This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Semi final goalkeeper
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Casual Orpington 07 Apr 22 9.16am |
|
|
Butland has played all the cup games , apart from the f*ck up at millwall he’s done well. But an FA cup semi final, surely Viera would play the keeper that he considers to be the best and plays the majority of the games ? I’d play Guaita , admittedly Viera knows more about football than me. But could he run a successful plastering firm? Doubt it.
|
Sansbup Norfolk 07 Apr 22 9.30am |
|
|
For the sake of team morale and good man-management Butland must play. He's a fine keeper and will do us proud, but I'm a huge Guaita fan.
|
pssguy 07 Apr 22 10.14am |
|
|
This is a must-win game and Guaita is the better goalkeeper. Sub on Butland when we are 4-0 up with 5 minutes to play. Rinse and repeat in the Final
|
silvertop Portishead 07 Apr 22 10.20am |
|
|
Whoever is performing best in training and who the defenders say they are more comfortable having behind them.
The other can get Leicester away.
|
Nubes London 07 Apr 22 10.28am |
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Whoever is performing best in training and who the defenders say they are more comfortable having behind them.
The other can get Leicester away.
He can’t just bench Butland after he has held the position from the first cup game.
Not happening!
|
Palace Old Geezer Midhurst 07 Apr 22 10.32am |
|
|
Funny thing, I was just pondering this very issue earlier.
Both are fine keepers, but each has weaknesses. Either would do us proud at Wembley and I'm tending to favour Butland for the semi as he's kept goal in our Cup run so far.
But then, what about the final? Would be harsh not to give Guaita that one, but what does that say to Butland?
Who'd be a football manager eh?
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 07 Apr 22 3.31pm |
|
|
It's a squad game and we should go with our strongest 11 given the enormity and occasion.
Guaita is first choice which is why he plays the league games. He should play vs Chelsea.
We've played lesser opposition in every round, so at the time it was a calculated risk to play second choice Butland whilst giving him match practice to keep sharp.
Butland has done well, but he's also a professional and knows the score.
|
cryrst The garden of England 07 Apr 22 3.57pm |
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
It's a squad game and we should go with our strongest 11 given the enormity and occasion.
Guaita is first choice which is why he plays the league games. He should play vs Chelsea.
We've played lesser opposition in every round, so at the time it was a calculated risk to play second choice Butland whilst giving him match practice to keep sharp.
Butland has done well, but he's also a professional and knows the score.
This. I'm sure PV won't care who he upsets by the team he picks. Ward, tekkers and luka have found this out recently. I would go with vinny and butland will like it or lump it.
|
EddieMac 07 Apr 22 4.55pm |
|
|
Personally I don’t think there is much to choose between them both so would have no issue if Butland started.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 08 Apr 22 9.28pm |
|
|
Butland should play and VG is worthy of the no 1 shirt. Man management. Neither have let us down.
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 09 Apr 22 4.37am |
|
|
Viera is an honest coach and he's fair... I can see Butland keeping a well deserved spot.
However, Butland is professional enough to accept the decision that VG is the club #1...
Although....... VG art his age, isn't the future for palace...
Having said that, is Rutland ripe to take the #1 spot
But..... if you change it up and VG makes a flap, that bad karma??
Then again..... Vg could play a blinder...
suppose Butland cracks?
As you can see, it's all if's and buts..
Personally I would hope VG plays a blinder at Leicester, then gets the call for the SF and takes that into it.
This was once a quality forum....
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Apr 22 7.23am |
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
Viera is an honest coach and he's fair... I can see Butland keeping a well deserved spot.
However, Butland is professional enough to accept the decision that VG is the club #1...
Although....... VG art his age, isn't the future for palace...
Having said that, is Rutland ripe to take the #1 spot
But..... if you change it up and VG makes a flap, that bad karma??
Then again..... Vg could play a blinder...
suppose Butland cracks?
As you can see, it's all if's and buts..
Personally I would hope VG plays a blinder at Leicester, then gets the call for the SF and takes that into it.
I hope VG won't NEED to play a blinder at Leicester.
|
Cpfctill1die Boxhill 11 Apr 22 11.16am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'BUTLAND or Guaita on Sunday' by becky
PV has played Jack all the way so far in the cup - be interesting to see his choice on Sunday - personally I’d keep with Butland
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Apr 22 11.19am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'BUTLAND or Guaita on Sunday' by becky
Originally posted by Cpfctill1die
PV has played Jack all the way so far in the cup - be interesting to see his choice on Sunday - personally I’d keep with Butland
Think this has already been 'opened' in the 'Team for Semi-final' or something, thread fella.
May well get merged with that, or probably should.
For me, on form as well as ability, I'd go with Guaita but would not feel the Hennessey inspired panic I used to if not the case! That's Burnley's problem now 
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
Midlands Eagle 11 Apr 22 3.30pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'BUTLAND or Guaita on Sunday' by becky
[Link]
|
Pierre Purley 11 Apr 22 3.36pm |
|
|
I agree with Viabow on this and think that PV will stick with Butland. However as it has been said he always very much picks who he thinks deserves to play each week so who knows!!!
|
mars Folkestone 11 Apr 22 4.48pm |
|
|
We have two excellent keepers! Personally it’s Butland for me
|
mtp1958 Oswestry 12 Apr 22 9.40am |
|
|
I am a , if its not broken dont fix it , so Butland got us to here so he plays simples WEMBLEY WEMBLEY WE ARE THE FAMOUS CRYSTAL PALACE AND WE ARE GOING TO WEMBLEY
COYP
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 13 Apr 22 5.19am |
|
|
Stick with Butland!
|