You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > London’s 4th best team?
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

London’s 4th best team?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Bearcage Flag Welling 05 Jan 22 7.18am

West Ham are a richer club than us, helped by the size of their stadium and minimal related costs (subsidised by all Londoners), which will make it increasingly difficult for us to close the gap.
If you look at the available resources/income for Premier clubs, if Palace can break into the top half we are doing really well (punching above our weight). To do so consistently we need to up our income (e.g stadium development).
Otherwise we will continue as London’s 5th best team, and finishing towards the top of the bottom half in the Premier League, which is not something to be embarrassed about.

Edited by Bearcage (05 Jan 2022 7.20am)

 

YT Flag Oxford 05 Jan 22 9.01am

At the moment one could argue that we are the joint-worst PL team in London.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Jan 22 9.08am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

They don't have a ground, and they pay less wages than us, they mainly buy from smaller players

What a load of tripe

WH have a 99 year lease, so they effectively own the ground. Regardless of ownership they still have a much bigger ground than us (likely bigger than we'll ever have)

Over the last 4 seasons they have spent over £300 mill on transfers (we've spent about £100m), buying from the likes of Dortmund, Lazio, Arsenal, Villarreal.


What big clubs do we regularly buy players from? (plus any players we've got from bigger clubs have been on the way down)

Also why does it matter who you buy from?


 

Beastie Flag 05 Jan 22 9.31am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

What a load of tripe

WH have a 99 year lease, so they effectively own the ground. Regardless of ownership they still have a much bigger ground than us (likely bigger than we'll ever have)

Over the last 4 seasons they have spent over £300 mill on transfers (we've spent about £100m), buying from the likes of Dortmund, Lazio, Arsenal, Villarreal.


What big clubs do we regularly buy players from? (plus any players we've got from bigger clubs have been on the way down)

Also why does it matter who you buy from?


It doesn’t. And having the Olympic stadium built on their doorstep is not the point either.

They’re bigger because they have a bigger fanbase and because they’ve had a more successful history than us. The reality is though, that we’ve been on a par with them for a long time and their recent improvements on the pitch are what we should be striving for. And I think we’re heading the right way on that front.

 

leejaneagles Flag 05 Jan 22 10.34am

I think without getting an Oil-baron Owner, it's all a bit much of a muchness really.

There won't really be such a thing as the 'best of the rest', whether that's London in general or the whole League whilst those top 3 or 4 you mentioned have billions to spend.

It will ebb and flow. One year, West Ham will have the more experienced Manager with a settled Team and a consistent injury-free starting 11 playing to a game-plan. That will mean they finish top 6 and everyone will praise them in the Media as the next big thing and they will definitely make top 4 next season.

Then, their best players like Rice will go to City/United/Chelsea and coupled with European fixtures they aren't prepared for, they'll have a mare of a start to the Season and will be tipped for relegation before getting knocked out of Europe and eventually settling mid-table.

During that time, a different Club, may as well be Palace, will have a run where their new Manager Vieira has got his ideas in place, playing electric football, have a top player like Connor Gallagher injury free and we push for top 6. Everyone says we'll qualify for top 4 the following season but guess what. Someone buys Gallagher, we get into a relegation battle because of European games we aren't prepared for and don't have a big enough squad and 2 or 3 of our starting 11 get injured and then we finish lower than West Ham.

And so it is written.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Jan 22 10.40am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

They don't have a ground, and they pay less wages than us, they mainly buy from smaller players

We didn’t have a ground under Jordan’s era, we were renting it from Noades. Owning or renting a ground doesn’t make a lot of difference.
Where they buy players from is irrelevant, if they improve their team, it’s called good business, if they don’t pay much for them.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Jan 22 10.57am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

I think without getting an Oil-baron Owner, it's all a bit much of a muchness really.

There won't really be such a thing as the 'best of the rest', whether that's London in general or the whole League whilst those top 3 or 4 you mentioned have billions to spend.

It will ebb and flow. One year, West Ham will have the more experienced Manager with a settled Team and a consistent injury-free starting 11 playing to a game-plan. That will mean they finish top 6 and everyone will praise them in the Media as the next big thing and they will definitely make top 4 next season.

