You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should We Field More Youngsters?
November 16 2026 4.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should We Field More Youngsters?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 03 Feb 22 11.07am

Originally posted by Elpis

Does anyone know how the FIFA proposal last year has developed . I guess it was shelved due to corona but the proposal was to reduce the amount of loans any club could do restricted to 6 per club both in and out .

That would obviously impact the way clubs like Chelsea operate with 30 odd players out and I think 1 (Niguez) in . Something would obviously have to give there with a pool of talent returning to Stamford bridge without a team to play in
(A cheeky bid for CG anyone ?)

The proposal would also encourage sides to use more of their own junior ranks without the the availability or option of a loan . It make our academy status even more important than first thought .

Or does SP know something we dont ?

In theory it should make a massive difference, and its the right kind of thing to stop the Chelsea's of the word loaning out 20 odd players.

But in practice the fact that it doesn't include home grown or home trained young players undermines it a little. Chelsea have over 20 players out on loan at the min, most would fall in that exclusion bracket.

So stops them hoarding older player, but doesn't stop them hovering up all the young talent.


 

deleted 25 Flag 07 Feb 22 8.21am

From the highlights I've seen from last season Scott Banks has that X factor .

We are going to miss Gallagher next season so would be good to see if anybody has the ability to step up

Two goals today, one a trademark freekick

Been out for awhile so missed going out on loan but think he is a natural

Edited by Vincehair (08 Feb 2022 7.26pm)

 

Den1923 Flag 08 Feb 22 10.35am

Clearly PV does not think they have reached the required standard and that is supported by the fact that no championship side has approached us as yet for loans of these players. As it stands it would be silly until we are safe to sacrifice experience for younger unproven players. As some have said it is a long way from u23 level to PL standard. Our first priority has to be safety for which we need to pass 40 points before we can say that and then if PV thinks they are worth a run out so be it!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 08 Feb 22 11.23am

Simple answer is, if they are good enough, then they will be given a chance, as seen with Adaramola against Hartlepool. If they aren’t good enough or better than who is already in the team they won’t.
The judgement of Vieira and his coaching team with all their years of experience in the game, needs to be trusted.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 08 Feb 22 12.09pm

If Wiki is accurate PV got his debut at Cannes when he was 18 -
So if anyone knows / has personal experience about this particular subject matter I would say he does.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 08 Feb 22 12.17pm

Originally posted by rikz

And how good has sancho been in the prem ? Would rather play players because they're good enough not because they're young. Like someone else has said, how many players have we released from our academy, have gone onto better things ? None. Zaha, wan bissaka, moses, Clyne, Mitchell, Watson, routledge have all broken into the first team so it shows when it comes to identifying young players who are good enough, as a club we have a pretty good track record.

I agree with this to a certain extent but on the flip side you have the likes of Mitchell, who wasn’t ready when he broke into the team but has nothing but improve ever since.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should We Field More Youngsters?