % so 5 minutes and my place is steaming.
Most merchants brochures have radiator sizes and outputs so check if your rads are the correct size for a boiler system.
A rough measurement and type of radiator ( K1,K2 etc) will be close enough.
Then add 50% to the correct size for a boiler system to a heat pump system and watch your wall disappear for when you get a heat pump.
That's aside of an electric element in your hot water cylinder at
12amps (3 kw) to trim your hot water to 55*c and the problems gets bigger. Sadly hmg have not done any presearch or spoken to the pros and the tree huggers don't even get it either I'm afraid.
Pm me if you have any questions ref your rads.

Seconded.

 


Red and Blue Army!

BlueJay Flag UK 19 Oct 21 8.50pm

Originally posted by becky

Bloody silly idea - just tried it with disastrous results

Filled the bath with cold water, sat hubbie in it and plugged in the microwave to heat the water.

Anyway, the funeral is next week.

This would certainly cut your heating bill long term - but not recommended .

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 19 Oct 21 11.47pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The main problem is that the temperatures aren't the same as gas boilers deliver. Typically 82*c flow (out water temp)
and 71*c ( back water temp) return water temperature to the boiler. Hence the present radiator sizes required to heat the space ( room volume). Heat pumps deliver about 65*c flow which will mean up sizing radiators by at least 50%.
Ie a single will be a double and a double will be a treble. That's if they are sized correctly of course. Later for the basic calculations.
The outdoor units are much quieter than the older ones but take up a lot of space and still need power to run. An average of 8kw at the low end. That's 32 amps and many fuse boards are at the limit now so compared to a boiler at max 5 amps there are problems with the 'load' already.
The calculations for radiator sizing which I use are.
Living and dining rooms 5 BTU per cubic foot.
Bedrooms 4 BTU per cubic foot.
Bathrooms and ensuites 3 BTU per cubic foot.
BTU = British thermal units
3412 BTU = 1 kw or 1000 Watts.
Ie a lounge 10ft long x 15ft wide x7ft tall.
10 x 15 x 7 = 1050 x 5 = 5250 BTU or thereabouts
Different calcs for different rooms but same process.
If your heating with a boiler needs to be on longer than 20 minutes to warm your drum your rads are undersized I'm afraid.
I oversized mine by 20 % so 5 minutes and my place is steaming.
Most merchants brochures have radiator sizes and outputs so check if your rads are the correct size for a boiler system.
A rough measurement and type of radiator ( K1,K2 etc) will be close enough.
Then add 50% to the correct size for a boiler system to a heat pump system and watch your wall disappear for when you get a heat pump.
That's aside of an electric element in your hot water cylinder at
12amps (3 kw) to trim your hot water to 55*c and the problems gets bigger. Sadly hmg have not done any presearch or spoken to the pros and the tree huggers don't even get it either I'm afraid.
Pm me if you have any questions ref your rads.

That is such an excellent post on so many levels...

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 20 Oct 21 12.48am

I was quoted £15000 max for an installation and could claim back on govt grant, but no official figure set as not yet available in my area of UK. Not really an incentive.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 20 Oct 21 1.08am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

I was quoted £15000 max for an installation and could claim back on govt grant, but no official figure set as not yet available in my area of UK. Not really an incentive.

Limited to 90,000 grants too (out of 20 million+ homes).

 

BlueJay Flag UK 20 Oct 21 1.09am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

That is such an excellent post on so many levels...

I had the very same thought

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 20 Oct 21 6.50am

Originally posted by cryrst

The main problem is that the temperatures aren't the same as gas boilers deliver. Typically 82*c flow (out water temp)
and 71*c ( back water temp) return water temperature to the boiler. Hence the present radiator sizes required to heat the space ( room volume). Heat pumps deliver about 65*c flow which will mean up sizing radiators by at least 50%.
Ie a single will be a double and a double will be a treble. That's if they are sized correctly of course. Later for the basic calculations.
The outdoor units are much quieter than the older ones but take up a lot of space and still need power to run. An average of 8kw at the low end. That's 32 amps and many fuse boards are at the limit now so compared to a boiler at max 5 amps there are problems with the 'load' already.
The calculations for radiator sizing which I use are.
Living and dining rooms 5 BTU per cubic foot.
Bedrooms 4 BTU per cubic foot.
Bathrooms and ensuites 3 BTU per cubic foot.
BTU = British thermal units
3412 BTU = 1 kw or 1000 Watts.
Ie a lounge 10ft long x 15ft wide x7ft tall.
10 x 15 x 7 = 1050 x 5 = 5250 BTU or thereabouts
Different calcs for different rooms but same process.
If your heating with a boiler needs to be on longer than 20 minutes to warm your drum your rads are undersized I'm afraid.
I oversized mine by 20 % so 5 minutes and my place is steaming.
Most merchants brochures have radiator sizes and outputs so check if your rads are the correct size for a boiler system.
A rough measurement and type of radiator ( K1,K2 etc) will be close enough.
Then add 50% to the correct size for a boiler system to a heat pump system and watch your wall disappear for when you get a heat pump.
That's aside of an electric element in your hot water cylinder at
12amps (3 kw) to trim your hot water to 55*c and the problems gets bigger. Sadly hmg have not done any presearch or spoken to the pros and the tree huggers don't even get it either I'm afraid.
Pm me if you have any questions ref your rads.

The first batch of people will give their thoughts of how rubbish the idea of heat source boilers are

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 20 Oct 21 9.48pm

We've got underfloor heating in our gaff down here in Sussex so I don't know how that would work with a heat source pump.

To suggest that gas boilers will be obsolete in about 15 years time and replaced by heat source seems like the stuff of dreams. Cryst is either in the trade or has done his homework: either way the issues he describes are substantial. As I understand it these systems require an enormous amount of work to install at the cost of thousands of pounds.

To convert the entire population is an almost unimaginable task and expense that the government don't appear to have worked through at all. Nice idea, but surely not yet viable.

Anyway, where's all the electricity coming from to power just about everything in our lives from kettles to cars to heating?

Frankly, it's unlikely I'll still be around to see how all this pans out, but I do worry for my grandchildren.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.


You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Air Source heat pumps