You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Mag- Palace hate article
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Mag- Palace hate article


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Sansbup Flag Norfolk 09 Apr 22 11.51am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

....They're a one club city. If you are from Newcastle you support Newcastle that's how it is. We are one of 3 clubs in South London alone without taking North, West and East London into consideration....

Not sure you're right there... isn't Newcastle a suburb of Sunderland? Or is it Middlesbrough?

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Apr 22 12.44pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Not sure you're right there... isn't Newcastle a suburb of Sunderland? Or is it Middlesbrough?

I thought Newcastle were just a s*** team in Hartlepool

 

BlueJay Flag UK 09 Apr 22 12.52pm

They've used Palace and indeed HOL for their source material before:

"Crystal Palace fans pleased with own team but can’t believe how bad Newcastle were – Interesting comments"

[Link]

--


Crystal Palace fans have their say on Newcastle United match (and takeover obviously…

[Link]


It's just quick and easy posts for them, that get a reaction. It's someone on the look out for clicks and £££. We buy into it by highlighting it really.

On the plus side if you're looking to feature in a future article, I would assume that they're reading this thread so say something witty or controversial and you might feature

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Apr 22 2.50pm

Does anyone seriously care what Newcastle fans think? If you think it's alright that Saudi Arabia own your team then you're really not someone with enough intelligence to pay any heed to.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Grumbles 09 Apr 22 2.54pm

Originally posted by monkey

I thought Newcastle were just a s*** team in Hartlepool

Being a monkey you should know.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 09 Apr 22 3.28pm

We have sent a reply to them . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Apr 22 3.39pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Does anyone seriously care what Newcastle fans think? If you think it's alright that Saudi Arabia own your team then you're really not someone with enough intelligence to pay any heed to.

This country exports close on £8billion of goods and services to Saudi every year so I think that their ownership of a football club here is pretty small beer in comparison

 

peterg Flag Anerley 09 Apr 22 4.09pm

What a bizarre article. All over the place.
Ironically, I have usually enjoyed meeting and joshing with the Toon fans on their way to the Palace. Did so this time again, when one of them came into the craft beer shop near the clocktower and ordered four pints of lager.

 


The right place at the right time

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Apr 22 5.07pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This country exports close on £8billion of goods and services to Saudi every year so I think that their ownership of a football club here is pretty small beer in comparison

I'm not asking any country to do no business with Saudi Arabia, just pointing out that if fans can see nothing wrong with the ownership, then they're not worth worrying about.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Apr 22 7.49pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

We have sent a reply to them . . . [Link]

We? Palace Si does not speak for me or I doubt ‘’most Palace fans’’ as he claims. And the Palace fans I’ve ‘’spoken to’’ don’t wish them well. They think it’s a disgrace it’s been allowed.

 


COYP

sydtheeagle Flag England 09 Apr 22 8.53pm

I think as a club we probably particularly irritate a certain level of opposing supporters. Teams that are actually big and, mostly have had some success (Man C, Man U, Liverpool, Chelsea, Spurs, Arsenal) really don't care about us. Teams that struggle (obvious rivals aside) really don't care either. But teams that think they're big but clearly aren't (Newcastle, Everton, etc.) probably do get pissed off when we get attention that they think is theirs by God-given right. That's the way those sorts of clubs think. They can't change the fact that they lose everything ON the pitch because they're s***e, but when a club like Palace start taking over where they think should rank off the pitch too, well, they start to moan. Palace basking in the limelight is probably too much for a small, regional club that has a few noisy supporters of its own to deal with.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Apr 22 9.31pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I think as a club we probably particularly irritate a certain level of opposing supporters. Teams that are actually big and, mostly have had some success (Man C, Man U, Liverpool, Chelsea, Spurs, Arsenal) really don't care about us. Teams that struggle (obvious rivals aside) really don't care either. But teams that think they're big but clearly aren't (Newcastle, Everton, etc.) probably do get pissed off when we get attention that they think is theirs by God-given right. That's the way those sorts of clubs think. They can't change the fact that they lose everything ON the pitch because they're s***e, but when a club like Palace start taking over where they think should rank off the pitch too, well, they start to moan. Palace basking in the limelight is probably too much for a small, regional club that has a few noisy supporters of its own to deal with.

Reading used to p1ss me off when we played them, which might be comparable, but that was because of their misplaced arrogance. Difference is we could’ve been where we are now a few times whereas they are a rugby town, if that.