Then, their best players like Rice will go to City/United/Chelsea and coupled with European fixtures they aren't prepared for, they'll have a mare of a start to the Season and will be tipped for relegation before getting knocked out of Europe and eventually settling mid-table.

During that time, a different Club, may as well be Palace, will have a run where their new Manager Vieira has got his ideas in place, playing electric football, have a top player like Connor Gallagher injury free and we push for top 6. Everyone says we'll qualify for top 4 the following season but guess what. Someone buys Gallagher, we get into a relegation battle because of European games we aren't prepared for and don't have a big enough squad and 2 or 3 of our starting 11 get injured and then we finish lower than West Ham.

And so it is written.

Exactly this. Every season one of the midfield overachieve, but then return back to their natural home the next season!

 

Harpo64 Flag 06 Jan 22 3.21pm

This is the second season running that West Ham go into the new year sitting in the top 5.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 06 Jan 22 5.14pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Rubbish, similar size team

You've lost it.

They have won quite a lot down the years.

WH have spent 25 years in the PL. We have spent 12 seasons and almost all of that has been during this last run. Essentially they have been close to ever present in the PL with short stays in the Champo.

They fill a 50K seater stadium and have recently been valued higher than Newcastle prior to the Czech takeover.

 

uncleneal Flag Croydon 10 Jan 22 7.49am

I always used to say WH were the 3rd biggest team in London behind Spurs and Arsenal given the false position that Chelscum are in.

Unfortunately, the Russian money has now established them as a big team winning leagues and European Cups.

Overseas, I see Liverpool and Chelsea tops more than anyone else.

With regard to us, we haven miles to go before we are bigger than WH and given the ground, I cannot see t,his happening. We can still compete but size wise, we are a long way off.

 

SpyroCrystal 10 Jan 22 10.03am

I can tell you 100 per cent that Palace should be the 4th biggest club in London.
Arsenal, Chelski and Spurs are all bigger and unreachable unfortunately. However, West Ham are a 'paper tiger' and although bigger than us they are most certainly not better than the Palace.
We have better fans, better stadium and a better lore than the Spammers.
West Ham could collapse when Rice and Soucek leave. They are just a bloated version of Millwall with global recognition. The Covid fiasco really helped them settle otherwise I reckon they would have been set for another relegation battle last two seasons. If we ever sought ourselves fully at the top to the bottom we could easily surpass Wet Spam. London's real 4th best the Red and Blue. X

 


Big up the Palace!!!!

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 10 Jan 22 10.11am

Look squad wise west ham fans dont think its that good , they are very worried about cup runs as they dont have a very good team past there 1st 11 , and I live in a west ham area.
as for fan base we have 1m supporters waiting tobe tapped into , if manu keep playing badly the surrey lot may support there local team.
true fan base two biggest clubs in london are us and west ham we go into surrey they go into Essex , we had a bigger ground than west ham for along time before seating (us 51k+ WH 41k) so as who is the biggest its open , but one thing is needed a bigger ground ASAP

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Jan 22 10.29am

Perhaps someone could set me str8 here - my thoughts were that WH sold the Boleyn ground to property developers, pocketed the cash until they got custody / tenants rights at the ground now affectionately known as the tax payers stadium -

They then injected some of the money from the sale of the previous stadium into new players which on the back of having David Moyes as a seasoned manager is why we see them in their current form & league position -

Am I wrong ?

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 10 Jan 22 10.33am

spot on

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Jan 22 10.44am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Perhaps someone could set me str8 here - my thoughts were that WH sold the Boleyn ground to property developers, pocketed the cash until they got custody / tenants rights at the ground now affectionately known as the tax payers stadium -

They then injected some of the money from the sale of the previous stadium into new players which on the back of having David Moyes as a seasoned manager is why we see them in their current form & league position -

Am I wrong ?

Not entirely correct, they sacked Moyes, when they had some cash out of the stadium deal. They decided to bring in Pellegrini, who wasted most of it, they then went crawling back to Moyes. The now have a Czech billionaire on board bankrolling them.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > London’s 4th best team?