You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

var


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
eaglesdare Flag 06 Sep 22 11.28pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

West Ham's goal should have stood and Newcastle's shouldn't have.s
But for Shearers pathetic rant and the Saudi's not getting what they want our one would not have made a headline.
Sheare r was an amazing player but on the tv he is a knob!

If a player tackles a player after the ball has been played is it not called a late tackle / mistimed and is a foul? In this case the Chelsea goalkeeper plays the ball but is then fouled / late tackled and is clearly hurt!

Having reviewed both Newcastle and west ham goals again I still find them both correct decision! I don't know it has been announced by the pgmol or whatever they call themselves that they were incorrect decisions. Perhaps media pressure or money?

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 07 Sep 22 7.02am

I thought the Chelsea GK let the ball get away from him, realised immediately he had made a clanger, when Bowen clipped him on the way through he saw it as a way of getting something out of the situation & exaggerated the knock in an attempt to hoodwink the ref which succeeded-

Same as Jotta did against us to win the penalty - lost the ball & jumped into Vincente to try to recover the situation, hoodwink the ref.

 

YT Flag Oxford 07 Sep 22 8.11am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Anybody else quite fancy Staveley? Surely she'd be on top steering the ship - so to speak.

I wouldn't touch her with a bargepole.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 07 Sep 22 8.21am

I haven't seen the incident yet

Dermot Gallagher had his two pennorth, saying that the Newcastle goal shouldn't have been given because of the foul on the goalie. However, the correct decision should have been a penalty in view of a foul by Mitchell just before the goalie was clattered. The decision therefore boils down to whether Mitchell did or didn't commit a foul. Gallagher thinks he did, whereas the referee, influenced by VAR, thinks he didn't.

The comment by Staveley about "we are discussing [how games are referreed] with the officials" perfectly demonstrates how the Premier League is run, for the benefit of the most wealthy and therefore influential (i.e. corruptly, as we've long suspected).

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

becky Flag over the moon 07 Sep 22 8.33am

Originally posted by YT

I haven't seen the incident yet

Dermot Gallagher had his two pennorth, saying that the Newcastle goal shouldn't have been given because of the foul on the goalie. However, the correct decision should have been a penalty in view of a foul by Mitchell just before the goalie was clattered. The decision therefore boils down to whether Mitchell did or didn't commit a foul. Gallagher thinks he did, whereas the referee, influenced by VAR, thinks he didn't.

The comment by Staveley about "we are discussing [how games are referreed] with the officials" perfectly demonstrates how the Premier League is run, for the benefit of the most wealthy and therefore influential (i.e. corruptly, as we've long suspected).

Actually, the decision boils down to were anything up to 3 N'castle players offside when the ball was played in....but no-one else is talking about that except Hol

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Sep 22 8.34am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I thought the Chelsea GK let the ball get away from him, realised immediately he had made a clanger, when Bowen clipped him on the way through he saw it as a way of getting something out of the situation & exaggerated the knock in an attempt to hoodwink the ref which succeeded-

Same as Jotta did against us to win the penalty - lost the ball & jumped into Vincente to try to recover the situation, hoodwink the ref.

IF the goal had been allowed to stand, I suspect there would have been a debate centred around the fact that Bowen made contact with the goalkeeper, he was left prostrate on the ground and was not in a position to get on his feet to block the subsequent shot !

Edited by Willo (07 Sep 2022 8.35am)

 

YT Flag Oxford 07 Sep 22 8.41am

Originally posted by becky

Actually, the decision boils down to were anything up to 3 N'castle players offside when the ball was played in....but no-one else is talking about that except Hol

As I said; I haven't seen it, so I can't comment on the potential offside either. However, I read elsewhere that the offside claim had been debunked on HOL. The fact is that VAR/the ref DIDN'T disallow the goal for offside; it was disallowed for the foul on the keeper.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Sep 22 8.45am

Originally posted by Willo

IF the goal had been allowed to stand, I suspect there would have been a debate centred around the fact that Bowen made contact with the goalkeeper, he was left prostrate on the ground and was not in a position to get on his feet to block the subsequent shot !

Edited by Willo (07 Sep 2022 8.35am)

I strongly disagree Willo.

I would like physicists, biologists et al to come out en masse and explain why a 6ft6" man was rendered incapable of arising following a faint glance from Bowen's foot. His condition of being 'prostrate' was as much a choice as anyone going to bed at night.

If you choose to kip in the middle of a football game any ire should be directed at you, not any insignificant incident you to try to justify invented dramatics.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Sep 22 8.59am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I strongly disagree Willo.

I would like physicists, biologists et al to come out en masse and explain why a 6ft6" man was rendered incapable of arising following a faint glance from Bowen's foot. His condition of being 'prostrate' was as much a choice as anyone going to bed at night.

If you choose to kip in the middle of a football game any ire should be directed at you, not any insignificant incident you to try to justify invented dramatics.

For avoidance of doubt I am not concluding that the goalkeeper was injured and it did appear having perused the replays that the contact with him was not significant, however I maintain that had the goal been allowed to stand on the back of the fact that Jarrod's boot DID make contact and the goalkeeper was prostrate on the ground there would have been howls of discontent.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 07 Sep 22 12.20pm

Originally posted by Willo

For avoidance of doubt I am not concluding that the goalkeeper was injured and it did appear having perused the replays that the contact with him was not significant, however I maintain that had the goal been allowed to stand on the back of the fact that Jarrod's boot DID make contact and the goalkeeper was prostrate on the ground there would have been howls of discontent.

I don't think so - it was play acting as bad as Jota's against us last season. Going down with a smile. Surprised Mendy didn't start laughing when the goal was disallowed.
Anyway, it's all good - West Ham lost, Moyes had a rant, he can't accept his own shortcomings. And Tuchel's been found out. Chelsea are last season's United now - barring Liverpool of course. It's great to see these big teams really f things up. Entertaining. If only Potter goes to Chelsea now, the icing on the cake.
And Newcastle's goal disallowed - exactly as the world should be. Order restored - Ukraine next and we're all hunky dory.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var