You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your BEST 11 and subs for 23
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your BEST 11 and subs for 23


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 24 Jul 22 4.44pm

Based on playing 3 at the back for most of pre season I think it could be something like this. I wouldn't be disappointed but it's bloody hard trying to choose a bench.

lineup (1).png Attachment: lineup (1).png (134.19Kb)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 24 Jul 22 5.12pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

Based on playing 3 at the back for most of pre season I think it could be something like this. I wouldn't be disappointed but it's bloody hard trying to choose a bench.

We never started 3 at the back for any game i saw.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

PatrickA Flag London 24 Jul 22 7.09pm

Eze lined up on the right of a front 3 in the second half yesterday, occasionally interchanging position with Schlupp.
In the likely early season absence of Olise, and taking into account our tough early fixtures, it wouldn't surprise me if Vieira started Eze in a nominal front 3, but with some freedom to roam.
This would allow a more compact and competitive midfield 3 in the early fixtures.
I'm not sure this gets the best out of Eze, but there is a conservative side to Vieira against the top teams which makes me think he won't want to be overrun in midfield.
I'm not suggesting this would be permanent, but just against the better teams.
If not this Vieira could employ Zaha as the central striker as hr has also done previously which again allows a more compact midfield.


Originally posted by Casual

I like JPM, Zaha, Olise and Eze in the same team, but can’t see it being used often, only against the weaker teams at home.
Swapping Eze for Connor makes us weaker defensively.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 24 Jul 22 7.44pm

Just to clear something up, Richard's primary position is LEFT-sided centre back (although he is two-footed). If there were no other considerations, it's Guehi's place for which he'd naturally contend (and he is not going to displace Guehi, before anyone puts words in my mouth).

My guess is that Richards' appeal is two-fold. First, beyond Andersson and Guehi we are thin at centre half (not least given Tomkins' age and injury history) and we were relatively lucky last year that our CBs went through an entire season virtually injury-free. If that luck doesn't hold, Richards can step in for either of Guehi or Andersson without weakening the team.

Secondly, I think while it won't be our primary tactic, there are times this season (certain games that may call for it) when we will play three (centre halves) at the back. Vieira has already indicated that if he has the players, this approach sometimes fits. So I think Guehi-Andersson-Richards will see the light of day, if not every week.

Lastly, Richards' is extremely athletic and at a pinch, could play fullback as an injury sub. But he's not the answer at either left back or right back at least for now. Lack of positional awareness and rashness in the tackle are arguably the weakest parts of his game at present and those are shortcomings that would be badly exposed at full-back.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 24 Jul 22 8.06pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

We never started 3 at the back for any game i saw.

My fault. I meant based on talk of playing 3 at the back for most of pre season. And bringing Richards in I cant see him sitting on the bench or Viera dropping Clyne. But saying that if we was going for 3 at the back he would of tried it out in the friendlies so Im probably talking sh1t.
Maybe this then

lineup.png Attachment: lineup.png (136.52Kb)

 

Living In Hope Flag Petersfield 24 Jul 22 9.26pm

Johnstone
Clyne Anderson Guehi Mitchell
Doucoure Hughes
Olise Eze Zaha
Edouard

Not so sure about picking Edouard but I think there is ability there, not sure why it isn't happening for him. I previously said that I feel Mateta is not Premier League standard, but I am still open-minded on this as he is a nightmare to mark, but he just looks as if he belongs in a lower league. Hoping maybe Plange will forge ahead of both. McArthur (for Hughes) great but now quite old and injury prone. Also hope Ferguson will find fitness and challenge Clyne. I know nothing about Richards yet. Also I assume Ebiowei will not be 1st team for a year or two, but not seen enough to properly judge.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 Jul 22 9.35pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Why do you think Edouard will play at CF as he hasn't even played one minute in that position on the overseas tour.

The question wasn't 'who do you think PV will pick'. It was YOUR best 11. And like me, the poster obviously believes that currently, Eduoard is the best option we have up top.

