This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by VinceHilaire
Took my younger son to the Leeds game a couple of weeks ago for his 10th birthday. Got to the ground early as he was desperate to get his top autographed by as many Palace players as possible. Some of the players were naturally relaxed, chatted to my son, signed his top, took a selfie with him etc. on this point…Joel Ward is one of the most genuine, nicest players I have ever met. Once my son told him it was his birthday, he reached into his sports bag and gave him one of his training tops! Unbelievable. However, I want to focus on this thread…so when he asked Olise for his autograph, the guy never looked at my son, or smiled and seemed to be out of his comfort zone. Without doubt, he is a shy person. I guess the point is sometimes you forget how young these players really are, and don’t know how to cope with the fans/media attention they receive. His interview on Sunday was just an honest set of answers by a player who clearly has not been ‘coached’ in how to answer media questions. I agree, just a young, shy guy. Comes across as a bit aloof, however, this is often just a shield/defence mechanism. In a changing room you have different characters - some need a bollocking, some need an arm around them - Olise is clearly the latter. I think PV is managing him well
|
|
|
The interviewer asked crass questions that got the answer, they deserved
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
Anyone ever thought the interviewer was just trying to keep it as simple as possible for a lad that may be shy and handling other issues? Yeah - those questions are asked and players waffle out sound bites, but that's media training taking over. My thoughts - next time send Olise out with a pal and share the interview, we've seen many a time a player add some banter/encouragement or work on answers - the club can't set him up to fail like that again. He failed?? Olise is a valuable member of our football team. Why all this crap about teaching him to perform in front of reporters, he's a footballer and thus does his (brilliant) talk on the pitch.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
He failed?? Olise is a valuable member of our football team. Why all this crap about teaching him to perform in front of reporters, he's a footballer and thus does his (brilliant) talk on the pitch. Absolutely agree. I completely reject any notion that footballers should have some sort of 'media training' alongside their role which should only be considered in the instance they are likely to get themselves/the club in trouble for whatever reason. Yes they have a duty to conduct themselves properly given their exposure to the public however the requirement for them to 'entertain' us should be limited to the football pitch. A lot of these young players, Olise included, are very young too. If Sky et al don't think they interview well then... don't interview them!!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
I don't see that he needs any media training, if you watch the full interview. Certainly better than I would have done at his age.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
He failed?? Olise is a valuable member of our football team. Why all this crap about teaching him to perform in front of reporters, he's a footballer and thus does his (brilliant) talk on the pitch. yeah, it was a s*** interview all round... and if you think it doesn't matter, tell that to companies looking to sponsor and the money it brings - in fact, why you even on a public forum talking about the game? Just watch it, go home, live ya life, repeat
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Absolutely agree. I completely reject any notion that footballers should have some sort of 'media training' alongside their role which should only be considered in the instance they are likely to get themselves/the club in trouble for whatever reason. Yes they have a duty to conduct themselves properly given their exposure to the public however the requirement for them to 'entertain' us should be limited to the football pitch. A lot of these young players, Olise included, are very young too. If Sky et al don't think they interview well then... don't interview them!! I don’t know what the deal is with professional footballers and media work, but I know managers are obligated to speak to the media after matches. Is it possible that match winners/man of the match must do the same? - possibly for sponsorship reasons/contracts? And if so, should he address his camera issues or should he keep doing the same? My guess is that Olise will be embarrassed by the interview when he looks back at it - it was uncomfortable viewing. His football will always come first, but if he does a few more like that, people will start to think he’s a bit simple which might bring an unwanted pressure. The reality is that the media side is a part of the job most players didn’t sign up for - which is why a lot of clubs offer media training.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
I don’t know what the deal is with professional footballers and media work, but I know managers are obligated to speak to the media after matches. Is it possible that match winners/man of the match must do the same? - possibly for sponsorship reasons/contracts? And if so, should he address his camera issues or should he keep doing the same? My guess is that Olise will be embarrassed by the interview when he looks back at it - it was uncomfortable viewing. His football will always come first, but if he does a few more like that, people will start to think he’s a bit simple which might bring an unwanted pressure. The reality is that the media side is a part of the job most players didn’t sign up for - which is why a lot of clubs offer media training. I watched Olise's... I don't know what you call it - 'welcome video' when he first joined. It was documentary-esque in terms of having people that knew him provide some insight and background into his character. He either is or plays somewhat of an 'enigma' type or at the very least far removed from the conventions we may expect of footballers. He came across as the