You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Handbaaaaaaaaaaall!!!!
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Handbaaaaaaaaaaall!!!!


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Oct 22 4.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

I garland your comments with praise for your eloquent, cerebral and rhetorical panache but with respect I do not stand four-square behind each and every point you have raised.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 4.18pm)

And that's the beauty of the game Willo and life in general. It is just my subjective opinion which is no authority nor guarantee of objective correctness whatsoever but I cannot for the life of me understand what goes through referee's heads sometimes and would most welcome an explanation from the individuals for the removal of any lingering, pernicious thoughts that may lead perhaps not myself but certainly others up false garden paths!

I have long opined the proclaimed atrocities are ineptitude as opposed to anything more malevolent and will caveat, especially in light of the criticism levelled at him from the most hard done by peoples in the history of mankind (scousers), that Michael Oliver for me is one referee I not only hold no grudge against but actually consider a very adept referee. I would not think that if I was so blindly committed to 'hating' upon the officials.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 22 5.02pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

And that's the beauty of the game Willo and life in general. It is just my subjective opinion which is no authority nor guarantee of objective correctness whatsoever but I cannot for the life of me understand what goes through referee's heads sometimes and would most welcome an explanation from the individuals for the removal of any lingering, pernicious thoughts that may lead perhaps not myself but certainly others up false garden paths!

I have long opined the proclaimed atrocities are ineptitude as opposed to anything more malevolent and will caveat, especially in light of the criticism levelled at him from the most hard done by peoples in the history of mankind (scousers), that Michael Oliver for me is one referee I not only hold no grudge against but actually consider a very adept referee. I would not think that if I was so blindly committed to 'hating' upon the officials.

Exceedingly eloquent as ever.

I have always maintained that referees, being human beings, do err from time to time having to make instant decisions in "Pressure cooker" environments but I do not accept these can be attributed to ineptitude.

Apropos referees having to explain their actions, I believe they would only be asked to do so to respond to controversial incidents and replies might even generate further controversy! They would not be asked to explain any decisions which showed them in a very positive light, accordingly there would be a lack of balance with referees only being thrust in front of the cameras when it was deemed by the media an apology was justified due to a faux-pas.

I understand the clamour for post-match explanations but there is a bigger picture.Referees already have to explain the rationale behind their thinking as part of a forensic assessment after each match.


Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 5.19pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Oct 22 5.13pm

It has been scientifically proven that refs are biased. The factors are largely psychological and multiple. Obvious things like home team comes into it. An interesting finding in our case is that refs favour successful teams, and research indicates that refs favour high reputation teams and players. It's not like we see it with our own eyes every week.
In the last match, when we were time wasting at the end, imagine that had been away at Old Trafford. We would have been penalised. So, the home advantage and Leeds being no bigger than us really (currently) meant we could get away with it.
Chelsea got all the decisions against us, by and large. Man City.
Usually, the games fit the pattern.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Oct 22 5.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

Exceedingly eloquent as ever.

I have always maintained that referees, being human beings, do err from time to time having to make instant decisions in "Pressure cooker" environments but I do not accept these can be attributed to ineptitude.

Apropos referees having to explain their actions, I believe they would only be asked to do so to respond to controversial incidents and replies might even generate further controversy! They would not be asked to explain any decisions which showed them in a very positive light, accordingly there would be a lack of balance with referees only being thrust in front of the cameras when it was deemed by the media an apology was justified.

Willo, I agree on first point entirely however with VAR now it has caused further fuel for the proverbial fire in my own humble opinion. As previously mentioned VAR is intended to relieve the pressure and subsequent fallout from a incorrect decision which would be influenced or hampered by live circumstances and the evidence so far is suggesting that hasn't happened or isn't happening as intended or desired. It must also be stated that officials, experts/pundits, fans et al as individuals or a collective will always disagree too, no matter the evidence and literature available.

