You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another astonishing VAR decision.
November 22 2026 7.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another astonishing VAR decision.


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Mar 22 10.17am

Originally posted by Willo

My view for what it is worth (Probably not a lot !) is that the VAR has seen contact with the arm but adjudged that the actual position of contact is inconclusive based on 'Sleeve line', 'Bottom of the armpit' etc etc.

PGMOL have apologised to Everton for decisions made! Presumably Palace’s apology is in the post!,
Will the Officials from Saturday be demoted? Maybe for 1 game, the game is being ruined by incompetent officials

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 10.24am

Originally posted by Spiderman

PGMOL have apologised to Everton for decisions made! Presumably Palace’s apology is in the post!,
Will the Officials from Saturday be demoted? Maybe for 1 game, the game is being ruined by incompetent officials

Officials being human will err from time to time, but I do not accept that there is gross incompetence on display apropos the refereeing fraternity.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Mar 22 11.14am

Originally posted by Willo

Officials being human will err from time to time, but I do not accept that there is gross incompetence on display apropos the refereeing fraternity.

Well imo, that var decision and those at Palace were gross incompetence. We will never agree on this I suspect

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 01 Mar 22 12.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

Officials being human will err from time to time, but I do not accept that there is gross incompetence on display apropos the refereeing fraternity.

Mistakes aren’t the issue though - refs are only human so some errors are inevitable; particularly when players are so adept at conning them, but VAR was brought in to stop these sorts of thing happening and it hasn’t been very successful. Or if it has the error rate before it’s introduction must’ve been very high indeed.

 

The Dolphin Flag 01 Mar 22 1.49pm

Originally posted by Willo

Officials being human will err from time to time, but I do not accept that there is gross incompetence on display apropos the refereeing fraternity.

Willo - the VAR referee should not make these mistakes - he has every view on a screen in front of him.
For Everton it was obvious beyond belief and in our game versus Liverpool if he saw what the rest of the world saw then how was it a penalty.
It is corrupt in the var office - it must be because no one can be that blind or incompetent - they are downright cheats!

 

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 01 Mar 22 1.52pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

PGMOL have apologised to Everton for decisions made! Presumably Palace’s apology is in the post!,
Will the Officials from Saturday be demoted? Maybe for 1 game, the game is being ruined by incompetent officials

Nope - Chris Kavanagh (the VAR official) is due to ref the Burnley v Leicester game tonight.

Edited by Charlie Croker (01 Mar 2022 1.52pm)

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 01 Mar 22 1.58pm

Originally posted by Willo

Officials being human will err from time to time, but I do not accept that there is gross incompetence on display apropos the refereeing fraternity.

The on-field mistakes are not the point, as others have said. VAR is supposed to help the on-field officials in rectifying their mistakes or, at the very least, it's supposed to give them the ability to watch it again. Which, in this case if he'd been asked to would have almost certainly have led to overturning the original decision.

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Mar 22 2.07pm

Here are the appointments for 5th round . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 2.15pm

Originally posted by Charlie Croker

The on-field mistakes are not the point, as others have said. VAR is supposed to help the on-field officials in rectifying their mistakes or, at the very least, it's supposed to give them the ability to watch it again. Which, in this case if he'd been asked to would have almost certainly have led to overturning the original decision.

The on-field referee has not awarded a penalty the VAR has deemed that the evidence was inconclusive accordingly the mechanism for asking the referee to consult the monitor was not activated.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Mar 22 2.59pm

Originally posted by Willo

The on-field referee has not awarded a penalty the VAR has deemed that the evidence was inconclusive accordingly the mechanism for asking the referee to consult the monitor was not activated.

Inconclusive only in the mind of the VAR. It should not be a subjective decision, the very least the ref should have been referred to the screen. Obviously PGMOL think it was a wrong decision.
IMO the VAR officials should be independent from the referees “boys club”. Should be ex-players who have some idea of whether someone has actually been fouled or is trying to con the ref

Edited by Spiderman (01 Mar 2022 3.07pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 3.10pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Inconclusive only in the mind of the VAR. It should not be a subjective decision, the very least the ref should have been referred to the screen. Obviously PGMOL think it was a wrong decision.

