This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I like Andersen and was very pleased we signed him. I agree he most certainly is not a DM. He obviously needs a CB partner who is quick to play alongside him. Has limitations but think he is an upgrade on others we have (except Guehu)
|
|
|
Originally posted by OldFella
I try to ignore your frequent posts, but it is difficult when almost each post you do make marks you out as a div. For anyone new to communication on the internet, see above. Yes, I know, it is a bit isn't it? On the original suggestion, the same thought had crossed my mind but I feel Andersen will lack the mobility for the position, and that his long passing range would, if anything, become less of a weapon if he plays in midfield. When we play the ball around the edge of our box not only does Andersen get more time and space than he would in midfield, but the opponent is more likely to have pressed up the pitch a bit, creating space for the long pass. That said, wasn't there some talk that he played in midfield in the past?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think this could work well as DM good passer an captain material, Tomkins or even Kouyate and Guehi as CD, leaves Hughes, Gallagher and McArthur to get forward more, certainly better than Luka He's got the attributes but the pace and mobility, for me he's coming up short at centre back because of it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I concur with these sentiments. I accept that Andersen is a ball-playing central defender who can spray passes around to good effect but his sheer lack of pace is alarming and his mobility on the turn is called into question. Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2022 10.16am) I think he would be best suited playing in a back 3, with two mobile partners to cover him - it's a shame we don't have the wing-backs to make a system of that sort effective yet. Medium term, I think both Andersen and Guehi would benefit from a 3 at the back system - we'd have to recruit to make it work though. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (06 Jan 2022 11.39am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The very fact that the idea of Andersen playing in midfield is a discussion point perhaps shows how badly he's defended. I really can't think of a game where his defending has stood out as impressive, and he has often been poor in that respect. Guehi hasn't been a lot better. Neither of them can deal with a high ball into the box, and with Guaita being the type of keeper who mostly stays on his line, we are very vulnerable to crosses and at set plays. Teams are surely starting to work that out now. None of this means the players should be dropped. As others have said, we went out and paid good money for footballing centre-halves to fit our new system, and the whole set up is now built around them. When Tompkins (who is a much better defender under a high ball) plays, the team looks worse in every respect as he is not as comfortable in possession, so we no longer use the ball as well and end up with more defending to do anyway. Plus he struggles to play in the high defensive line we now use. The hope is that Andersen, Geuhi and Guaita all get better at the rudimentary basics of dealing with a ball into the box. V measured and sensible post. Couldn't agree more. We have invested in a new style of play. Not as defensively stable but also with less defending to do. We need to trust the process and take assurance in the fact that the CBs (and TM and NF) are young enough to lean, and will hopefully get better and better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
V measured and sensible post. Couldn't agree more. We have invested in a new style of play. Not as defensively stable but also with less defending to do. We need to trust the process and take assurance in the fact that the CBs (and TM and NF) are young enough to lean, and will hopefully get better and better. This is Marc Guehi's first season in the PL and at 6ft he is not that tall for a central-defender but I have seen him more imposing in the air than he has been at our club.He is young and inexperienced and will get better. I was not impressed with Andersen at Fulham and whilst we all recognise his qualities on the ball,his defensive frailties are there for all to see.
|
|
|
I think it's testament to Guehi that his age is so often overlooked - he's a year younger than Mitchell.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think it's testament to Guehi that his age is so often overlooked - he's a year younger than Mitchell. This is very true, I had not even realised that! We have a diamond here , we should enjoy him while we can, mainly because I believe he is destined for great things, would be nice if that was with Palace
|
|
|
Originally posted by viveasheagle
Rather than play in Midfield i was wondering in time if we might at times play 3 central defenders with 2 wing backs. Problem currently is we don't have any right sided wingback though i think both Mitchell and Schlupp could play the role on the left. 3-4-1-2. This is the system Fabio Capello used for AS Roma's 2000 winning side. Needs a certain personnel, but is effective.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I concur with these sentiments. I accept that Andersen is a ball-playing central defender who can spray passes around to good effect but his sheer lack of pace is alarming and his mobility on the turn is called into question. Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2022 10.16am) Willo.. good to see you back. I concur with our feelings re this. Hope you and the Misses had a good New Years. We're coming into a great time to be a Palace supporter (I think) so looking forward to hearing from you more again.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth. |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The very fact that the idea of Andersen playing in midfield is a discussion point perhaps shows how badly he's defended. I really can't think of a game where his defending has stood out as impressive, and he has often been poor in that respect. Guehi hasn't been a lot better. Neither of them can deal with a high ball into the box, and with Guaita being the type of keeper who mostly stays on his line, we are very vulnerable to crosses and at set plays. Teams are surely starting to work that out now. None of this means the players should be dropped. As others have said, we went out and paid good money for footballing centre-halves to fit our new system, and the whole set up is now built around them. When Tompkins (who is a much better defender under a high ball) plays, the team looks worse in every respect as he is not as comfortable in possession, so we no longer use the ball as well and end up with more defending to do anyway. Plus he struggles to play in the high defensive line we now use. The hope is that Andersen, Geuhi and Guaita all get better at the rudimentary basics of dealing with a ball into the box. Pretty sure this is a Guaita rather than a CB issue. Our record at defending set pieces was no better under RH last season. He's a good shot stopper but a definite liability if the ball is crossed in.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.