You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Black Managers
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Black Managers


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 27 Oct 22 1.50pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This article is fairly standard stuff as far as the BBC sports desk is concerned nowadays; disproportionate attention to the same old subject matter, covered to a fairly low intellectual standard and exclusively through the prism of identity politics.

As others have said, if you're determined to categorise people only by their race (a preoccupation that used to be the exclusive domain of racists, but which now underpins the 'woke' philosophy) then you could just as easily point out the disproportionate number of black players, and even managers, in relation to the population, or take the same stats as evidence of a failure to launch within the 'black community' (whatever the hell that phrase even means), but of course that's not how the BBC present it.

Notwithstanding, I do take the point that as most managers are former players, the ratio of black players to managers is noticeable. What I can't abide, however, is the practice of starting with a conclusion (it's all down to racism) rather than investigating the matter objectively. We get nowhere like that, in football or wider society.

Regarding football management vacancies, my instinct is that football is too competitive and valuable an industry to deliberately restrict its own access to talent by discounting people based on race. Clubs hire and fire people from all over the world at a rate of knots in pursuit of even the slightest advantage in management, coaching, technical and support staff. Club owners come from all over the world, from lots of cultures and industries, and the idea they would all, despite their different backgrounds and fierce competition with each other nevertheless conspire to restrict opportunities for black candidates, even when those candidates might add value and give them an advantage worth tens of millions, just doesn't stack up.

Ultimately however, as with any aspect of life, we can only understand whether there is a problem if the matter is properly and scientifically investigated. How many black applicants were there for vacancies in management? What were thier scores at interview compared to other candidates? Is there a correlation showing high scores at interview but failure to get job offers? If you don't have this information then you can only guess, or worse, presume. Which leads back to the BBC.

The tragedy here is that the BBC doesn't need to be an ideological echo chamber. It doesn't have to pander to a particular political mindset, because it doesn't have to sell its product, and is still read by a range of people, if only because we've all paid for it already anyway. It could be head and shoulders above the rest of the mainstream media just because of that freedom, be the place we all go to and trust to set out not only the facts, but the contrasting ways one could assess those facts. It could raise the general standards of public discussion.

Instead we get this same old fixed-position bollocks, and more sadly still, people like Vieira, who are willing and able to articulate their thoughts, are denied access to the reasonable counter arguments that might develop thought and understanding, as are we in turn. The conversation just never happens, and we all miss out.

Excellently put.

It would be great if instead of the player vs manager percentages. We could understand where and what the barriers are.

There are countless black players who were fantastic leaders on the pitch, no reason they wouldn't make great managers. But as the big toe Punt said we need to interrogate where the issues are.

I remember a similar article from Hayden Mullins, saying the 'ratios didn't feel right'. But also not offering any insight as to how he manged to go from a player to a coach to a manager. WAs it harder because he was black, what doors were closed to him, and how to open them etc.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Oct 22 4.44pm

I don't buy into the black players need role models to get into management argument. That may apply to a black person outside of football but I don't agree it applied to players.

To become a PL player you have to have ability and much more, self belief. Many don't make it simply because they are not driven enough and get distracted by women and booze.

So the argument that a person (of any colour) made it against all the odds to become a player suddenly becomes a wallflower when it comes to management doesn't really hold true.

I don't know why black players are not becoming managers but I doubt it is a lack of self belief or even role models. If they show the same self determination that got them to be footballers they should at least get to some level coaching.


 


One more point

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Oct 22 10.16am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Excellently put.

It would be great if instead of the player vs manager percentages. We could understand where and what the barriers are.

There are countless black players who were fantastic leaders on the pitch, no reason they wouldn't make great managers. But as the big toe Punt said we need to interrogate where the issues are.

I remember a similar article from Hayden Mullins, saying the 'ratios didn't feel right'. But also not offering any insight as to how he manged to go from a player to a coach to a manager. WAs it harder because he was black, what doors were closed to him, and how to open them etc.

Without deliberately adding fuel to a hotly contested debate, but does anyone here have an idea what these barriers are? Are they institutional, are clubs or coaching courses consciously or un-consciously creating hurdles for black players to get their badges and apply for managerial jobs?

Or are there mental barriers, social pressure barriers? I fail to see that if a black player, say Raheem Sterling, goes down the usual routes a white player would do he is limited by these alleged barriers.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Oct 22 3.21pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Without deliberately adding fuel to a hotly contested debate, but does anyone here have an idea what these barriers are? Are they institutional, are clubs or coaching courses consciously or un-consciously creating hurdles for black players to get their badges and apply for managerial jobs?

Or are there mental barriers, social pressure barriers? I fail to see that if a black player, say Raheem Sterling, goes down the usual routes a white player would do he is limited by these alleged barriers.

In reality they are going to be multifaceted. And some will be binary and others difficult to articulate at all.

I'd be interested to find out about intent. Whenever this topic raises its head, you never have any express coming out saying they were blocked/prevented from perusing a career after management.

I happened to be in the same room as Claude Makelele a year or so ago. He was, and still is, working in a development role at Chelsea. I asked him if he fancied replacing Lampard, and he laughed. Why would he want the stress and pressure of that job. Developing hte kids is much more rewarding, and you're not going to get sacked!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 05 Nov 22 9.30am

A manager is really a chess player. Surely there are lots of good black chess players ? I wonder did PV ever play chess as a kid ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Black Managers