The VAR clearly decided that having looked at the images,as far as he was concerned it was inconclusive as to whether the contact with the ball was made in an area which constitutes 'Handball'.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Mar 22 3.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

The VAR clearly decided that having looked at the images,as far as he was concerned it was inconclusive as to whether the contact with the ball was made in an area which constitutes 'Handball'.

With all due respect Willo, unless there is ambiguity as to what is categorised as an arm, VAR has the capability to review the instance from various camera angles, in slow motion, and decide whether it hit a f***ing arm or not.

The only two explanations are either corruption or gross incompetency. Given the CK is now in charge of the Burnley game I have to assume it's the former.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 3.34pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

With all due respect Willo, unless there is ambiguity as to what is categorised as an arm, VAR has the capability to review the instance from various camera angles, in slow motion, and decide whether it hit a f***ing arm or not.

The only two explanations are either corruption or gross incompetency. Given the CK is now in charge of the Burnley game I have to assume it's the former.

I totally reject the accusations that corruption is at the heart of VAR decisions, accordingly I reject the charge that the decision which has caused such controversy was borne out of corruption.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Mar 22 3.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

The VAR clearly decided that having looked at the images,as far as he was concerned it was inconclusive as to whether the contact with the ball was made in an area which constitutes 'Handball'.

Well it seems that only VAR and you are the only 2 who think it was inconclusive. TBF I think Tierney was unsighted so needed VAR to step up, clearly who was not up to the task

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Mar 22 3.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

I totally reject the accusations that corruption is at the heart of VAR decisions, accordingly I reject the charge that the decision which has caused such controversy was borne out of corruption.

Maybe not but the decisions given against us in the Liverpool game, smacked of corruption, as I sincerely hope the PL are not knowingly employing totally incompetent Officials

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 3.49pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Well it seems that only VAR and you are the only 2 who think it was inconclusive. TBF I think Tierney was unsighted so needed VAR to step up, clearly who was not up to the task

The VAR formed the opinion that the evidence was inconclusive and clearly this will (If it hasn't already) be discussed as part of the forensic post-match analysis.

Had the ball made contact lower down on the arm, the VAR would have arrived at a different decision.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 22 3.52pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Maybe not but the decisions given against us in the Liverpool game, smacked of corruption, as I sincerely hope the PL are not knowingly employing totally incompetent Officials

With respect I have already stated why I believe the penalty was awarded in the Jota incident.

I don't believe I have anymore to add on the Jota penalty decision or the incident involving Rodri.

Edited by Willo (01 Mar 2022 3.58pm)

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 02 Mar 22 11.01am

strange that Riley says sorry to everton but not us , not looking good regarding the person on VAR ,

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Mar 22 2.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

I totally reject the accusations that corruption is at the heart of VAR decisions, accordingly I reject the charge that the decision which has caused such controversy was borne out of corruption.

You'll be surprised how widespread corruption is on this planet. This country is no exception. Tends to follow big money. Take a look at the recent growth of money in football and join up the dots.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 02 Mar 22 4.09pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

You'll be surprised how widespread corruption is on this planet. This country is no exception. Tends to follow big money. Take a look at the recent growth of money in football and join up the dots.

I wouldn't say I entirely subscribe to your thinking although I did bring up corruption but more 'tongue in cheek' than a devoted belief let alone evidence for. I do think it naive however to not look at the culture and circumstances around football (as you've highlighted) and not accept it as at least a possibility if not reality.

I could never be a football referee at any level, I know I'd have bias whomever was playing whether it be the Sudanese second division or the English Premier League. If you then added a significant sum of money to the equation of which I was confident would remain unexposed, I'd certainly be willing to give a few dodgy decisions here and there Let's say Southampton vs Wolves or something, would be very hard to make a full case for in any circumstance without full evidence, given the ambiguity around officiating these days. Throw 5 or 6 figures on the table and I'd certainly be inclined!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another astonishing VAR decision.