archetypal Frenchman, perhaps more suited to brooding outside a Parisian cafe in muted clothing, folded up in deep contemplation or ennui, slowly puffing on a cigarette if that conjures up some imagery. Quite frankly, it's somewhat refreshing given the usual half-witted cliches trotted out: "The gaffer just told me to go out and give it my all", "the lads gave 110%", "I just want to thank the fans" etc. I actually much prefer his demeanour, makes him more relatable for me and lends itself to his footballing style in offering something a bit different, original and of actual interest. I don't think it's because he's "a bit simple", he just doesn't conform well or parrot others as we see so often, once again, appealing to myself but I would guess plenty of others too. He may just be a bit shy, maybe even a bit arrogant or maybe just very introverted and so on. Anyhow, it's an improvement and refreshing in my eyes. If anybody wants him to read from a script for contractual obligations and that is deemed necessary for financial reasons then so be it however I for one do not support or like that position. I'd prefer to see Mickey out there reacting naturally to media questioning, if he must be put in that position, and not just offering up the usual drivel we've all become so accustom to. In any event and whatever choice he makes, he'll still have my support that's for sure.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I watched Olise's... I don't know what you call it - 'welcome video' when he first joined. It was documentary-esque in terms of having people that knew him provide some insight and background into his character. He either is or plays somewhat of an 'enigma' type or at the very least far removed from the conventions we may expect of footballers. He came across as the archetypal Frenchman, perhaps more suited to brooding outside a Parisian cafe in muted clothing, folded up in deep contemplation or ennui, slowly puffing on a cigarette if that conjures up some imagery. Quite frankly, it's somewhat refreshing given the usual half-witted cliches trotted out: "The gaffer just told me to go out and give it my all", "the lads gave 110%", "I just want to thank the fans" etc. I actually much prefer his demeanour, makes him more relatable for me and lends itself to his footballing style in offering something a bit different, original and of actual interest. I don't think it's because he's "a bit simple", he just doesn't conform well or parrot others as we see so often, once again, appealing to myself but I would guess plenty of others too. He may just be a bit shy, maybe even a bit arrogant or maybe just very introverted and so on. Anyhow, it's an improvement and refreshing in my eyes. If anybody wants him to read from a script for contractual obligations and that is deemed necessary for financial reasons then so be it however I for one do not support or like that position. I'd prefer to see Mickey out there reacting naturally to media questioning, if he must be put in that position, and not just offering up the usual drivel we've all become so accustom to. In any event and whatever choice he makes, he'll still have my support that's for sure. Thought this was worth a share [Link] Just hope it hasn’t become a distraction for him and it can be quickly forgotten.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
The camera was on him as fans like to get an insight form the players directly. On this occasion the interviewer asked perfectly reasonable open questions which were deserving of a better answer from someone who has just scored a 94th minute equaliser who you expect to be ecstatic. If someone can pull out the Millwall interview, on that occasion, I would agree that the questioning was poor - all closed questions which got one word responses. As Willo suggests, I think he's very uncomfortable in front of the camera which is fair enough and pretty normal, hence why he would benefit from media training. It would be a good life skill to learn.
Do knob off with your "media training" nonsense. He's a young football player not a tv personality. His job is to perform on the pitch not in front of a microphone.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
My guess is that Olise will be embarrassed by the interview when he looks back at it - it was uncomfortable viewing. His football will always come first, but if he does a few more like that, people will start to think he’s a bit simple which might bring an unwanted pressure. The reality is that the media side is a part of the job most players didn’t sign up for - which is why a lot of clubs offer media training. I couldn't disagree with you more. I don't think he'll be remotely embarrassed by the interview, now or in the future. Olise strikes me as more intelligent and more self-possessed by far than the average footballer, and like it or not I suspect he knows exactly what he's doing. Whether it's the right or wrong way to conduct an interview is a different question; I have no doubt Michael conducted that interview the way he wanted to, after thinking about it. It seems obvious that his curt responses were designed to make a point; they were not thoughtless and off-the-cuff. The media side of the business is part of the job for the club, but not for the player. It would be true to say that a player who is media-friendly is likely to make more money through sponsorships and so on...being a camera magnet definitely benefits a player commercially. But if Olise is prepared to forego the finacial gains of being a media star and feels more comfortable without the attention then that's up to him. It's only part of his job if he wants it to be and quite clearly he doesn't. Why would he need media training if he has no interest in ever speaking to the media? I'm genuinely shocked that you took an interview that I thought was dripping in sarcasm as evidence of the player's low intelligence. I thought the opposite. My take was finally, here's a player who's actually sharp enough to see through the media and take the piss out of the interviewer with a straight face. Olise strikes me as anything but dim.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.