You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.
November 16 2026 3.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Elpis Flag In a pub 13 Apr 22 10.16am

Favourite Peter Taylor
Dislike Ismael
Grower Doris (he was a crap CF but a brilliant FB )
overated Brolin
underated Cannon (how he didnt get scotland caps ? )
GOAT Wilf

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 13 Apr 22 1.39pm

Favourite Geoff Thomas
Dislike Steve Claridge
Grower Mateta
Over rated Hungarian "Wayne Rooney" whose name escapes me. He was that good.
Under rated Martin Kelly
GOAT Wilf

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Apr 22 1.57pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Favourite Geoff Thomas
Dislike Steve Claridge
Grower Mateta
Over rated Hungarian "Wayne Rooney" whose name escapes me. He was that good.
Under rated Martin Kelly
GOAT Wilf

Sandor Torghelle!!!

The old man has never let that go

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

KAOS Flag In a tree 13 Apr 22 3.30pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Dougie Freedman

Palace Player I dislike: Neil Ruddock ... one of life's grade A divs!

Palace Player that grew on me: Been a few, but, dare I say it, has to be AJ as wasn't convinced when he first joined at all.

Most overrated Palace Player: Brolin when he played for us! A complete mess ...

Most underrated Palace Player: Anton Otulakowski ... only played a handful of games, but always looked so accomplished ...

The G.O.A.T.: Wilf! Would love us to win the FA cup so he finally wins something too ...

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 13 Apr 22 3.50pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Jules - true legend of the club!
Palace Player I dislike: Adebayor - useless lump who we paid a fortune to do almost nothing. He then moaned coming here was a mistake which was such a knobbish thing to say! (Special mention to John Oster too..)
Palace Player that grew on me: Alan Lee - Could be absolutely awful at times but scored some huge goals when we were in admin.
Most overrated Palace Player: Kuqi!
Most underrated Palace Player: Kouyate seems to go under the radar an awful lot. Also is it me or was Marco Reich under appreciated??
The G.O.A.T.: It's got to be Wilf hasn't it?!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Apr 22 3.56pm

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Jules - true legend of the club!
Palace Player I dislike: Adebayor - useless lump who we paid a fortune to do almost nothing. He then moaned coming here was a mistake which was such a knobbish thing to say! (Special mention to John Oster too..)
Palace Player that grew on me: Alan Lee - Could be absolutely awful at times but scored some huge goals when we were in admin.
Most overrated Palace Player: Kuqi!
Most underrated Palace Player: Kouyate seems to go under the radar an awful lot. Also is it me or was Marco Reich under appreciated??
The G.O.A.T.: It's got to be Wilf hasn't it?!

I will grovel for forgiveness should I be wrong but was his first goal vs Coventry? A late winner?

I have a distinct memory of putting the game on the radio after coming home late, with only a few mins to go, and hearing the commentator gushing about a late goal from a Marci Reich! I hung my head in despair having never heard of him, let alone that we'd signed him and indeed won the match!

I think I also recall he had a solitary German Cap, which for me, at the time, made him a God amongst men in our team!

Bot sure he was underrated, I certainly thought he was very good but may be wrong.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Apr 22 6.29pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I will grovel for forgiveness should I be wrong but was his first goal vs Coventry? A late winner?

I have a distinct memory of putting the game on the radio after coming home late, with only a few mins to go, and hearing the commentator gushing about a late goal from a Marci Reich! I hung my head in despair having never heard of him, let alone that we'd signed him and indeed won the match!

I think I also recall he had a solitary German Cap, which for me, at the time, made him a God amongst men in our team!

Bot sure he was underrated, I certainly thought he was very good but may be wrong.

He scored the winner against Liverpool in the League Cup and we had a bit of a run. That's probably his most famous moment for us.

 


Red and Blue Army!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 Apr 22 1.29am

Originally posted by KAOS


Palace Player that grew on me: Been a few, but, dare I say it, has to be AJ as wasn't convinced when he first joined at all.