 


COYP

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 09 Apr 22 11.46pm

I’ve lived up here for the past five years. Most blokes in Newcastle are into football - there’s f all else going on - and most support Newcastle or Sunderland. There are v few plastic Man U etc fans. This cultivates and exaggerates their level of support when things are going well, and creates widespread intolerance and abuse when they aren’t winning. Newcastle fans can’t stand that they haven’t won a trophy for over 50 years, they only see the big 6 as having any right to be doing better than them. The article in the mag on Palace - you could substitute any of Leicester, Brighton, Villa, Wolves. They do know how to drink beer and eat chips like you wouldn’t believe.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 10 Apr 22 3.02am

Originally posted by eagleman13

We have sent a reply to them . . . [Link]

He didn't hang about!

 

CPFC Dartford Flag Dartford 10 Apr 22 9.36am

Jealousy, plain and simple. If we were in the Championship they wouldn’t even mention us. We are seen now as stepping on their toes and they don’t like it. I have a Geordie mate and it will absolutely irate him if we win the cup, purely for the fact that they haven’t, in his lifetime anyway. West Ham are the same! Personally I am absolutely loving it, we are heading for something very special and no one likes it!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Apr 22 11.48am

The Mag now comes up everyday on my feed. How nice for me.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 12 Apr 22 5.57pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

[Link]

Corrr, what a funny, pathetic & nit picky article.

Made me chuckle.

Not sure why this geordie hates us but a lot of meandering nonsense

Honoured that my quotes made his dross rambling article. However, he has conveniently left out a sentence to suit his narrative.

The Toon loon seems to have missed the point of the banner and instead goes on about how large their support is compared to ours - which everyone knows anyway. The away game next week is a dead rubber for both teams, it's a lot of money and time off to travel up and I can't imagine there are many Palace fans outside of SE London/Surrey. Good effort on those who are making the trek.

The way their fans celebrated receipt of the blood money was shameful and they can enjoy their hollow success along with Chelsea and City. Great to oust Mike Ashley, but at what cost? -is this honestly better? If we can ever win a cup it will mean so much more.

At least the likes of Manure and Liverpool have earned their right at the top through sustained periods of success on the pitch. Newcastle are a club I used to admire.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Apr 22 6.48pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Honoured that my quotes made his dross rambling article. However, he has conveniently left out a sentence to suit his narrative.

The Toon loon seems to have missed the point of the banner and instead goes on about how large their support is compared to ours - which everyone knows anyway. The away game next week is a dead rubber for both teams, it's a lot of money and time off to travel up and I can't imagine there are many Palace fans outside of SE London/Surrey. Good effort on those who are making the trek.

The way their fans celebrated receipt of the blood money was shameful and they can enjoy their hollow success along with Chelsea and City. Great to oust Mike Ashley, but at what cost? -is this honestly better? If we can ever win a cup it will mean so much more.

At least the likes of Manure and Liverpool have earned their right at the top through sustained periods of success on the pitch. Newcastle are a club I used to admire.

That's a huge assumption.

Unless we are assuming PL survival is the marker of success for Newcastle... which actually it may well be.

Do love the fact of 'how large their support is compared to ours' - I was under the impression that South East London and a few surrounding areas, with other professional football clubs in close proximity, in the same city as Chelsea, West Ham, Tottenham and Arsenal etc, was of far greater pull than almost the entire North East save a few stray Sunderland, perhaps Boro and the ubiquitous Manure fans

I like Newcastle, quite genuinely, but I do feel sorry for them in a way. I really can't see this working out too well for them. They've always had a good soul as a club and fanbase but that has been sold for blood money. I look forward, if in the event any success does actually come their way, to seeing hoards of international and 'tourist' fans replace the seats of your average working class Geordie at St. James' Park whilst they face the threat of liquidation and at best a severe plummet should their cash pipeline be withdrawn for a number of possible reasons.

But, to be fair and honest, at the end of the day, I actually don't give a monkey's! I prefer to concentrate on my own club as opposed to others and que sera sera for everyone else. COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Noz Flag North Hampshire 13 Apr 22 9.12am

A very low-brow diatribe.

An article that begins with an oxymoron gets little credence from me.

"Or at the very least a very sizeable minority of the Crystal Palace fans."

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 13 Apr 22 9.42am

Its that poorly written its a wonder it even got published .

Talks a lot about attendances when at the same time says Newcastle is 100 miles away from their nearest premier league opponents . Did it not dawn on him thats probably why they fill their ground every week ? Not that we dont of course with 7 clubs within 50 miles .

Still ......Newcastle is a great away game , one of my favourites that normally turns into a weekend bender (Im getting a bit old for all that now but the spirit for it is still there ) The fans are great ,the bars are great . The grounds OK though we are normally up in the gods which is a bit naff.
But , Im not missing two days off work to go up there on a wednesday night for a nothing game .

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Mag- Palace hate article