This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Take your point but only one of those from our academy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Take your point but only one of those from our academy. None of them are. Mitchell came from Brentford's academy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Take your point but only one of those from our academy. The op didn't mention the academy. He's talking about the club having lots of highly-regarded talent. A bit like West Ham in the 1960s...which incidentally was referred to as "the academy" just to confuse the issue.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
As sure as night follows day our academy will churn out the type of players we now have in the first team. What SP has pulled off with its location and design is nothing short of phenomenal. Look what Chelsea academy does at Cobham. Give ours a few seasons and it will be on a par with Chelsea. Think that's setting the bar too high really. A couple of points. Naive to think I believe we will match Chelsea as a draw to young talent. How many people growing up in our catchment area actually support us? And that's leaving aside draw Chelsea have in the market and youth football is very much a market place nowadays. We can offer a clearer route to the first team than Chelsea can perhaps but even here they are well ahead of us with Chaloboah and James and Mount etc well established and they have the art of farming talent out on loan to a very fine art. There's a strong precedent to be attracted to Chelsea if you look at the likes of Guehi, Tomori, Livramento, Broja etc A slightly contrary point is that I suspect what we are seeing right now at Chelsea is some form of high water mark that is unlikely to be reproduced for a couple of generations - the contemporary class of 92. The type of players we have in our first team are in some ways generational talents especially if you look at Zaha, Olise, Eze and Gallagher. Only one of those was home reared. The others were the pick of the crop from elsewhere - that sort of player is not churned out Edited by Omph (24 Mar 2022 9.32am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
My opinion was that an academy/perusal of young players was based on recognising talent and polishing diamonds in the rough as opposed to picking up kids kicking around in SE London and turning them into Lionel Messi! Recruitment, talent spotting etc is the main focus of the game these days, especially at top level. The most romantic story is that of your Wilfried Zaha, who grows up a stones throw away from Selhurst and starts with us from day dot, but that will never be the be all and end all. WZ is a very special talent but I do get the feeling sometimes people expect there to be 10,000 of him knocking about in Sunday leagues across Southwark, Lewisham, Bromley, Croydon, Sutton etc at any given stage and we should be picking them up then. Think you have it . From memory Manchester United recently nabbed our local youth scout! Nothing is sacred - it's a real marketplace down there.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Think that's setting the bar too high really. A couple of points. Naive to think I believe we will match Chelsea as a draw to young talent. How many people growing up in our catchment area actually support us? And that's leaving aside draw Chelsea have in the market and youth football is very much a market place nowadays. We can offer a clearer route to the first team than Chelsea can perhaps but even here they are well ahead of us with Chaloboah and James and Mount etc well established and they have the art of farming talent out on loan to a very fine art. There's a strong precedent to be attracted to Chelsea if you look at the likes of Guehi, Tomori, Livramento, Broja etc A slightly contrary point is that I suspect what we are seeing right now at Chelsea is some form of high water mark that is unlikely to be reproduced for a couple of generations - the contemporary class of 92. The type of players we have in our first team are in some ways generational talents especially if you look at Zaha, Olise, Eze and Gallagher. Only one of those was home reared. The others were the pick of the crop from elsewhere - that sort of player is not churned out Edited by Omph (24 Mar 2022 9.32am) Well maybe just maybe the next generation will be an improvement on current and south london is an area that just may have above average hungry talent. I’m sure Parish considered things carefully before creating the academy. Plus, I’m a glass overflowing fan which obviously distorts my opinion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
None of them are. Mitchell came from Brentford's academy. A tad pedantic, but, yes he did. BUT, went straight into our academy in 2016 . . . [Link]
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
As sure as night follows day our academy will churn out the type of players we now have in the first team. What SP has pulled off with its location and design is nothing short of phenomenal. Look what Chelsea academy does at Cobham. Give ours a few seasons and it will be on a par with Chelsea. The quality of youngsters who hit our first team these days has definitely improved since the likes of Tom Soares and Gary Borrowdale
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
The quality of youngsters who hit our first team these days has definitely improved since the likes of Tom Soares and Gary Borrowdale Could not of got any worse. Yes, we have certainly come a long way since then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Crystal_Clear
Could not of got any worse. Yes, we have certainly come a long way since then. We've bought far worse, even for quite large fees for us. The funniest I can remember is Gareth Taylor. I thought Soares and Borrowdale were ok for the time.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
This is a great read and far more interesting than the other recent articles
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
The quality of youngsters who hit our first team these days has definitely improved since the likes of Tom Soares and Gary Borrowdale Both good players for us Soares and England U23 went for a decent fee when we were in financial trouble £2.5 M rings a bell Borowdale went for about £650,000 after making over 100 appearances . Both saw their carears nosedive but thats hardly reflective of where they were while at the Palace .
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.