You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rules is rules aren't they?
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rules is rules aren't they?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
TheBigToePunt Flag 04 Oct 22 8.53pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Question: Ignoring Team colours.... If that was Haaland/Salah/Messi instead of Ayew, would that have constituted a Clear Goal Scoring opportunity ?

Interesting question that. I mean, obviously a world class player is more likely to score than a mediocre one, and even if you ignore the standard of the player in question, a fast attacking player is far more likely to capitalise on an opportunity than a slow defensive player is.

Where would you stop once you start differentiating? Perhaps you could factor in whether the attacking player had the ball on his stronger or weaker foot? Or what kind of form he's been in. Or if he's carrying an injury. I mean, we would all instinctively recognise the role these things play in how dangerous a chance is, but I don't believe referees can or do factor in the identity of the player.

 

KLEAGLE2 Flag Shirley 04 Oct 22 10.23pm

How often do you see a player losing the ball deliberately punch the ball away....never. Why did Silva then?
Because he damn well knew he was the last man and Ayew would be in on goal. His reaction alone surely meant the ref should have given a red.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 04 Oct 22 11.51pm

I did just post this on the match thread and only just seen this thread so I'll post it on here as well.

Now don't shoot me down here but as a qualified referee I'll give my take on the Silva incident.

Now clearly it was an obvious handball and it was what is known as a DOGSO (Denying a goal or an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity)

When you get taught about DOGSO on your referee course you're told to take into account the Distance to the goal, the Direction the attacker is travelling and the distance of the other defenders from the ball.

I'll admit this one was a tough one but taking my Palace glasses off and putting my referee glasses on Ayew was to the left hand side of the pitch. His direction of travel was to the left and not towards the goal. His distance from goal was still about 35 yards and there was another defender, apart from Silva level with him or just behind him when the foul occurred.

I think taking all that into consideration I can see why a yellow was given and not a red.

However it was a tight one I'll admit. I hope this explains things a little bit for everyone.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Oct 22 10.58am

Originally posted by KLEAGLE2

How often do you see a player losing the ball deliberately punch the ball away....never. Why did Silva then?
Because he damn well knew he was the last man and Ayew would be in on goal. His reaction alone surely meant the ref should have given a red.

You regularily see players, who have been, or think then have been fouled falling on the ball, and often using their hands in anticipation of the ref blowing the foul.
I Think this or a variation on this is what Silva was doing, except that Ayew didn't foul him - it was a valid shoulder charge (that the right term?) to win The ball.. Ayew was simply stronger than Silva.
When the Ref doesn't blow a foul, then its intentional handball.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Oct 22 11.05am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Interesting question that. I mean, obviously a world class player is more likely to score than a mediocre one, and even if you ignore the standard of the player in question, a fast attacking player is far more likely to capitalise on an opportunity than a slow defensive player is.

Where would you stop once you start differentiating? Perhaps you could factor in whether the attacking player had the ball on his stronger or weaker foot? Or what kind of form he's been in. Or if he's carrying an injury. I mean, we would all instinctively recognise the role these things play in how dangerous a chance is, but I don't believe referees can or do factor in the identity of the player.

obivously I should have added Mbappe to that list

With his speed, he could have easily reached the goal, and thus a 1on1 with the keeper before any of the covering defenders could get there.

IMHO, you cannot penalise a situation like this for one player and not another. Which way should it go?

FWIW, I don't buy into the corruption of refs - not intentionally, anyway. I just think their levels of incompetency seemingly know no bounds.
BUT (and it's a big but) the rulebook does not help them.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Oct 22 11.33am

I was out with 3 Chelsea supporting mates on Monday night.

They all thought that it should have been a red card.

If you look at it from a moral standpoint, yes it should have been. Because that was deliberate cheating. The argument about whether it denied Ayew a genuine clear goal scoring opportunity is something of a red herring in my opinion. Silva would not have known whether he had cover or not, so he resorted to the handball. And in doing so also removed any prospect of the referee playing advantage.