Secondly, I am entirely accepting of the fact that my views on explanations and accountability are not well researched, evidenced, considerate of all variables or even entirely thought through! More of a personal desire and less the academic proposal. I have neither the time nor, due to a current bug + chest infection, energy to invest as things stand! It's more a longstanding 'beef' I've quietly held.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 22 5.25pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Willo, I agree on first point entirely however with VAR now it has caused further fuel for the proverbial fire in my own humble opinion. As previously mentioned VAR is intended to relieve the pressure and subsequent fallout from a incorrect decision which would be influenced or hampered by live circumstances and the evidence so far is suggesting that hasn't happened or isn't happening as intended or desired. It must also be stated that officials, experts/pundits, fans et al as individuals or a collective will always disagree too, no matter the evidence and literature available.

Secondly, I am entirely accepting of the fact that my views on explanations and accountability are not well researched, evidenced, considerate of all variables or even entirely thought through! More of a personal desire and less the academic proposal. I have neither the time nor, due to a current bug + chest infection, energy to invest as things stand! It's more a longstanding 'beef' I've quietly held.

Before VAR was introduced a gentleman said to me words to the effect "What will we talk about down the Public House when VAR eradicates all controversy ?" I kindly asserted that there would still be controversy due to subjective decisions that will be made as part of the VAR process.VAR was not going to be a panacea.

In bygone days there was animus directed towards the referee, now of course the referee AND VAR are subjected to fustigation !

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 5.29pm)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 10 Oct 22 5.35pm

The level of inconsistency is staggering...but not surprising when it's the same incompetent refs that the system was brought in to help, are now the ones making the decisions at VAR.

How the Rashford goal can be ruled out yet both West Ham goals involving handballs can be given. Utter joke.

And I know it's not a handball but how VAR can't see that Dawson (he will never be forgiven) cheated for the penalty is beyond me. Fulham fans must have been fuming.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Oct 22 5.35pm

Some stats on almost everything referee based, some numbers have been crunched - others plain to see. Quite revealing in some cases; some strange anomalies too. Spurs mainly.

[Link]

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 22 5.50pm

Originally posted by samprior

The level of inconsistency is staggering...but not surprising when it's the same incompetent refs that the system was brought in to help, are now the ones making the decisions at VAR.

How the Rashford goal can be ruled out yet both West Ham goals involving handballs can be given. Utter joke.

And I know it's not a handball but how VAR can't see that Dawson (he will never be forgiven) cheated for the penalty is beyond me. Fulham fans must have been fuming.

I do not believe that referees who have reached the Elite Level in the PL are "Incompetent" given the hoops they need to climb through to reach such a level.
I have witnessed referees being assessed in non-league on a regular basis as part of their journey up the 'Steps' to the pinnacle.

Indeed they will err from time to time, a charge that can be labelled at managers and players.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 5.52pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 22 6.14pm

Originally posted by samprior

The level of inconsistency is staggering...but not surprising when it's the same incompetent refs that the system was brought in to help, are now the ones making the decisions at VAR.

How the Rashford goal can be ruled out yet both West Ham goals involving handballs can be given. Utter joke.

And I know it's not a handball but how VAR can't see that Dawson (he will never be forgiven) cheated for the penalty is beyond me. Fulham fans must have been fuming.

In terms of the first incident, it was not conclusive that the ball touched the hand, the VAR studied the coverage for over 2 minutes and could not conclude with any certainty that contact was made,accordingly he could not inform the referee that an offence had been committed.

Apropos the Antonio incident, he clearly handled the ball but a goal did not result directly from the contact as Fulham players got involved with the goalkeeper saving the shot and there was a defender who also played the ball so it was viewed as a 'Reset' and a second phase.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 6.18pm)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 10 Oct 22 8.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of the first incident, it was not conclusive that the ball touched the hand, the VAR studied the coverage for over 2 minutes and could not conclude with any certainty that contact was made,accordingly he could not inform the referee that an offence had been committed.

Apropos the Antonio incident, he clearly handled the ball but a goal did not result directly from the contact as Fulham players got involved with the goalkeeper saving the shot and there was a defender who also played the ball so it was viewed as a 'Reset' and a second phase.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 6.18pm)

I think Scamaca's reaction before and after VAR told us everything we need to know. The replay clearly shows the momentum and spin of the ball change after contact with the hand.

If Antonio's was allowed then Rashford's should also be allowed as it didn't directly lead to a goal, Rashford still had to round Pickford, where he got a touch, but Rashford then slots it home.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Oct 22 9.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of the first incident, it was not conclusive that the ball touched the hand, the VAR studied the coverage for over 2 minutes and could not conclude with any certainty that contact was made,accordingly he could not inform the referee that an offence had been committed.

