You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v West Ham match thread
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v West Ham match thread


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
Putitout Flag Oxford 03 Jan 22 10.49am

Originally posted by Willo

Analysing the goals we conceded against W.Ham, I appreciate that the commentators mentioned that it was an exquisite cross for the Antonio goal but is it only me who has concluded that Guehi could have done better ? He was facing the ball in front of Antonio yet the W.Ham player was able to get a touch and steer it home.

With regard to Lanzini's goal, the defence was so deep when Rice collected the ball,and he was able to advance in acres of space unchallenged before passing to his teammate who also ran through with not a Palace player tracking him.
I don't think that Andersen covered himself in glory when he approached Lanzini who easily beat him as Andersen was heading for the old stand ! In actual fact there were other players near Lanzini and he was able to flick the ball up and get in a shot which of course was not blocked and resulted in the goal.
Indeed skilful from Lanzini but poor from a Palace perspective all round.


I agree about Guehi, he doesn’t always appear to read situations where he has to be first to the ball, he has a tendency to take a let’s see where it goes, attitude, when he should just get something on the ball no matter what.
The biggest problem was that not for the first time in vital moments our mid field did not supply the shield that must be there,. The first goal happened because there was little or no interference with WH , having so much space on the flank. Ward can not be left in the way he was.
The second was no challenge from midfield on one of Europes best midfielders setting up another , with little or no challenge. So the defenders are not perfect but the real reason we leak goals is our midfield might provide more in attack but not enough from a defensive perspective.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 03 Jan 22 11.01am

Originally posted by Willo

Analysing the goals we conceded against W.Ham, I appreciate that the commentators mentioned that it was an exquisite cross for the Antonio goal but is it only me who has concluded that Guehi could have done better ? He was facing the ball in front of Antonio yet the W.Ham player was able to get a touch and steer it home.

With regard to Lanzini's goal, the defence was so deep when Rice collected the ball,and he was able to advance in acres of space unchallenged before passing to his teammate who also ran through with not a Palace player tracking him.
I don't think that Andersen covered himself in glory when he approached Lanzini who easily beat him as Andersen was heading for the old stand ! In actual fact there were other players near Lanzini and he was able to flick the ball up and get in a shot which of course was not blocked and resulted in the goal.
Indeed skilful from Lanzini but poor from a Palace perspective all round.

It was a great cross for the first goal, Ward unfortunately not close enough to Benrhama to make it even more difficult. Speedy wingers like Leeds away and he cannot deal with them now but still gives his all in other areas which is commendable. In defence of Guehi Antonio is as strong as an ox and looked like he just lost the battle to the ball. As said second goal was way too easy in build up and execution on our part but was a good strike all the same.

Great to see us come out fighting and attacking in the 2nd half and not try to contain. Not sure if it was true that Gallagher was being rested as he had a brilliant 2nd half away to them earlier in the season. He could of conjured up something again and taken a breather in the FA Cup. Overall a good performance from us, only lacking in the result and another pointer the team are going in the right direction. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

maddog Flag Wiltshire 03 Jan 22 11.39am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

It was a great cross for the first goal, Ward unfortunately not close enough to Benrhama to make it even more difficult. Speedy wingers like Leeds away and he cannot deal with them now but still gives his all in other areas which is commendable. In defence of Guehi Antonio is as strong as an ox and looked like he just lost the battle to the ball. As said second goal was way too easy in build up and execution on our part but was a good strike all the same.

Great to see us come out fighting and attacking in the 2nd half and not try to contain. Not sure if it was true that Gallagher was being rested as he had a brilliant 2nd half away to them earlier in the season. He could of conjured up something again and taken a breather in the FA Cup. Overall a good performance from us, only lacking in the result and another pointer the team are going in the right direction. COYP !!

It’s unfair to blame Ward for their first - neither his speed nor his positioning.
was at fault. He has been told to play as a CD when Palace have possession and so he moved across to form a back three with Andersen and Guehi as Palace’s midfield pushed up the field. The midfield (Hughes?) immediately lost possession though, failed to react quickly to that (no midfield press!) and the ball went straight out to WH’s left wing. Ward did his best to get back across and was pretty much there.

The goal was the result of that loss of possession - not Ward’s speed or lack of.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Jan 22 11.59am

Originally posted by maddog

It’s unfair to blame Ward for their first - neither his speed nor his positioning.
was at fault. He has been told to play as a CD when Palace have possession and so he moved across to form a back three with Andersen and Guehi as Palace’s midfield pushed up the field. The midfield (Hughes?) immediately lost possession though, failed to react quickly to that (no midfield press!) and the ball went straight out to WH’s left wing. Ward did his best to get back across and was pretty much there.

The goal was the result of that loss of possession - not Ward’s speed or lack of.


A correct assessment in my view. I would add that Ayew could have been closer (as noted by MOTD).

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 22 1.22pm

We seem to be in accord, that our defenders are not strong enough in the tackle. I agree that our midfield also didn't protect well enough for, all 3 goals actually.

So far this season Olise has been a better impact sub than a starter. Suspect he will, however, get a run of games now with Ayew & Zaha away for a while.

I really hope PV has the balls to play Gallagher, McArthur and Hughes but might be a bit weak in the heading department?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 22 4.02pm

Originally posted by Willo

Analysing the goals we conceded against W.Ham, I appreciate that the commentators mentioned that it was an exquisite cross for the Antonio goal but is it only me who has concluded that Guehi could have done better ? He was facing the ball in front of Antonio yet the W.Ham player was able to get a touch and steer it home.

With regard to Lanzini's goal, the defence was so deep when Rice collected the ball,and he was able to advance in acres of space unchallenged before passing to his teammate who also ran through with not a Palace player tracking him.
I don't think that Andersen covered himself in glory when he approached Lanzini who easily beat him as Andersen was heading for the old stand ! In actual fact there were other players near Lanzini and he was able to flick the ball up and get in a shot which of course was not blocked and resulted in the goal.
Indeed skilful from Lanzini but poor from a Palace perspective all round.

Possibly correct but football needs mistakes otherwise every game would end 0-0 ..some where in every build up someone ballsed up, obviously the further up the table you go less teams tend to do this but thankfully West Ham obliged twice.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 04 Jan 22 8.16am

For our first goal Diop ducked out of the way of the cross that gave Eduoard the chance to score.

 

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v West Ham match thread