In this case, I don't think the punishment fit the crime. However the rule book allows otherwise.

In general, we were not fairly treated by the officials. Right from the moment that Edouard was given that early yellow card. If you watched the Leeds / Villa game the next day, Koch committed a similar foul well into the game but was not booked. Later in the match he got what should have been his second yellow. No consistency in the application of the laws by the referees has always been an issue but seems to be getting worse.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 05 Oct 22 11.42am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I was out with 3 Chelsea supporting mates on Monday night.

They all thought that it should have been a red card.

If you look at it from a moral standpoint, yes it should have been. Because that was deliberate cheating. The argument about whether it denied Ayew a genuine clear goal scoring opportunity is something of a red herring in my opinion. Silva would not have known whether he had cover or not, so he resorted to the handball. And in doing so also removed any prospect of the referee playing advantage.

In this case, I don't think the punishment fit the crime. However the rule book allows otherwise.

In general, we were not fairly treated by the officials. Right from the moment that Edouard was given that early yellow card. If you watched the Leeds / Villa game the next day, Koch committed a similar foul well into the game but was not booked. Later in the match he got what should have been his second yellow. No consistency in the application of the laws by the referees has always been an issue but seems to be getting worse.

I suggest you seek better company.

Living near Brighton then admitting to having not 1, not 2, but 3 Chelsea mates.....well, you worry me sometimes.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Oct 22 11.47am

Originally posted by mezzer

I suggest you seek better company.

Living near Brighton then admitting to having not 1, not 2, but 3 Chelsea mates.....well, you worry me sometimes.

Only sometimes ?!

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 09 Oct 22 8.50pm

Originally posted by West Stand

The interesting thing here is if the ref thought there was a “ clear goal scoring opportunity “ he almost probably would have played advantage. The fact he blew suggests that he didn’t.
Interestingly if he had played advantage irrespective of the outcome of that phase of play Silva couldn’t have been sanctioned
Irrespective heres what refs are told to factor into such incidents point one and two are the two that would tip it in my opinion

1: The distance between the offence and the goal. The closer it is to the penalty and goal areas the more likely the criteria would be satisfied. It’s not only the proximity, but also the area of the pitch, centrally in and around the penalty area is likely to satisfy the criteria, being right out on a touchline near the corner for example wouldn’t.

2: The general direction of play. If the striker has his back to goal or is side on looking to play the ball to an opponent then it will not fit the criteria for DOGSO. He needs to be in a position to be able to be about to take a shot or in the process of lining up a shot.

3: Likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball. This can be applied equally to the striker and to the defender. In relation to the striker, he does not have to have the ball actually at his feet, he could be running onto a pass from a team mate that, without the action of the defender/goalkeeper, he would have collected and had a shot on target, for example. In relation to the defender he needs to have a chance of winning the ball, for example by a clean, well timed tackle. If the striker has got away from the defender and the only means to stop him getting a shot away is to push him over or pull him back then the defender does not have any possibility of playing the ball and therefore no chance of “gaining control of the ball”.

4: The location and number of other defenders, which includes the goalkeeper. There is no set distance specified but the general rule is that if there is a covering defender or goalkeeper within range to make a tackle then the criteria for DOGSO are unlikely to be met. If the goalkeeper is stranded, has already committed to diving one way, leaving the player the opportunity to chip over him or shoot the other side of him or is the player making a last ditch tackle then the DOGSO criteria is liable to be met. If another defender, including the goalkeeper is in a close enough position to make a lawful tackle or attempt a save then the criteria will not be met.

I wonder how many attackers would convert in that position, 30 yards out, one on one... it to me, was a clear goal scoring opportunity.

Unless when they say clear, they actually mean the ball is an inch off the line and it's 100% going in.

However the word opportunity here is everything...

If Silva doesn't smack the ball away, Ayew is one on one and has a clear opportunity to score a goal... sure, he may miss the opportunity, but he has an opportunity none the less

 


This was once a quality forum....

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rules is rules aren't they?