Apropos the Antonio incident, he clearly handled the ball but a goal did not result directly from the contact as Fulham players got involved with the goalkeeper saving the shot and there was a defender who also played the ball so it was viewed as a 'Reset' and a second phase.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 6.18pm)

I do find this rule quite staggeringly ridiculous. The next 'phase', whatever that means, cannot happen without the one preceding it... where there was a foul... which needs to be given when there's time allocated to review. Just doesn't make any logical sense to me.

In light of this however, I would like to see Guaita run down the pitch to the last man, ball in hands, throw it as hard as possible at an opposition player, perhaps even the goalie, then have 3 or 4 of our players following him, collect the ball as it bounces of said defender, and score. I'm sure if we did this last minute we could sacrifice a red card and have one player manhandle the referee so he cannot see or blow his whistle. It would then be a 'second' phase upon review of play as the ball was last played by a defender who failed to control it. RHUBARB!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

YT Flag Oxford 10 Oct 22 10.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of the first incident, it was not conclusive that the ball touched the hand, the VAR studied the coverage for over 2 minutes and could not conclude with any certainty that contact was made,accordingly he could not inform the referee that an offence had been committed.

Apropos the Antonio incident, he clearly handled the ball but a goal did not result directly from the contact as Fulham players got involved with the goalkeeper saving the shot and there was a defender who also played the ball so it was viewed as a 'Reset' and a second phase.

Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 6.18pm)

This alone demonstrates that football has completely lost the plot, when it makes stupid rules about which refereeing mistakes the cameras are allowed to correct and which they aren't. It's absolutely ludicrous and you couldn't make it up if you tried.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Oct 22 10.30pm

Originally posted by YT

This alone demonstrates that football has completely lost the plot, when it makes stupid rules about which refereeing mistakes the cameras are allowed to correct and which they aren't. It's absolutely ludicrous and you couldn't make it up if you tried.

I personally think we should have a VAR screen a bit like 'Catchphrase' where you pick 5 players, like a penalty shootout, to answer General Knowledge questions. Each correct answer provides the chance to press a button to stop on a square to reveal the picture to the referee.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 22 11.09pm

Originally posted by samprior

I think Scamaca's reaction before and after VAR told us everything we need to know. The replay clearly shows the momentum and spin of the ball change after contact with the hand.

If Antonio's was allowed then Rashford's should also be allowed as it didn't directly lead to a goal, Rashford still had to round Pickford, where he got a touch, but Rashford then slots it home.

With respect, the replay was not conclusive as to whether the ball made contact with the hand.

In relation to Antonio and Rashford, there were different factors involved and I have already articulated the rationale behind the decisions.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Oct 22 1.02am

Originally posted by Willo



With respect, the replay was not conclusive as to whether the ball made contact with the hand.

In relation to Antonio and Rashford, there were different factors involved and I have already articulated the rationale behind the decisions.

I'm afraid you're wrong on that one Willo if I recall MoTD correctly!

The ball was seen spinning down after changing direction ever so slightly from the contact where it had no spin at all beforehand. It's either witchcraft or contact.

For what it's worth, I didn't consider Scamacca to have 'controlled' the ball using his hand and think the touch was of little consequence.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

samprior Flag Hamburg 11 Oct 22 6.27am

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, the replay was not conclusive as to whether the ball made contact with the hand.

In relation to Antonio and Rashford, there were different factors involved and I have already articulated the rationale behind the decisions.

As have I. If you believe all decisions were correct then so be it.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 11 Oct 22 3.05pm


I think that we should start making kits without sleeves; and have the players run around with their arms inside their tops. Takes handball out the equation.

It will also make Ronaldo look like a leaping Salmon when going for a header.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Oct 22 5.35pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger


I think that we should start making kits without sleeves; and have the players run around with their arms inside their tops. Takes handball out the equation.

It will also make Ronaldo look like a leaping Salmon when going for a header.

Just to gain an edge a team should all get their arms surgically removed. The obvious and quick solution.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Handbaaaaaaaaaaall!!!!