You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So it’s admitted it wasn’t a penalty
November 16 2026 4.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So it’s admitted it wasn’t a penalty


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Feb 22 3.40am

Got to say I’m running out of steam on VAR. AND THis new rule on handling of offsides gets my goat. Bothe ways they let the game go on. Then decide. Why not put an electronic chip in the device already on the back of every player that would beep if they’re offside. Then it’s instant. The only good one is goal line technology cos it’s instant.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Feb 22 4.20am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Got to say I’m running out of steam on VAR. AND THis new rule on handling of offsides gets my goat. Bothe ways they let the game go on. Then decide. Why not put an electronic chip in the device already on the back of every player that would beep if they’re offside. Then it’s instant. The only good one is goal line technology cos it’s instant.

Typical though that the one they get right is the one that happens most infrequently.
The Middlesbrough handball was daft as well, the fact it was a different player who scored shouldn’t matter. Not that it wasn’t funny of course.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 07 Feb 22 9.31am

It seems to me that VAR was only invented to make sure that LiVARpool win matches . I wonder are the players themselves not embarrased by some of the decisions , i know their managers not .

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 07 Feb 22 4.08pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Totally agree. The ref has given the keeper a yellow, so there's no argument about it being an infringement or not. The keeper was the last man, had the Cardiff player taken it round the keeper he would have had the whole goal to aim at.

watch again there was a liverpool player behind him and he didnt have control of the ball so sorry its only a yellow , and i had a ref sitting next to me watching the game he told me

 

uncleneal Flag Croydon 08 Feb 22 8.19am

Before VAR when a mistake was made, you could feel some sympathy as the game is played at such a pace nowadays.

The scouse pen is completely different in that they had time to analyse it and came to that decision. Football is sometimes about opinions but this is not one of those situations….it was not a pen. You could easily argue a yellow for Jota.

The check on the offside is absurd and you could see Dermot Gallagher’s embarrassment at explaining it. Complete bollox.

Personally, I do not believe in corruption but there has always been an unconscious bias towards the top teams.

Hate scousers.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 08 Feb 22 8.59am

Originally posted by mtp1958

watch again there was a liverpool player behind him and he didnt have control of the ball so sorry its only a yellow , and i had a ref sitting next to me watching the game he told me

bit of a Loophole really ?

In A usual in play situation like this, and the Defender was the 'last man', there's still a player behind him - the goalie. yet that is a Red Card? Why should this be any different just because it's the goalkeeper making the challenge and a defender behind him?
doesn't offside cater for that situation - why shouldn't this?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

southnorwoodhill Flag 08 Feb 22 9.56am

Originally posted by mtp1958

watch again there was a liverpool player behind him and he didnt have control of the ball so sorry its only a yellow , and i had a ref sitting next to me watching the game he told me

Ok I've had another look and paused it where the keeper slids in an makes contact with the Cardiff player. The LiVARpool defender is in line with the keeper, roughly about 6 to 8 feet away. If the Cardiff player had evaded the scything foul and emerged with the ball he would have been in with the opportunity of a punt toward the open goal, albeit from about 40 yards. I think most professional players can hit the target from that sort of distance, so this was a clear scoring opportunity denied by foul play.
Crucially it was 0-0 at the time and Cardiff were playing with good intent. Sound familiar?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (08 Feb 2022 9.58am)

 

EddieMac Flag 08 Feb 22 10.48am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I found it interesting that the clip shown to Friend only shows the contact it does not show Jota running into the box, looking at Guaita and adjusting his run to take him into the keeper. In other words, the contact has been taken out of context with the overall play, almost as if they were searching for something to make it look like a penalty.

Shocking, truly shocking officiating by the VAR official and then Friend for being sucked in.

Exactly this. I couldn’t believe the footage he was shown which is why Pawson should be the one taking all the heat for both goals.

 

Palace BANANA Flag Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 08 Feb 22 11.11am

Originally posted by mtp1958

watch again there was a liverpool player behind him and he didnt have control of the ball so sorry its only a yellow , and i had a ref sitting next to me watching the game he told me

Totally disagree, sounds like "your ref" got it wrong too.. if a defender/outfield player had made that challenge in the same sort of situation he would've/should've been RED carded.. apart from anything else the keeper had his studs up, another RED card challenge by todays rules.. as for the paltry "punishment" Kevin Friend was given, it means nothing now as it won't change the result.. the scoucers cheated once AGAIN and got away with it once AGAIN.. SALAH one of the worst.. why hasn't Craig Pawson been "punished"?.. Friend hadn't given the penalty, Pawson told him to look at the VAR monitor suggesting/telling him it was a pen.. also what about their 2nd goal against us, Roberto Firmino in an offside position and interfering with play.. where was VAR, Pawson, then telling Friend it was offside.. both should be demoted and/or fined.. it does smack of favouritism particularly when you add in the two very bad decisions against Cardiff at the weekend when it was still 0-0..

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 08 Feb 22 11.30am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

bit of a Loophole really ?

In A usual in play situation like this, and the Defender was the 'last man', there's still a player behind him - the goalie. yet that is a Red Card? Why should this be any different just because it's the goalkeeper making the challenge and a defender behind him?
doesn't offside cater for that situation - why shouldn't this?

It’s another one of those “anywhere else on the pitch that would’ve been a foul” or “if that hadn’t been done just after kick-off it would’ve been a card” deals.
When one of the commentators pets commits a foul it’s almost always “out of frustration”.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 08 Feb 22 12.05pm

Or they rush to say - it looks worse than it is

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

It’s another one of those “anywhere else on the pitch that would’ve been a foul” or “if that hadn’t been done just after kick-off it would’ve been a card” deals.
When one of the commentators pets commits a foul it’s almost always “out of frustration”.

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 09 Feb 22 2.13pm

Originally posted by Palace BANANA



Totally disagree, sounds like "your ref" got it wrong too..
if a defender/outfield player had made that challenge in the same sort of situation he would've/should've been RED carded.. apart from anything else the keeper had his studs up, another RED card challenge by todays rules.. as for the paltry "punishment" Kevin Friend was given, it means nothing now as it won't change the result.. the scoucers cheated once AGAIN and got away with it once AGAIN.. SALAH one of the worst.. why hasn't Craig Pawson been "punished"?.. Friend hadn't given the penalty, Pawson told him to look at the VAR monitor suggesting/telling him it was a pen.. also what about their 2nd goal against us, Roberto Firmino in an offside position and interfering with play.. where was VAR, Pawson, then telling Friend it was offside.. both should be demoted and/or fined.. it does smack of favouritism particularly when you add in the two very bad decisions against Cardiff at the weekend when it was still 0-0..

would love to agree with you the only grey area , is the tackle reckless and should be a foul for serious foul play which is a red card , but the red for preventing a goal scoring chance , theres more than last man involed , the liverpool player was close enough to prevent and the player missed controled the ball so would not have had a clear run . we would not have been happy if our keeper was sent off so , i hate it when my mate is right and explains the reason behind it and smiles when saying it grrrrr

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Feb 22 2.49pm

So every pundit was wrong, every other player who commented and every fan - except for one or two Liverpool ones - are also wrong. Fair enough, glad that's sorted out.
What I will say is we should get over it now. It's in the past. Win tonight.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So it’s admitted it wasn’t a penalty