You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When the injuries come...
November 16 2026 3.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

When the injuries come...


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
taylors lovechild Flag 01 Dec 21 3.28pm

I actually think Tomkins is possibly a better defender than Andersen and less likely to be muscled off the ball; however, this season we really do need two ball-playing centre-backs for the system to work well. Technically Jairo was brought in as a ball-playing centre-back, but he has never convinced me defensively. It'll also be interesting to see how Clyne gets on if he comes in for Ward (who I believe now has a one match ban). Last season he looked a bit lost positionally at times, but he is possibly faster and better when going forward than Ward. Kelly hasn't even looked convincing in the U23 games he's played, so I really can't see him playing again unless we get down to the bare bones.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Dec 21 4.15pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I actually think Tomkins is possibly a better defender than Andersen and less likely to be muscled off the ball; however, this season we really do need two ball-playing centre-backs for the system to work well. Technically Jairo was brought in as a ball-playing centre-back, but he has never convinced me defensively. It'll also be interesting to see how Clyne gets on if he comes in for Ward (who I believe now has a one match ban). Last season he looked a bit lost positionally at times, but he is possibly faster and better when going forward than Ward. Kelly hasn't even looked convincing in the U23 games he's played, so I really can't see him playing again unless we get down to the bare bones.

A defender who turns his back when the ball is kicked at him.

 


One more point

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Dec 21 4.46pm

Originally posted by Badger11

A defender who turns his back when the ball is kicked at him.

It's my opinion that anyone who does this shouldn't be in a Palace shirt. I remember one Danny Gabbidon doing so and then never playing for us again Was I glad to see his back on that occasion.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 05 Dec 21 4.32pm


Patrick Viera's post -match comments:

"I think we weren't brave enough to play out the back. We were missing players today, there was a lack of confidence in possession. We didn't allow ourselves to play."

In a nutshell. Top priority for Jan: buy another CB who is comfortable carrying. I'm sure Dougie must be able to recommend one that he's seen on his scouting missions.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Dec 21 8.57pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1


Patrick Viera's post -match comments:

"I think we weren't brave enough to play out the back. We were missing players today, there was a lack of confidence in possession. We didn't allow ourselves to play."

In a nutshell. Top priority for Jan: buy another CB who is comfortable carrying. I'm sure Dougie must be able to recommend one that he's seen on his scouting missions.

IMO, with the players selected, we weren’t good enough to play out from the back.

If your approach is so reliant on a thirty four year old midfielder who has inevitably picked up niggling injuries over the last few seasons and Both first choice centre backs being available then you need to have a good plan b.

I listened on the radio as I can’t be arsed with streams but have sympathy for the manager regarding the missed chances in the last two games and several others before

 

glaziermart Flag 05 Dec 21 10.49pm

PV has started to become negative. More frightened to lose than go for the win. His treatment of Hughes and Eduoard is odd to say the least. He can't decide where to play Olise (who never played wide right for Reading!!) - honestly the next 3 games: Everton, Southampton and Watford, if we don't get at least 7 points, the honeymoon is well and truly over.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 05 Dec 21 11.25pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

PV has started to become negative. More frightened to lose than go for the win. His treatment of Hughes and Eduoard is odd to say the least. He can't decide where to play Olise (who never played wide right for Reading!!) - honestly the next 3 games: Everton, Southampton and Watford, if we don't get at least 7 points, the honeymoon is well and truly over.

Second that! Wonder how PV can avoid trusting Edouard to start up front. And what does Will Hughes have to do to get into the team when (football)-brainless Schlupp lasted the whole game? Add to that, why put Eze and Olise on for just a couple of minutes?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Dec 21 7.29am

The fact PV is publicly highlighting concerns shows he will want to change things. He started brightly without having to rely on the squad as whole. Now injuries have hit and performances have slumped he will start to learn more about the players he has.

One thing his team need to learn is that Kouyate's job is to win the ball, block shots and be a big b@stard in the area for set-pieces. Do not give him the ball, you take it off him. His role is to do the dirty work. Gallagher kept giving him the ball unnecessarily, possibly mistaking him for Jorginho and Kouyate repaid him by misplacing nearly all his passes (surely he broke some kind of record on Sunday? Can you have a minus score for passing accuracy?) Two games running Schlupp has been wearing his invisibility cloak. I thought he deserved his chance to stake a claim. Sadly he looks as lost in the role as he did in preseason. He has looked best as a sub with the simple instruction "get in the box".

No doubt Everton will sack Benitez and hire Zidane before we play them on Sunday.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 06 Dec 21 8.52am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The fact PV is publicly highlighting concerns shows he will want to change things. He started brightly without having to rely on the squad as whole. Now injuries have hit and performances have slumped he will start to learn more about the players he has.

One thing his team need to learn is that Kouyate's job is to win the ball, block shots and be a big b@stard in the area for set-pieces. Do not give him the ball, you take it off him. His role is to do the dirty work. Gallagher kept giving him the ball unnecessarily, possibly mistaking him for Jorginho and Kouyate repaid him by misplacing nearly all his passes (surely he broke some kind of record on Sunday? Can you have a minus score for passing accuracy?) Two games running Schlupp has been wearing his invisibility cloak. I thought he deserved his chance to stake a claim. Sadly he looks as lost in the role as he did in preseason. He has looked best as a sub with the simple instruction "get in the box".

No doubt Everton will sack Benitez and hire Zidane before we play them on Sunday.

I'm quite looking forward to the Townsend-Mitchell match-up.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When the injuries come...