Why is this in Transfer Talk?

FEELING GLAD ALL OVER

Another one the club allowed to leave and has not hit the heights. I guess we made the right call after all.

I love the spin of how after a successful spell in Germany he went to the MLS. Young talent does not leave Europe for the MLS and then sign for Swindon.

Edited by Badger11 (13 Mar 2022 12.02pm)

One more point

Yup I know but how hard did we try? Or did his agent spin it that he wanted to leave as we didn't offer him what he wanted?

One more point

I suspect he got offered what he was worth, and he thought we was better than that.

I guess ultimately we were right

So far none of the players in the Parish regime we have released have gone onto bigger and better things so kudos to Dougie and the academy team.

There is an argument why were they not released earlier but often the coaches know that only 1 player in a group will make it. The other 10 are there to help him although they don't know it.

One more point

There's only one I can think of Noni Madueke at PSV... but he left our set up for Spurs. He was very young and not sure what the situation was with that. However with such a huge pool of players at the age it's inevitable some will slip through the gaps, usually down to the huge differences in physical development at that age.

As you say the fact we can hardly name anyone who's gone on to better things shows we're doing something right. For me getting one player from the youth set up established in the first team every two seasons is the benchmark for a successful academy. We seem to be heading in the right direction, AWB, Mitchell... next possibly one of Adaramola, Rak-Sakyi or Banks seem the best bet - but sometimes there's a relative surprise. Those who fall short it seems with our new set up we're committed to support the young players achieve elsewhere.

We do seem to keep them for too long though. Sam Wood was almost 23 when we released him. Surely a decision could have been made earlier.
Ryan Inniss is the most bizarre one - i think he was 26 before we finally got rid of him.
Surely it doesn't suit either party after say 21 if they are nowhere near the 1st team.

Clearly some players have injuries and/or have late development but in Inniss's case he was massive at 18.

We had a young reserve goalie a few years back - at 21 he was loaned to a Conference South side. Surely that should have been happening a few years earlier to toughen him her.

Both Egbo and Jonny Wiliams are out of contract at Swindon - it will be interesting to see what happens.

Interestingly there are quite a lot of other ex Palace youngsters out of contract with their lower league clubs - it can be quite ruthless at that level, with clubs often only offering 1 year contracts.

Also notice ex Palace target Michael Hector, who had verbally agreed to join Palace before opting for Chelsea (where he never kicked a ball) has been released by Fulham after again barely kicking a ball over the last 2 seasons.

I'm expecting Johnny Williams to rejoin Charlton now that Ben Garner is manager there

Old, Ungifted and White