This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
If Brighty didn’t advise to sell Murray and Pardew couldn’t wait to flog him we would’ve had a perfectly good lone striker for quite a while. We wouldn’t have bought Benteke or all the other sh1t loaned in or bought on the cheap because all the Benteke eggs in one basket smashed after injury/Hodgson not utilising Benteke properly. He still missed chances he should’ve scored but he wasn’t suited to little involvement while needing to score after a few touches over the course of 85 minutes. We could’ve replaced like for like by preparing for it. I think Parish has learned from this kind of mistake. i agree Tekkers was an expensive mistake but it was the purchase of Wickham that led to Murray's departure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
It's an interesting observation, but I think we just need shift how the striker is judged in this type of system.. you're right we're not going to find someone who can do the hard bits while also coming up with 20+ goals, but in theory this system allows us to get our most dangerous players (Wilf + Olise) receiving the ball in better areas. Liverpool are the best example; say before Jota & Diaz came along, Firmino played every game and struggled to score 15 a season, but Salah & Mane were able to contribute north of 20 goals each from the wide positions by virtue of being higher up the pitch. Not for one minute suggesting we're going to get 60 odd goals out of Wilf and Olise, but in theory it's about getting our most dangerous players into dangerous positions as often as we can. I absolutely agree there. I do feel as though we have been caught between the 'big man' and the 'finisher' up front recently - buying players that match one of these conditions but then let us down on the other. I think it would take some genius and slice of luck to find/scout/procure the exact right fit. Also, and I do love him dearly, but can't help but feel the deity like figure of Wilf, on whom we were so dependant, is no longer able to live up to that expectation. Hence pondering if we will see a change in tact? Olise is very promising and even now good for me however would question whether the whole team and style of play can be built around him? PV seems very much more the 'whole team' kind of manager as opposed to 'make sure we're defensively sound and rely on Wilf or occasionally someone else to conjure something down the other end' and again maybe we will see a change in formation?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I absolutely agree there. I do feel as though we have been caught between the 'big man' and the 'finisher' up front recently - buying players that match one of these conditions but then let us down on the other. I think it would take some genius and slice of luck to find/scout/procure the exact right fit. Also, and I do love him dearly, but can't help but feel the deity like figure of Wilf, on whom we were so dependant, is no longer able to live up to that expectation. Hence pondering if we will see a change in tact? Olise is very promising and even now good for me however would question whether the whole team and style of play can be built around him? PV seems very much more the 'whole team' kind of manager as opposed to 'make sure we're defensively sound and rely on Wilf or occasionally someone else to conjure something down the other end' and again maybe we will see a change in formation? I think most teams at our level are in that boat - Dwight Gayle's career is probably a good example of it.. scored goals for fun in the Championship, still a decent goalscorer at Prem level, but not quite prolific enough to justify a place in a starting line-up. It's also relevant that most teams trying to survive in the Prem can only really get away with playing one striker, so 'luxury' options like Gayle start too look very hard to accommodate. I think you're being a bit harsh on Wilf - for me, he's still far and away our best finisher and creator and still the person I want to see on the ball as often as possible in the final third. For all his flaws (of which there are plenty), I think some probably still underappreciate quite how good he is for our level. I have to say I think Olise is talented enough to warrant building a team to make him as effective as possible - with him and Wilf playing on opposite flanks (which I think has only actually happened a handful of times this season, somehow) we have two genuinely dangerous wide men that will cause most defences problems - I think those two are our 'USP' or the stand-out bits of our squad you'd build around... most bottom half teams don't have final third players half as impactful.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
4-3-3 is very effective if you have 5 outstanding forwards like Liverpool and they are devastating on the counter attack whatever the selection. I think 4-3-3 is the most effective for our players - any time we've deviated from it this season, it has not gone well. I'd argue all of Mitchell, Ward, Gallagher, Wilf, Olise and arguably Eze are at their best in a 4-3-3, which is the bulk of our best players. Edouard is the only one who jumps out to me as a bad fit for our system at the moment.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think 4-3-3 is the most effective for our players - any time we've deviated from it this season, it has not gone well. I'd argue all of Mitchell, Ward, Gallagher, Wilf, Olise and arguably Eze are at their best in a 4-3-3, which is the bulk of our best players. Edouard is the only one who jumps out to me as a bad fit for our system at the moment. Team for tonight? Guiata, Clyne Andersen Guehi Ward Gallagher MacArthur Eze Ayew Mateta Zaha
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Team for tonight? Guiata, Clyne Andersen Guehi Ward Gallagher MacArthur Eze Ayew Mateta Zaha I don't know what to expect tonight if I'm honest... if Mitchell is out I've half a feeling we'll end up with Schlupp at wing-back or something similar. Ayew was woeful against Newcastle, but his work rate quite suits matching up against Leeds. I get the impression PV wants to give Eze and Edouard opportunities before the end of the season, but both would concern me a touch against a high-intensity side like Leeds. Macca has absolutely earned himself a start with the performance the other night - expect he'll be in whatever the system.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don't know what to expect tonight if I'm honest... if Mitchell is out I've half a feeling we'll end up with Schlupp at wing-back or something similar. Ayew was woeful against Newcastle, but his work rate quite suits matching up against Leeds. I get the impression PV wants to give Eze and Edouard opportunities before the end of the season, but both would concern me a touch against a high-intensity side like Leeds. Macca has absolutely earned himself a start with the performance the other night - expect he'll be in whatever the system.
Good team. Think Schlupp should be LB/wing back. Mateta will play I suspect but I for one, would like to see Eduoard given more game time. Edited by Spiderman (25 Apr 2022 5.09pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.