You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Main Stand - Presented 50 months ago !!!!!
November 16 2026 3.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New Main Stand - Presented 50 months ago !!!!!


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 19 Apr 22 1.16pm

Those conversations included the consideration of using a Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO) to purchase a parcel of land on the site that is currently owned by supermarket giant Sainsbury’s.

The council is understood to be prepared to facilitate the CPO if Palace are willing to fund it. All parties are understood to be eager for the redevelopment to be taken forward as soon as possible.

This is the main piece of good news. Sainsburys are the main reason for delays and getting a CPO would be be delicious schadenfreude.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (19 Apr 2022 1.16pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 19 Apr 22 2.28pm

Thanks for posting.

They really do make it next to impossible to do something that will positively impact an area.

Some of the improvement costs are madness - £100k for cycle routes?! How many people cycle to a football match

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 19 Apr 22 3.08pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Thanks for posting.

They really do make it next to impossible to do something that will positively impact an area.

Some of the improvement costs are madness - £100k for cycle routes?! How many people cycle to a football match

Probably Mapletree.

 


Pro USA & Israel

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 19 Apr 22 10.54pm

I can see an update but not any " significant progress "

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Apr 22 11.02pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Probably Mapletree.

Yup, sometimes.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 22 6.04am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Yup, sometimes.

It's not real cycling if it has a battery

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Apr 22 7.19am

Originally posted by cryrst

It's not real cycling if it has a battery

Or an engine and 4 doors.

Seriously though, this is good news and it shows that contrary to some opinions it hasn’t been consigned to the bottom drawer of someone’s desk.

My only concern is that inflation and materials cost will have significantly uplifted the overall scheme cost by possibly as much as 40-50% since it was originally planned. The Sainsburys land under CPO will not be that expensive in the grand scheme of things but a replacement for the Wooderson Close properties, the sec 106 agreement and a significant increase in build costs will be.

I think we are realistically still 5 years away from sitting in a new stand and my preference is still a rebuild of the Crystal Palace athletics stadium.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Apr 22 8.40am

Eagle - If I remember & I stand ready to be corrected but the Crystal Palace Athletics stadium was ruled out because it stands on the corner of 4 London boroughs (Along with some additional transport concerns) but basically ( if I remember correctly) the general feeling was that if we have this much trouble just satisfying Croydon borough, can you imagine what it would be like trying to get all 4 London boroughs to agree.

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Or an engine and 4 doors.

Seriously though, this is good news and it shows that contrary to some opinions it hasn’t been consigned to the bottom drawer of someone’s desk.

My only concern is that inflation and materials cost will have significantly uplifted the overall scheme cost by possibly as much as 40-50% since it was originally planned. The Sainsburys land under CPO will not be that expensive in the grand scheme of things but a replacement for the Wooderson Close properties, the sec 106 agreement and a significant increase in build costs will be.

I think we are realistically still 5 years away from sitting in a new stand and my preference is still a rebuild of the Crystal Palace athletics stadium.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 20 Apr 22 12.56pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Eagle - If I remember & I stand ready to be corrected but the Crystal Palace Athletics stadium was ruled out because it stands on the corner of 4 London boroughs (Along with some additional transport concerns) but basically ( if I remember correctly) the general feeling was that if we have this much trouble just satisfying Croydon borough, can you imagine what it would be like trying to get all 4 London boroughs to agree.

Yes the CP athletic stadium option has been explored and rejected many times. Not just the 4 borough issue - road infrastructure is a disaster and the local residents were very anti it, and they were organised and vocal. It's definitely a non starter

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 20 Apr 22 7.07pm

Some time ago I posted a few things about the new stand, written from my professional perspective as a planner.

Of the various issues covered, two seem pertinent in light of the Athletic article (which at least seems fairly well informed and not stuffed full of the usual inaccurate details and baseless speculation).

Firstly, for anyone who doesn't know what a Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO) is, it is a mechanism that allows the Council to buy your land for market price (ish) whether you want to sell it or not, when that land is needed for development from which the community will benefit. Usually, as in this case, the developer (CPFC) pays for it, the Council has the power in law to make it happen, so it is a partnership between club and Council.

Getting a CPO on the Sainsburys land was always a method likely to be pursued successfully if a fair price could not be agreed. Both Palace and Sainsburys would have known that all along. Which brings me to the second issue, timescales.

Palace got the original planning application through in record speed, and it's clear the Council want this to go ahead. The various tariffs and charges are perfectly reasonable, and it's really not clear to me why Palace took so long to sign the legal agreement and/or press for the CPO.

It isn't obvious that what is apparently happening now couldn't have happened within six months of the original planning permission, and I remain of the view that something within CPFC delayed progress.

Maybe...

The club weren't actually ready to get cracking when permission came through because they expected the planning process to take longer.

The club were focused on the academy at the time, and didn't want to take on two projects at once (it is still quite a small organisation at boardroom level I feel, which results in great care being taken for better or worse. Mostly better).

Up until recently, the club were worried about whether we had a squad likely to stay up for the foreseeable future, but now feel we do.

The club were worried that we didn't have enough salable assets on the pitch to bail the club out if construction costs spiralled, but now feel we do.

The club wanted to cull the wage bill before taking on a loan of the required size to build this stand, presuming we are repaying a loan on this project.

Textor is more upfront with the cash than his compatriots (keeping in mind that none of the spending on the stand is caught by FFP).

Covid.


Personally, I think all of these are reasonable considerations for the club to have, and if the stand gets started in the next 18 months it'll still be a pretty quick journey from paperwork to brickwork by the standards of most projects this size, especially in recent circumstances.

Man City would have done it quicker no doubt, but many wouldn't have done it at all. Ultimately, the stand will be around for much longer than most of us, and the delays are fairly small beer in that context.

 

dorking Flag 20 Apr 22 9.16pm

Thank you SW16 for sharing the paywall article, much appreciated.

And also to BigToe the planner, for a fair and reasonable summation.

I suspect the main delays were having confidence in Palace being a stable team in the league (which we now seem to have cracked) and not wanting to pay Sainsbury's huge demands for the sliver of land, bearing in mind Harris and Blitzer have wanted out for a couple of years.

I think the materials costs have massively spiralled over the last 2 years, and so there must be signs that Textor is willing to chuck huge amounts of dosh to get this done.

All of the above is just my own gut feelings on the matter based on nothing other than guesswork and hunches!!!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Apr 22 10.54pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Eagle - If I remember & I stand ready to be corrected but the Crystal Palace Athletics stadium was ruled out because it stands on the corner of 4 London boroughs (Along with some additional transport concerns) but basically ( if I remember correctly) the general feeling was that if we have this much trouble just satisfying Croydon borough, can you imagine what it would be like trying to get all 4 London boroughs to agree.

You are of course correct but that was just my preference for location without worrying too much about the restrictions. I have always favoured a move to a new site but I do appreciate all of the arguments against doing this.

Ultimately with the direction we are currently going, I think we will continue to upgrade the ground by either buying the site off Sainsburys or agreeing a rebuild of the Whitehorse stand incorporating a new store. It would be nice to think that might happen in the next 20 years. I’m sure a lot of fans would prefer an upgrade on the Arthur first though!

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Main Stand - Presented 50 months ago !!!!!