...

Good shout this one Kaos mate, he was even known as ‘fast but useless’ in his early days, little did we know.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 14 Apr 22 5.14am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Saw this trending on twitter, although it was used for 'Rappers', 'NBA/NFL/MLB players' etc and thought it ridiculous not one yank had thought to do one for Palace Players!

Give it a go if you've got a spare few mins today, bit of fun and would of course be interested to see. Going to once more expose my relative youth here, but I'll give it a go for now and may come back with a revised version that I've given more than 5 mins to...


Favourite Palace Player of all time: Aki Riihilahti

Palace Player I dislike: Tom Soares, always thought he was 5H!T!!

Palace Player that grew on me: Neil Danns (Had never herd of him previously)

Most overrated Palace Player: I fear it may be AWB but will go with Tom Soares again or very possibly John Bostock (who?... exactly)

Most underrated Palace Player: Joonas Kolkka, thought he was superb! Wish he'd stayed longer

The G.O.A.T.: Has to be Wilf, surely? He's long dethroned AJ for me (in my lifetime).

Fav player: I had a soft spot for Andy Linighan but it's got to be Freedman.

Disliked: Won't say his name, striker, loaned from city by Pardew.. expensive loser.

Grew on me: Speroni

Overrated: Has to be AWB, that price tag was not justified, seemed a nice guy though.

Underrated: Kouyate - immense player.

GOAT: I think Martyn was a champion all rounder...

 


This was once a quality forum....

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 14 Apr 22 11.55am

Favourite Palace Player of all time: John Jackson

Palace Player I dislike: Shefki Kuqi....couldn't abide the bloke
Palace Player that grew on me: Doris
Most overrated Palace Player: Meyer
Most underrated Palace Player: Phil Hoadley
The G.O.A.T.: Wilf

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 14 Apr 22 12.17pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: John Salako
Palace Player I dislike: Wayne Routledge
Palace Player that grew on me: Claude Davis
Most overrated Palace Player: Wilf Zaha
Most underrated Palace Player: Paul Williams (granted I was a child but in my eyes his link-up and support play with Chris Armstrong was wonderful)
The G.O.A.T: Ian Wright

I've probably missed some but didn't want to overthink it

 

Skip Flag 14 Apr 22 1.14pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Ian Wright
Palace Player I dislike: Craig Harrison
Palace Player that grew on me: KG
Most overrated Palace Player: John Macken
Most underrated Palace Player: Kevin Mabbutt
The G.O.A.T: Geoff Thomas

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 15 Apr 22 9.06am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

Favourite Palace Player of all time: John Salako
Palace Player I dislike: Wayne Routledge
Palace Player that grew on me: Claude Davis
Most overrated Palace Player: Wilf Zaha
Most underrated Palace Player: Paul Williams (granted I was a child but in my eyes his link-up and support play with Chris Armstrong was wonderful)
The G.O.A.T: Ian Wright

I've probably missed some but didn't want to overthink it

I have to say, I know he was a f*** up waiting to happen, but loved big Claude Davis, he was a real beast and such a massive presence at the back. Sitting behind the goal I could always see the fear in whoever he was marking at corners

Edited by monkey (15 Apr 2022 9.07am)

 

Nubes Flag London 16 Apr 22 12.53pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Clinton Morrison

Palace player I dislike: Neil Ruddock

Palace player that grew on me: Bruce Dyer

Most overrated Palace Player: Simon Rodger

Most underrated Palace Player: Bobby Bowry

The G.O.A.T: Wilf

 

AshfordEagle94 Flag Canterbury 16 Apr 22 1.21pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Dougie Freedman

Palace player I dislike: Scott Flinders

Palace player that grew on me: Jordan Ayew

Most overrated Palace Player: Ben Watson

Most underrated Palace Player: Aki Riihilahti

The G.O.A.T: Speroni

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.