You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Odsonne Edouard
November 16 2026 3.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Odsonne Edouard


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 21 Apr 22 8.46am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

He's starting tonight, so we'll see how he gets on.

Comments please. For me, I just couldn't get a stable stream so can't. But I was still surprised JPM didn't start.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Apr 22 8.55am

Difficult to pass judgement on him last night given that it was his first start in quite a while and coming into a group of players that looked like they were still not over Sunday's disappointment.

This season has passed him by somewhat. Hopefully he will learn from it and improve.

I'm still not certain of where he is most effective, and I'm not convinced that PV is either.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Elpis Flag In a pub 21 Apr 22 9.35am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Difficult to pass judgement on him last night given that it was his first start in quite a while and coming into a group of players that looked like they were still not over Sunday's disappointment.

This season has passed him by somewhat. Hopefully he will learn from it and improve.

I'm still not certain of where he is most effective, and I'm not convinced that PV is either.

Thats the problem with players who can play in a variety of positions , they normally end up where Edouard finds himself most of the time

On the bench .

Edouard is a support striker for me and would flourish playing in a two . Hes not a winger and hes not a lone striker nor a midfielder .
That would mean Vieria changing his prefered formation though .

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Apr 22 1.08pm

Thought he grew into it yesterday, as did the team - anonymous first half but had some moments in the second.

He clearly has quality; the way he receives the ball in tight spaces and some of the turns he pulls off are clearly beyond the talents of Benteke or Mateta, but he doesn't impact the game as much, certainly not as Mateta.

I'd definitely want to hang onto him - there's clearly a talented player there with an eye for a goal.. if it takes a while to figure out how best to utilise him, I think there is enough there to persist with him.

 

paulkida Flag Nuneaton 21 Apr 22 4.18pm

You see many supporters stating he's not strong enough to play centrally in the premier league for us.

Was never an issue for Andy Johnson, you have to play to their strengths, we lumped it long a lot yesterday and he can't hold it up like Benteke/Mateta or Murray used to.

He had probably one chance facing the goal and didn't connect with it. So far I haven't been overly impressed with him, doesn't seem lightning quick, not strong or tall, his touch isn't the best, hard to see what the best option for him is. I guess we would need to be creating lots of chances for him to score 1-2 a match. We aren't doing that at the moment.

All is not lost.. he needs a run of games at least. But I would also like Mateta to play as he has looked most likely to score from all our strikers.

 


GGGGGG...Granville

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Apr 22 4.29pm

I'm still of the opinion Edouard is your typical 'glory-hunting', 'goal-hanging' poacher mould.

That is not a derogatory statement by any means from me, 'tis an art in itself and a highly effective one if mastered.

The problem for me is Edouard played in a decent Celtic team, in a league and against teams for which my Nan could bag 15 goals a season and she's been dead for some time now.

All jokes and Scottish football digs aside, he obviously has something to bring however the step up to the PL was always going to be a difficult one, alongside the adaptation to a different styles of play to the aforementioned. For me, he looks overwhelmed and not up to the task.

I say that with no resentment or anger at all, that's just my take on it.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

dg1937 Flag 21 Apr 22 4.52pm

Fair comment, Nicholas91. I think his best moments have been when he cuts in from the left. I think he has decent close control and an eye for goal. I'm not convinced he has what it takes to play in the centre and, currently, I think JPM looks better in that role.

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Apr 22 4.53pm

Edouard looked like he could be the answer in the early part of the season. He pressed well, abetted by Gallagher, looked mobile and made good runs in the penalty area.
He also showed promise on the left of the attack.
However, in recent months he’s had very limited opportunities so it’s perhaps unfair to be too harsh on the fact that he has not impressed on these limited opportunities.
Perhaps he’s lost confidence and/or has not impressed in training.
He’s criticised for not leading the line properly, not being physical enough and being more of a poacher than all round centre forward.
And yet the same accusations could be levelled against the chap we’re linked with as a possible replacement -Nketiah.
If people are expecting him to lead the line, win the ball in the air and challenge physical centre halves they are likely to be disappointed.
I don’t see that much difference between Edouard and Nkethia.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Apr 22 6.19pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Fair comment, Nicholas91. I think his best moments have been when he cuts in from the left. I think he has decent close control and an eye for goal. I'm not convinced he has what it takes to play in the centre and, currently, I think JPM looks better in that role.

No I do get your comment, my thinking was geared more towards I would suggest we bought him as a striker, not as a winger and were we looking to invest in a winger we'd of gone for a different player. I'm not discounting the possibility of being completely wrong here although I'd of thought we already had Zaha way beyond nailed in for that spot for the time being and if looking for one, we'd have gone for a verified left winger, not for someone plying their trade as a forward in Scotland... does that make sense? I lose track of my own thoughts sometimes!

May also just be my own knowledge failing me here too, but I very much saw the summer recruitment as Wilf, Edouard, Benteke or Mateta and Olise starting up front. Granted, Edouard may have been bought as a bit more of a utility forward player for the sake of options in which case I'd argue we are still looking for that nailed on, first name on the team sheet forward. Agree Mateta looks the better option of what we currently have.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

dg1937 Flag 21 Apr 22 9.13pm

I agree with your point that if we wanted a winger we should have bought a winger.

Yes, Mateta and Edouard could maybe function as a two up top. Trouble is, PV hasn't favoured that system yet.

I do think a flexible horses for courses approach would be a sign of growing maturity and confidence. People criticised PV for changing the formula on Sunday but it worked, up to a point, in the first half and, fine margins, if Kouyate's shot had gone in instead of hitting the post... Teams should be able to play more than one system.

For whatever reason Edouard hasn't quite clicked yet but he is young and I personally think he will come good.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 25 Apr 22 10.38pm

Clearly PV doesn’t rate him.

 


Bring back Brolin

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 25 Apr 22 11.25pm

But where does he play in that side. Olise came on for Ayew and did well. Benteke came on for JP and also did well. He isn’t going to displace Wilf.
His best performances have been when Wilf was at Afcon playing on the left. He needs to be patient. He will get opportunities going forward and will need to take them.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 26 Apr 22 4.05am

OE is always on the bench, so you think, "If he could only get into a match, he could do something." Then he gets into a match and does nothing. Every time.

In my opinion, it was good to take a chance on him, but it hasn't worked out, so time to move on. There's nothing worse than sticking with a failed striker for years, like Wickham or Benteke.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 26 Apr 22 6.31am

Originally posted by dg1937

I agree with your point that if we wanted a winger we should have bought a winger.

Yes, Mateta and Edouard could maybe function as a two up top. Trouble is, PV hasn't favoured that system yet.

I do think a flexible horses for courses approach would be a sign of growing maturity and confidence. People criticised PV for changing the formula on Sunday but it worked, up to a point, in the first half and, fine margins, if Kouyate's shot had gone in instead of hitting the post... Teams should be able to play more than one system.

For whatever reason Edouard hasn't quite clicked yet but he is young and I personally think he will come good.

I agree with that when they had a chance of being on the pitch at the sametime they look comfortable with each other and work well together , but im old school love the idea of 2 strikers 2 wingers

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Odsonne Edouard