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 24 Jul 22 11.57pm

Some thoughts being expressed about Mateta over Eduoard. My opinion: I LOVE Mateta's determination, drive and desperation to score goals. Wherever he maybe at skills wise at present, if he maintains that same drive that he did consistently last season, surely he has to break through and become a regular EPL goal-scorer? His positive attitude and hunger must be infectious for the whole team. I also note Eduoard's continuing drive to score more goals and it was his desperate midfield pass that set Ayew running with Mateta for the equaliser against QPR recently. Maybe it's not either/or. I think they're both worth keeping and present headaches for defenses. I must say that I was impressed by Schlupp's determined runs too. He edges out Hughes I think who, while quick with his feet, seems less powerful and dynamic. Just some thoughts!

 

sprites Flag Auckland 25 Jul 22 2.51am

Originally posted by Oddball2021

Some thoughts being expressed about Mateta over Eduoard. My opinion: I LOVE Mateta's determination, drive and desperation to score goals. Wherever he maybe at skills wise at present, if he maintains that same drive that he did consistently last season, surely he has to break through and become a regular EPL goal-scorer? His positive attitude and hunger must be infectious for the whole team. I also note Eduoard's continuing drive to score more goals and it was his desperate midfield pass that set Ayew running with Mateta for the equaliser against QPR recently. Maybe it's not either/or. I think they're both worth keeping and present headaches for defenses. I must say that I was impressed by Schlupp's determined runs too. He edges out Hughes I think who, while quick with his feet, seems less powerful and dynamic. Just some thoughts!

Don't think he'll ever be a consistent PL goal scorer. Just not good enough unfortunately. All the huff and puff in the world can't make up for a lack of ability.

Agree about Schlupp. Love the guy!

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 25 Jul 22 7.42am

Originally posted by sprites

The question wasn't 'who do you think PV will pick'. It was YOUR best 11. And like me, the poster obviously believes that currently, Eduoard is the best option we have up top.

Err, the OP has Mateta as CF.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Hootie121082 Flag Vrysoulles 29 Jul 22 12.41pm

Depending if we make anymore signings and seeing who we are linked to. I'd me happy with this

Guaita

Wan Bissaka Anderson Guehi Mitchell

Doucoure Gibbs White

Olise Eze Zaha

Lozano

Edited by Hootie121082 (29 Jul 2022 12.42pm)

 


FEELING GLAD ALL OVER

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Jul 22 1.08pm

Originally posted by Hootie121082

Depending if we make anymore signings and seeing who we are linked to. I'd me happy with this

Guaita

Wan Bissaka Anderson Guehi Mitchell

Doucoure Gibbs White

Olise Eze Zaha

Lozano

Edited by Hootie121082 (29 Jul 2022 12.42pm)


With Clyne, Ward, Richards and Ferguson all able to play RB, I don't see us wasting money on AWB. We have more pressing needs in midfield IMHO, but I'm not sure Gibbs White will be the answer, especially given the price Wolves will want for him.

As for Lozano, probably too expensive for us. I see us going for Mayoral or Dieng if PV feels he needs another striker

Edited by doombear (29 Jul 2022 1.08pm)

 

Hootie121082 Flag Vrysoulles 29 Jul 22 1.31pm

Originally posted by doombear


With Clyne, Ward, Richards and Ferguson all able to play RB, I don't see us wasting money on AWB. We have more pressing needs in midfield IMHO, but I'm not sure Gibbs White will be the answer, especially given the price Wolves will want for him.

As for Lozano, probably too expensive for us. I see us going for Mayoral or Dieng if PV feels he needs another striker

Edited by doombear (29 Jul 2022 1.08pm)

You might be right about Lozano regarding the price but Mayoral would be a great signing as well. Gibbs-White I think would be a great addition but the price could be a bit too hefty for us as you quoted. If Benteke leaves I think we will definitely need another striker and I am not convinced that Edouard or Mateta are going to be firing on all cylinders, although I very much hope I am wrong. Which other CM are we being linked to at the moment who could do he job of Gallagher?

 


FEELING GLAD ALL OVER

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 29 Jul 22 1.52pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

My fault. I meant based on talk of playing 3 at the back for most of pre season. And bringing Richards in I cant see him sitting on the bench or Viera dropping Clyne. But saying that if we was going for 3 at the back he would of tried it out in the friendlies so Im probably talking sh1t.
Maybe this then

That would look awesome with Gallagher in Hughes' poz!
[Link]


Edited by Oddball2021 (29 Jul 2022 1.53pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your BEST 11 and subs for 23