You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bristol Rovers v Palace U21: Barton Finks
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bristol Rovers v Palace U21: Barton Finks


taylors lovechild Flag 05 Oct 22 6.56am

I saw about an hour of the game. Gordon had a few moments and Raymond once again looked tidy when he came on, but we were a bit sloppy and headless. Balmer has an insane throw on him which can reach past the penalty spot, but sadly his defending does not seem quite at the same level yet. After recent highs hopefully this will give some perspective to the lads and push them to try harder. It also highlights how far from the PL standard most of them are though.

While Barton's comments after the game [Link] seem more suited to those of a Sunday League manager rather than a professional one, we weren't great and I can understand his frustration. Do they get some kind of pay-off from the PL to play the top youth teams?

Edited by taylors lovechild (05 Oct 2022 6.57am)

 

Therealeaglestilidie Flag 05 Oct 22 7.33am

[Link]


Barton went on to expand on his thoughts.

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 05 Oct 22 7.40am

I personally think he is just peed off his 38 year old experienced player got sent off.
Think we would have been better served playing Ebiowei who is not playing first team games and maybe if we can field a couple of outfield players over age like Riedewald to make us more competitive.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 05 Oct 22 7.47am

I think he has a point. Clubs like the Gas will have a smaller equal and these matches are hardly ones to bring in sufficient income to make them worth playing. I wonder how much profit was generated last night?

It's just another trophy that is probably meaningless to everyone until you get to within a sniff of the final.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 05 Oct 22 7.51am

He's probably right in most of what he's saying. Shame he had to slate a load of kids trying to make it in the process but he is pure scum so not surprising.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 05 Oct 22 11.13am

An off night for the U21s against a stronger than expected Rovers outfit in this odd grouping.

We have Everton at home this Sunday hopefully it will be out of their system by then, quite sloppy generally.

We have great potential and with 31 games to go for the first team a few may get their opportunity, Rak-Saki etc. are out on loan.

Olise was only 19 I wouldn't say they were too young, it depends on the individual, and they are heading the PL beating Chelsea etc.

You just never know.

COYP.


 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Oct 22 11.45am

In my opinion, the most interesting point that Barton made was U21 players being so far away from the level required to play League football.

It's something that has been discussed on here before.

I still think that the best way to ready young players is to have Reserve teams where you would get a mixture of age groups. That set up also provided a better opportunity for fringe players and those returning from injury to play competitive games. The main benefit though, was to give promising young players exposure to playing proper ' mens ' football. I don't think the U21 structure does that properly.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Oct 22 12.10pm

Thinking about it, it's still really embarrassing that 38-year-old Glenn Whelan managed to get sent off when his team were 2-0 up against a youth team in a competition his manager apparently doesn't care about. He didn't seem to physically confront anyone so he must have said something pretty awful to the ref to get a red. Classy.

 

Skip Flag 05 Oct 22 1.22pm

What an absolute pr!ck. If he doesn't like the competition then why doesn't he play his youth team in it ? I haven't forgotten that he stubbed a cigar into the eye of a Man City youth player. He shouldn't be allowed anywhere near the game.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Oct 22 1.32pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In my opinion, the most interesting point that Barton made was U21 players being so far away from the level required to play League football.

It's something that has been discussed on here before.

I still think that the best way to ready young players is to have Reserve teams where you would get a mixture of age groups. That set up also provided a better opportunity for fringe players and those returning from injury to play competitive games. The main benefit though, was to give promising young players exposure to playing proper ' mens ' football. I don't think the U21 structure does that properly.

This is the crux of it.

And whilst not nice to hear, we all know that our U21 team wont all transition to the first team. Many will not transition to men's football at any level.

But even if it feels a little unfair on some of the lads, we need to field a team al season, even if only 1 or 2 have a chance of progressing.

We've all been guilty of seeing some good academy performances and presuming they are good enough, only for them to be released to the very bottom of the football pyramid

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Oct 22 1.50pm

The progress of the academy Team is extraordinary.

But it still has some way to go. The Academy was only opened a short while ago. Give it time.

BTW is Joey Barton really an oracle whose opinion is any more valid than the next twot?

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 05 Oct 22 3.55pm

He’s right really, I’ve always thought that tournament is a farce, men against boys, no surprise an under 21 side never gets anywhere near the final, they should’ve left it how it was, just league 1 and 2

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Oct 22 7.50pm

Originally posted by silvertop

The progress of the academy Team is extraordinary.

But it still has some way to go. The Academy was only opened a short while ago. Give it time.

BTW is Joey Barton really an oracle whose opinion is any more valid than the next twot?

No. But he had a decent career and is going to be better at understanding levels than us.

I guess the point isn't really a direct dig at our academy, but all academy's. Most of the kids wont make it, and playing against seasoned pros, highlights how far away they really are.

But it doesn't really mean that its not working. If we can progress just 1 player ever 2-3 years into the first team commercially that's probable ok. Especially with deals like AWB.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Oct 22 8.53pm

I'm surprised Barton could take the time off from beating up his wife to manage a side. Is he part-time?

 


Red and Blue Army!

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 05 Oct 22 9.31pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In my opinion, the most interesting point that Barton made was U21 players being so far away from the level required to play League football.

It's something that has been discussed on here before.

I still think that the best way to ready young players is to have Reserve teams where you would get a mixture of age groups. That set up also provided a better opportunity for fringe players and those returning from injury to play competitive games. The main benefit though, was to give promising young players exposure to playing proper ' mens ' football. I don't think the U21 structure does that properly.

The U21 league allows for a goalkeeper and 5 others who are over 21 to play in each team. It's not really any different to a reserve team - it's the selection each club makes that makes it so.

If we wanted to:

Johnstone

Rodney Richards Balmer Adaramola

Riedewald Milivojevic Hughes

Ebiowei Mateta Gordon

That'd be within the rules.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Oct 22 4.15am

Losing two nil to a league one side currently in the relegation zone certainly does put some perspective onto where the majority of the players are and the extent of the step up.....it levels us because we can get carried away with the fanfare.

Barton's words are harsh and crass to air so publicly and seem born from his frustration with the referee, however that doesn't mean they weren't mostly true.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Oct 2022 4.16am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Oct 22 9.17am

Originally posted by ambrose7

The U21 league allows for a goalkeeper and 5 others who are over 21 to play in each team. It's not really any different to a reserve team - it's the selection each club makes that makes it so.

If we wanted to:

Johnstone

Rodney Richards Balmer Adaramola

Riedewald Milivojevic Hughes

Ebiowei Mateta Gordon

That'd be within the rules.

It would be, but whats the purpose of the team? Sure winning is great, but the aim has to be providing a pathway to potential stars. I dont want Luka picking up his wages and blocking talent as well

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Oct 22 10.06am

Originally posted by ambrose7

The U21 league allows for a goalkeeper and 5 others who are over 21 to play in each team. It's not really any different to a reserve team - it's the selection each club makes that makes it so.

...

That applies to the U21 League as it enables clubs to give game time to first team squad members coming back from injury etc. I'm not convinced it applies to the EFL cup, though.

 

pssguy Flag 06 Oct 22 7.12pm

Man City and Liverpool are a combined 0-3 in this competition and I would not be surprised to see a couple of years down the road one or two of their players going for 20 million+ after barely playing for their first team

Only two of the side put out are over 19 and Ozoh and Rodney just 17 so plenty of time for progress

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bristol Rovers v Palace U21: Barton Finks